|
Terry, would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please?
|
00:00:05
|
|
To the flag of the United States of America.
|
00:00:12
|
|
And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
|
00:00:16
|
|
Steve, did you have somebody lined up for the?
|
00:00:31
|
|
Implication.
|
00:00:33
|
|
No, OK.
|
00:00:38
|
|
OK. Thank you.
|
00:00:40
|
|
No, that's.
|
00:00:43
|
|
OK. Good morning, everybody.
|
00:00:51
|
|
We're going to start off on two public.
|
00:00:54
|
|
Information Discussion.
|
00:00:58
|
|
To adopt A resolution #23-1-O.
|
00:01:01
|
|
Granting a 25 year franchise to Cactus state utility.
|
00:01:05
|
|
Operating Company LLC Cactus State to provide water services to Cactus State's customers in the Tunnel Village service area. And
|
00:01:12
|
|
I'm not sure who's presenting today, Mr. Chairman, I believe Samantha Trimble.
|
00:01:20
|
|
Chief Deputy Deputy Clerk of the board is on the phone and we're presenting. Good morning, Samantha. Are you are you with us
|
00:01:29
|
|
today?
|
00:01:33
|
|
Yes, Sir, I'm here. OK, good. Well, you can you can present as.
|
00:01:39
|
|
It's.
|
00:01:47
|
|
All righty. Thank you, Chairman and Board members. So as stated, Cactus State Utility Operating Company, LLC is also known as
|
00:01:50
|
|
Cactus State. So throughout my presentation, I'm going to refer to them as Cactus State.
|
00:01:56
|
|
On October 23rd, 2023, I received an application Franchise application from Caitlin Smith of Fenimore Craig, PC Law Offices on
|
00:02:04
|
|
behalf of Cactus State to provide water services to Cactus State's customers in the Tonto Village area.
|
00:02:12
|
|
Miss Smith is present to answer questions or concerns of the Board throughout this.
|
00:02:20
|
|
Sometimes. So if you guys want to talk to her about anything, we can address her. She is there. The application was reviewed by
|
00:02:26
|
|
the clerk of the Board's office and attorney Jeff Dalton. It meets all requirements of Resolution #16-12-O1 which is the
|
00:02:32
|
|
resolution that outlines regulations and procedures for all utility franchises in unincorporated Field County. If adopted by the
|
00:02:39
|
|
board, Resolution number 231107 grants a 25 year franchise to Cactus State to provide water service to the Townsville Village
|
00:02:45
|
|
area.
|
00:02:52
|
|
Within 10 days after branching, the Franchise Cactus State is required to provide me with a certificate of insurance and the
|
00:02:59
|
|
signed franchise acceptance form. In December of 2021, the Arizona Corporation Commission, ACC provided the joint application, oh
|
00:03:06
|
|
sorry, approved the joint application of Town of Village Water Company, Inc and Texas State to transfer the water utility system
|
00:03:14
|
|
assets and the certificate of convenience and necessities. So that's known as the CCNN.
|
00:03:21
|
|
To Cactus State for the council village service area.
|
00:03:29
|
|
Cactus State provides service to approximately 190 customers in the Town of Village area.
|
00:03:33
|
|
The notice of hearing was published in the Pacing Roundup newspaper. The application fee and publication fee have been paid.
|
00:03:40
|
|
I have not received any objection regarding this request. I'd be happy to answer any questions or we can address Miss Smith as
|
00:03:47
|
|
well, and a public hearing is required for this item.
|
00:03:53
|
|
OK.
|
00:04:01
|
|
Supervisor client do you have anything? I do not, I'm.
|
00:04:03
|
|
Supervisor Christianson, do you wish to ask any questions today?
|
00:04:08
|
|
Thank you. No questions, no comments. Thank you.
|
00:04:13
|
|
OK. I only have one on the 25 year franchise, is that just common to have them for 25 years or is there a reason that that's for
|
00:04:16
|
|
25 years?
|
00:04:21
|
|
Yes Sir. That's just how the county has always done it is a 25 year franchise.
|
00:04:29
|
|
OK, that's fine, Ask an answer.
|
00:04:34
|
|
All right. Then I guess supervisor client, I'll call for a motion we we need to go through the public process, OK.
|
00:04:38
|
|
I'll open it to public hearing. Does anybody have?
|
00:04:46
|
|
Anything up in patient for the public hearing?
|
00:04:50
|
|
No.
|
00:04:54
|
|
Anyone here to comment on the public hearing?
|
00:04:56
|
|
OK, I'll close the public hearing and call for a motion. Mr. Chair, I'll make the motion to adopt resolution #23-11-077.
|
00:05:01
|
|
Granting a 25 year franchise to Cactus State Utility Operating Company, LLC.
|
00:05:14
|
|
I will second that with a motion. A second all in favor. Do so by saying aye, aye.
|
00:05:21
|
|
I passed unanimous.
|
00:05:28
|
|
OK. Moving on to public hearing 2B information discussion action to adopt resolution #23-11.
|
00:05:30
|
|
Dash 08 granting a 25 year franchise to Cactus state utility.
|
00:05:39
|
|
Operating Company LLC, Cactus State to provide water services to Cactus State's customers and Christopher Creek subdivision.
|
00:05:45
|
|
And Gardner subdivision.
|
00:05:54
|
|
OK, Samantha, you're on again.
|
00:05:58
|
|
Thank you. And so I also received this franchise application for Miss Smith on October 21st, 3rd that she submitted on behalf of
|
00:06:03
|
|
Cactus State. This franchise application for Cactus State to provide water service to its customers in the Christopher Creek
|
00:06:08
|
|
Subdivision and the Gardner subdivision.
|
00:06:14
|
|
The application was reviewed by the clerk of the Board's office and Mr. Dalton. It also meets all the requirements of Resolution
|
00:06:20
|
|
#16-12-O1 and the application and publication fees have been paid so if adopted by the board, Resolution #23 Seven Dash O 8 grant
|
00:06:27
|
|
a 25 year franchise detective State to provide water service to the Christopher Creek subdivision and Gardner subdivision within
|
00:06:34
|
|
10 days after granting the franchise. Cactus State is required to provide me with a certificate of insurance.
|
00:06:42
|
|
And signed franchise acceptance.
|
00:06:49
|
|
In December 2021, this application was also approved by the ACC for the transfer of the water utility system access and the
|
00:06:52
|
|
Certificate of Convenience and necessity to Cactus State.
|
00:06:58
|
|
This utility system is comprised of two subsystems, Christopher Creek Haven and Gardner Water Systems. Christopher Creek serves
|
00:07:06
|
|
the population of 30 full time residents with 194 connections. Gardener Water Systems serve.
|
00:07:13
|
|
A full time risk of population of 30 people with 94.
|
00:07:22
|
|
The total number of connections is greater than the resident population because many residents use this area as their second home.
|
00:07:26
|
|
The notice of hearing was published in the Roundup newspaper and I have not received any objection regarding this request. And if
|
00:07:32
|
|
you have any questions, Miss Smith or I are available to answer this for you.
|
00:07:38
|
|
OK. Thank you. Samantha, Supervisor, Client, do you have any questions? Yeah, thank you. Mr. Chair. Samantha, on this, it says on
|
00:07:45
|
|
my resolution number is the same as the previous one, is that correct?
|
00:07:51
|
|
No, I think this is, this is oh wait, the other one was 07, I do believe.
|
00:08:00
|
|
OK, I got it. I got it.
|
00:08:06
|
|
OK. I'm good. That's all I had. Thank you.
|
00:08:08
|
|
All right. Supervisor Christensen, do you have any questions?
|
00:08:13
|
|
No questions. Thank you.
|
00:08:17
|
|
OK, then I will open it to the public.
|
00:08:19
|
|
For public hearing, do we have any public imp?
|
00:08:23
|
|
No.
|
00:08:26
|
|
Do we have any public here in Globe?
|
00:08:28
|
|
OK, I will close the public hearing and I'll call for a motion. Mr. Chair. I'll make the motion to adopt resolution #23-11-0.
|
00:08:32
|
|
Granting a 25 year franchise to Cactus State Utility Operating Company, LLC.
|
00:08:43
|
|
I will second that having a motion, a second all in favor. Do so by saying aye, aye.
|
00:08:50
|
|
Hi, it was passed unanimous.
|
00:08:56
|
|
Moving on to.
|
00:09:00
|
|
Regular agenda, item information, discussion, action to approve source well contracting.
|
00:09:03
|
|
Agreement number 020221 Dash AAC.
|
00:09:08
|
|
With Agile Fleet incorporated in the amount of $55,417 and 1 penny.
|
00:09:14
|
|
For.
|
00:09:22
|
|
Oh, from November 1st, 2023 through October 31st, 2024 for the Fleet Commander software program.
|
00:09:24
|
|
Good morning. I'll be standing in for Romero. He had some training he needed to attend, so.
|
00:09:34
|
|
So yeah, this software has been huge for General Services. It's really has bridged a gap that used to exist.
|
00:09:42
|
|
In the past it's been difficult sharing maintenance repair history from our north to South shop.
|
00:09:51
|
|
As well as the ease ability of tracking our repair, maintenance and fuel costs, I mean it's all on one, one place we can we can go
|
00:09:57
|
|
and view it and.
|
00:10:01
|
|
Made that so much simpler than the way we used to do it.
|
00:10:06
|
|
A new thing that we've we've started doing as of this fiscal year is we're actually using Fleet Commander as a billing tool.
|
00:10:10
|
|
So this has actually reduced the amount of time spent on these billing functions.
|
00:10:18
|
|
And actually has reduced the amount of steaks that used to be made so.
|
00:10:24
|
|
It's been big in doing that. We're also in the process and we're almost there.
|
00:10:29
|
|
We're setting up what's called Maintenance Due reminders, so in the event your vehicle is due for maintenance.
|
00:10:35
|
|
It'll alert us and we will send out an e-mail basically saying hey, it's time service come on in and that will definitely reduce
|
00:10:41
|
|
the amount of.
|
00:10:45
|
|
Overdue services that sometimes happens when you just rely on the sticker in the window.
|
00:10:51
|
|
Other than that, I'll take any questions anyone has regarding this.
|
00:10:57
|
|
Thank you Super.
|
00:11:03
|
|
Fine, I'm good. Thanks, David.
|
00:11:05
|
|
Supervisor Christians.
|
00:11:08
|
|
Do you have any questions?
|
00:11:13
|
|
Just one.
|
00:11:16
|
|
Just fine.
|
00:11:19
|
|
No questions.
|
00:11:29
|
|
OK. And I have none people I decline on call for a motion.
|
00:11:35
|
|
Mr. Chair, I'd make the motion to approve Source Well Contract Agreement number 020221, Dash AAC with Agile Fleet Incorporated in
|
00:11:39
|
|
the amount of $55,417 and 1 penny.
|
00:11:46
|
|
I will second having a motion. Second all in favor do so by saying aye, aye.
|
00:11:55
|
|
I passed unanimously. Thank you very much. Thank you. Have a good day.
|
00:12:01
|
|
OK, moving on to three.
|
00:12:05
|
|
I can't believe there's any more action, OK?
|
00:12:08
|
|
3B Information discussion regarding the role of the public fiduciary in Gila County.
|
00:12:14
|
|
T.
|
00:12:21
|
|
You're on. Thank you very much for all you do. You're welcome. Good morning, supervisors and Chairman Christensen.
|
00:12:22
|
|
First off, I would like to introduce you to my staff which include.
|
00:12:31
|
|
Myself, Laura Short, which is my deputy.
|
00:12:38
|
|
I have 3 case managers, Patty Loose, Patty Ortega, Sonia Boyd.
|
00:12:42
|
|
Julian Velarde is my finance specialist.
|
00:12:46
|
|
Danny Creek is the administrative clerk and John Froman is the attorney for the Public Fiduciary's office.
|
00:12:50
|
|
So the definition of a fiduciary A fiduciary is someone who for a fee.
|
00:12:58
|
|
Serves as court appointed guardian or conservator for one or more persons who are unrelated to the fiduciary.
|
00:13:03
|
|
A fiduciary accepts the responsibility for taking care of the needs or property of another person for the benefit of that person.
|
00:13:10
|
|
The Office of the Public Fiduciary was established by the 1974 legislature to serve as fiduciary of last resort. And if you made a
|
00:13:19
|
|
copy of what was online, there is a newer version that was uploaded, so I'll get that copy to you.
|
00:13:26
|
|
Fiduciary Organizations In Arizona, there are several types of businesses that follow under the definition of a fiduciary.
|
00:13:37
|
|
You have individuals, business entities, government entities such as myself, So there's fifteen public fiduciaries around the
|
00:13:45
|
|
state of Arizona.
|
00:13:50
|
|
And then there's nonprofit fiduciaries. The professional fiduciary must be licensed with an Arizona Supreme Court, individually
|
00:13:55
|
|
and as a business entity, if applicable, prior to accepting court appointments.
|
00:14:01
|
|
Regarding licensure, licensure is granted by the Supreme Court through testing fingerprint and background check.
|
00:14:09
|
|
Public fiduciaries are appointed by the Board of Supervisors of each county.
|
00:14:17
|
|
So I was appointed by the Board of Supervisors over 23 years ago.
|
00:14:21
|
|
Cases are appointed to fiduciaries by the Superior Court judges.
|
00:14:26
|
|
Gila County Case Manager, Specialist and Finance Specialist must be licensed after completing 3 years of hands on training
|
00:14:31
|
|
underneath the fiduciary. We currently have 3 licensed fiduciaries in my office.
|
00:14:38
|
|
So when is a referral appropriate? A referral is appropriate anytime one feels they know of a vulnerable or incapacitated person
|
00:14:46
|
|
who is a victim of abuse or who is in danger of abandonment, neglect, or self neglect.
|
00:14:54
|
|
Her statute, 46455 states a person who has been employed to provide care to an incapacitated or vulnerable person and who causes
|
00:15:02
|
|
or permits the life or health of an adult to be endangered is guilty of a classified felony.
|
00:15:09
|
|
So who can make a referral? Basically anybody can make a referral to the public fiduciary. It could be.
|
00:15:19
|
|
Yourself, it could be a neighbor, a friend, a family member, an agency, a health department, a hospital.
|
00:15:27
|
|
A police officer, so anybody can refer someone to our office and Laura Short in my office, she will go with someone from my office
|
00:15:36
|
|
or myself and we'll go and do an investigation.
|
00:15:43
|
|
And we'll make a recommendation for the need of guardianship.
|
00:15:50
|
|
The fiduciary is responsible for gathering information to make a decision as to the need for an appointment.
|
00:15:55
|
|
We have to determine whether or not this person will suffer a financial loss if we don't step in.
|
00:16:02
|
|
Will benefit by having a fiduciary whether or not this person will qualify for benefits. It's really important that the person
|
00:16:07
|
|
have benefits or at least qualify for benefits. So we'll apply for all the benefits for them, but if they don't qualify for any
|
00:16:13
|
|
benefits.
|
00:16:18
|
|
It's hard, very hard, to serve them.
|
00:16:24
|
|
If they don't have a benefit, such as long term care or developmental disability.
|
00:16:26
|
|
Umm.
|
00:16:31
|
|
Seriously mentally ill things like that. Is the person at physical risk or and have they exhausted all suitable service providers?
|
00:16:33
|
|
Next is John Froman. He's been serving as the attorney for the public fiduciary office.
|
00:16:45
|
|
For over 22 years.
|
00:16:52
|
|
And we appear in front of Judge Chambers, Judge Wright and Judge Wallack.
|
00:16:55
|
|
And if you guys have any questions, feel free to jump in at any time.
|
00:17:02
|
|
So the process for a petition for an appointment. Legal pleadings are prepared by the public fiduciary attorney John Pearlman.
|
00:17:06
|
|
A hearing is scheduled with a Superior Court.
|
00:17:14
|
|
The judge appoints a court investigator and attorney and a physician and all of those.
|
00:17:18
|
|
People will write a report to the judge.
|
00:17:23
|
|
He'll review those documents and make a determination as to whether or not that person needs a guardian.
|
00:17:26
|
|
And or conservator?
|
00:17:33
|
|
In addition to general guardianship, there is mental health guardianship and the mental health guardianship powers allows.
|
00:17:36
|
|
To give the authority to consent.
|
00:17:45
|
|
A person into a inpatient mental health facility.
|
00:17:49
|
|
So.
|
00:17:54
|
|
I have general guardianship basically on everyone and there are.
|
00:17:55
|
|
Several people that I also have mental health guardianship, which allows me to place them in a hospital.
|
00:18:01
|
|
Tiffany.
|
00:18:08
|
|
When you start one of these cases and you guys, like I said, those three have to prepare a written report to the judge, how long
|
00:18:11
|
|
does that take to get through that process?
|
00:18:15
|
|
Well, usually when you set court out it's it has to be at least two weeks.
|
00:18:19
|
|
Because that's what it takes to get it on the court calendar 14 days.
|
00:18:25
|
|
And so something will go out to that physician.
|
00:18:29
|
|
And they have to have it into court by that time. OK. Thank you.
|
00:18:34
|
|
So we currently have 84.
|
00:18:39
|
|
Here is where all of our clients are located.
|
00:18:42
|
|
The next one is the client location chart. We have a lot of people that live in Gila County, but if they don't live in Gila
|
00:18:46
|
|
County, it's because the services that they receive are outside of Gila County.
|
00:18:52
|
|
So we place them where their needs are being met.
|
00:19:01
|
|
In 2023, we investigated 29 cases. We were appointed on 7.
|
00:19:08
|
|
We denied 8 of them.
|
00:19:14
|
|
Cases referred to private fiduciaries are 5, decedents of states are four and we were terminated on one guardianship this
|
00:19:17
|
|
particular case.
|
00:19:22
|
|
Myself.
|
00:19:29
|
|
And someone else actually transported this client to Texas.
|
00:19:31
|
|
Which is where her family is from.
|
00:19:35
|
|
I was able to go visit her two times.
|
00:19:37
|
|
And after that, it was determined that a family member was able to become a surrogate decision maker for her and we were able to
|
00:19:41
|
|
terminate the guardianship. So we got her where she needed to be with her family, and then we were able to terminate the
|
00:19:45
|
|
guardianship.
|
00:19:50
|
|
Expenses of establishing guardianship and conservatorship.
|
00:19:59
|
|
Filing fees charged by the clerk of the court.
|
00:20:04
|
|
Attorneys fees.
|
00:20:07
|
|
Proposed words, attorney fees. There is physician report costs, court investigator costs, and then private fiduciaries have bonds.
|
00:20:09
|
|
There are.
|
00:20:20
|
|
Excuse me?
|
00:20:23
|
|
Proposed by the public judiciary are approved by Gila County Board of Supervisors and Superior Court presiding judge.
|
00:20:25
|
|
Public fiduciary fees are approved annually by the Superior Court judge on each case. So every year, annually, we present the case
|
00:20:34
|
|
to the judge and he approves the fees. Fees are collected only when words necessities have been met.
|
00:20:41
|
|
Here is the public fiduciary fee schedule.
|
00:20:52
|
|
Next, our revenues and uncollected fees.
|
00:20:56
|
|
Our goal is to collect $45,000 a year, and in 2223 we collected 82,000. The increase was due to stimulus payments from COVID and
|
00:21:01
|
|
Native American Tribal Relief payments.
|
00:21:08
|
|
As you can see below, there is a lot of uncollected fees.
|
00:21:16
|
|
Both from people that are currently on our roster and people that have passed away. And the reason for that is because we have
|
00:21:21
|
|
people that live on $980 a month.
|
00:21:26
|
|
And they pay their rent and utilities and personal life.
|
00:21:32
|
|
Personal effects, and they don't have any money leftover for.
|
00:21:36
|
|
So we take care of the indigent. There's very little feasible money leftover for fees.
|
00:21:40
|
|
The rights that you could lose.
|
00:21:47
|
|
Upon the court finding Incapacity.
|
00:21:49
|
|
You could lose the right to vote to.
|
00:21:52
|
|
The right to decide where to live. How to spend your money or invest your money. The right to take or refuse medications.
|
00:21:56
|
|
Or to write a will or change an existing will?
|
00:22:05
|
|
Regarding the assignment of cases, we base it on the location of the word. We have a particular case manager. All she does is
|
00:22:12
|
|
drive to the valley, so she'll do the valley visits. We have one that does all pay.
|
00:22:18
|
|
Cases and so it depends. It could depend on where they live, their gender, or the level of difficulty of the case.
|
00:22:25
|
|
Next is the diagnosis chart.
|
00:22:36
|
|
And as you can see, a lot of our clients have a dual diagnosis.
|
00:22:39
|
|
So in decision making the general principles are the fiduciary shall exercise extreme care and diligence.
|
00:22:46
|
|
When making decisions on behalf of the word or protected person.
|
00:22:54
|
|
The fiduciary shall make all decisions in a manner that promotes the civil rights and liberties of the word or protective person
|
00:22:58
|
|
and maximizes independence and self-reliance.
|
00:23:03
|
|
Here are two primary roles for decision making. There's substitute judgment.
|
00:23:10
|
|
And best interest?
|
00:23:16
|
|
Major life decisions for a client. These are just a few decisions that I make.
|
00:23:22
|
|
Daily. Weekly. Monthly.
|
00:23:28
|
|
Do not resuscitate.
|
00:23:31
|
|
Full code status.
|
00:23:33
|
|
Life support. The removal of life support.
|
00:23:35
|
|
All surgical procedures, marriages and divorces.
|
00:23:38
|
|
Buying and selling Real?
|
00:23:43
|
|
Birth control and surgical sterilization.
|
00:23:45
|
|
Family involvement and interventions.
|
00:23:48
|
|
And whether or not to invest, invest.
|
00:23:52
|
|
And maximize the words of state. I have made decisions on all of these over the years.
|
00:23:56
|
|
Just in the last.
|
00:24:03
|
|
We've had two amputations.
|
00:24:05
|
|
Two blood clots. One person survived a blood clot, the other person did not.
|
00:24:08
|
|
So my office is on call 24/7, 365 days a year and that's basically Laura and I.
|
00:24:15
|
|
Referral to County Attorney for fraud.
|
00:24:29
|
|
Umm.
|
00:24:32
|
|
We have referred approximately 8 cases through the years to the County attorney's office for fraud when we felt like someone.
|
00:24:34
|
|
Was being financially exploited or abused in some way?
|
00:24:43
|
|
Other duties.
|
00:24:50
|
|
Other case management duties. This is just a fraction of the duties, just so you can get an idea of what we do. So we apply for
|
00:24:52
|
|
all the benefits that we believe somebody qualifies for.
|
00:24:57
|
|
Long term care disability veterans.
|
00:25:02
|
|
Administration. Social Security.
|
00:25:08
|
|
We change their mailing address so we can start receiving all of their mail. Go through all of their mail and see if they have
|
00:25:11
|
|
life insurance, burial policies, what all their bills are.
|
00:25:16
|
|
We secure all their assets and transfer titles.
|
00:25:22
|
|
We close all of their bank accounts and put it into a public fiduciary account in their name.
|
00:25:26
|
|
We prepare client.
|
00:25:31
|
|
Inventories, Picture inventories, Video inventories, sometimes.
|
00:25:34
|
|
Prepare a care.
|
00:25:38
|
|
Advanced directives end of life decisions with regards to advanced directives.
|
00:25:40
|
|
Those are ongoing and they change from day-to-day. So you could be a full code status at one moment and at midnight you get a call
|
00:25:45
|
|
from a doctor and you're changing that person to a do not resuscitate.
|
00:25:52
|
|
Attend all medical and psychological appointments, selling a property and assets.
|
00:26:01
|
|
We are supposed to visit clients no less than every other month.
|
00:26:10
|
|
And, but it usually requires more.
|
00:26:14
|
|
We just did a calculation on one particular client and this year so far we have seen him 39 times.
|
00:26:17
|
|
So it just depends on what is the need for that particular person.
|
00:26:23
|
|
I'm just going to give you just a couple case examples. Our office was referred on a 76 year old woman who had a brain tumor
|
00:26:32
|
|
behind her left eye causing significant protrusion and loss of vision.
|
00:26:38
|
|
She was a breast cancer survivor and had gone through major surgeries and was adamant she did not want the tumor.
|
00:26:45
|
|
Tumors surgically removed. Even though she had some cognitive deficits, she was able to express her wishes.
|
00:26:51
|
|
A Superior Court judge ordered she not be subject to surgery even though physicians reported the tumor was 100% curable with with
|
00:26:58
|
|
surgery and chemotherapy. She received palliative care at a skilled nursing facility until she passed away five months after our
|
00:27:05
|
|
appointment.
|
00:27:11
|
|
And that is something that.
|
00:27:18
|
|
Take to a judge.
|
00:27:22
|
|
And we give him all of the information and then sometimes a judge will guide us on what direction to go in.
|
00:27:24
|
|
The next the next example is an 80 year old gentleman living in a remote area of Gila County. He came to the attention of
|
00:27:33
|
|
community members when he began to exhibit dementia and paranoia.
|
00:27:39
|
|
A followed his home resulted in hospitalization and rehabilitation at a skilled nursing facility.
|
00:27:45
|
|
Due to the poor conditions of his home, no fiduciary and private practice would take this case. Our office became guardian and
|
00:27:51
|
|
after an inventory of the home, we sold the property.
|
00:27:57
|
|
So this is my staff.
|
00:28:03
|
|
We've got our gear on and we are getting ready to go into this home, so we have to go through all of the contents of the home.
|
00:28:06
|
|
And there may have been.
|
00:28:18
|
|
10 to 15.
|
00:28:21
|
|
Boxes. Metal containers that had straps of locks on them.
|
00:28:26
|
|
And so we had to get all of the locks off of everything, get inside, and most of the time there was nothing in there.
|
00:28:32
|
|
So that was treacherous, but as you can see, there's lots of things to go through.
|
00:28:41
|
|
This gentleman lived in very very poor condition. So we were happy that we were able to get him out of this condition and we
|
00:28:50
|
|
literally had to go. I was in this room go from bottom to top every single inch of that house and make sure there was nothing of
|
00:28:56
|
|
value in the home and or something that we had to preserve.
|
00:29:03
|
|
Umm. Or personal papers and effects and stuff like that?
|
00:29:11
|
|
OK.
|
00:29:17
|
|
And next we have one last example. The Superior Court requested our office investigate whether there was a continued need for
|
00:29:18
|
|
guardianship of a 28 year old man because the current guardian had filed for guardianship to be terminated. Our investigation
|
00:29:25
|
|
revealed an ongoing need for a representative payee through Social Security to take care of his finances, but that guardianship
|
00:29:33
|
|
was too invasive. We made our recommendations to the court.
|
00:29:40
|
|
And guardianship was successfully terminated and the young man civil rights was restored.
|
00:29:47
|
|
So we don't just take on the case because some because we get a referral, we like to do our due diligence, do the investigation
|
00:29:53
|
|
and make sure we make the right choice for that particular person.
|
00:29:58
|
|
There are mandatory reports the fiduciary must file with the court, which include inventory and appraisement, annual guardianship
|
00:30:06
|
|
reports to the court.
|
00:30:11
|
|
Annual accountings and final accountings, which include the proposed distribution, so we let the courts.
|
00:30:16
|
|
All the money that they spent throughout the year, all the income coming in, all the income going out and then once they passed
|
00:30:26
|
|
away, the proposed distribution.
|
00:30:30
|
|
Audit the Public Judiciary Office is audited by the Social Security Administration, the Arizona Supreme Court.
|
00:30:37
|
|
The Gila County Superior Court, the Gila County Finance Department and the Veterans Administration.
|
00:30:45
|
|
This is something that I've had sitting in my office for probably over 20 years and so I'm just going to read it to you because it
|
00:30:53
|
|
kind of makes me chuckle it sometimes.
|
00:30:58
|
|
To be a fiduciary, one must be courteous, diplomatic, caring.
|
00:31:04
|
|
Shrewd. Persuasive. Assertive.
|
00:31:09
|
|
Creative, Supportive, understanding. Responsible, Slow to anger, adaptable. A Sherlock Holmes, A motivator. Up to date, good
|
00:31:12
|
|
looking, have a good memory, acute business judgment.
|
00:31:20
|
|
Emotional stability and the embodiment of virtue, but with good working knowledge of sin and evil all in its forms.
|
00:31:28
|
|
A fiduciary must understand insurance, electricity, chemistry, Physiology, mechanics, architecture, physics.
|
00:31:36
|
|
Bookkeeping, thinking, merchandising, selling, shipping, contracting, claims, adjusting law, medicine, real estate, horse trading,
|
00:31:45
|
|
and human nature.
|
00:31:51
|
|
A fiduciary must be a coordinator, A clinician, a coach, a therapist and educator and an administrator.
|
00:31:57
|
|
A fiduciary must be a mind reader, a hypnotist, an athlete must be acquainted with machinery of all types and must know the
|
00:32:05
|
|
current price of everything from a shoestring to a skyscraper, an aspirin to an amputation.
|
00:32:13
|
|
They must know all, see all.
|
00:32:20
|
|
Tell nothing and be everywhere at the same time.
|
00:32:23
|
|
They must satisfy the payroll administrator, the accounts department, the Inland Revenue.
|
00:32:26
|
|
The insurance company, the supervisors, A solicitor, the insured, the claimant, the Law Society and the British Medical
|
00:32:32
|
|
Association.
|
00:32:37
|
|
Apart from that, our job's a piece of cake.
|
00:32:42
|
|
And I'm not all of those, but my staff, they help me with all of those things, so I'll disagree with that.
|
00:32:47
|
|
So not only do we have the public finishing, we run the public fiduciary office, of course, but we also do the indigent burial
|
00:32:58
|
|
program.
|
00:33:02
|
|
For the county.
|
00:33:07
|
|
The public fiduciary is charged with the review and approval of all indigent dispositions, requests and investigation into the
|
00:33:10
|
|
legitimacy of each claim.
|
00:33:14
|
|
All dispositions are by cremation unless there are religious objections.
|
00:33:19
|
|
Or the deceased is an.
|
00:33:24
|
|
Indigent disposition was originally intended for the burial or cremation of unclaimed or unidentifiable persons whom, for lack of
|
00:33:27
|
|
any other option, would be placed in a specific section of a cemetery. However, most applications are for individuals who have not
|
00:33:34
|
|
maintained family contact.
|
00:33:40
|
|
And no family member is willing or able to pay the expense of a burial.
|
00:33:47
|
|
The public fiduciary is contracted with a private investigator to assist in locating family members.
|
00:33:53
|
|
And currently we have a very good rate considering what other counties pay around the state.
|
00:34:00
|
|
We pay $410 for a non veteran and $560.00 for a veteran.
|
00:34:08
|
|
Hilla County authorizes cremation in order to reduce the burden on the funeral homes.
|
00:34:15
|
|
In 2023, we received 28 applications and authorized 19.
|
00:34:20
|
|
So in the other ones, Laura would have found another source, either a family member to pay for it, or another source to pay for
|
00:34:27
|
|
that burial.
|
00:34:31
|
|
OK. Do you have any questions?
|
00:34:37
|
|
Supervisor. Client. Tiffany. I don't know if I got a question. You know, I've all along I've kind of realized what you do, but I
|
00:34:41
|
|
guess I never realized to the extent you do it. And the only thing I can tell you is Mr. Menlo and us do not pay you enough.
|
00:34:48
|
|
So.
|
00:34:57
|
|
When you're dealing with somebody's life, basically.
|
00:34:58
|
|
Have you ever had?
|
00:35:03
|
|
Somebody from the family or?
|
00:35:05
|
|
Other parts of the family come back on you for whatever decision that you've made. Sure, sure. But what we like to do, there's not
|
00:35:07
|
|
a lot of family involvement, but when there is, we like to include them and but ultimately I have to make the decision.
|
00:35:15
|
|
So I I let the family know they're welcome to go to the court and become the guardian of that person if if they're not happy with
|
00:35:25
|
|
my decision.
|
00:35:29
|
|
But I don't run into that problem very often.
|
00:35:34
|
|
Good deal I I.
|
00:35:37
|
|
If there is family involvement, I try to have them be involved in the decision making.
|
00:35:39
|
|
Well, thank you and your staff for everything you do and and it's amazing. So thanks. Thanks for bringing this up today too.
|
00:35:47
|
|
That's good. You're welcome, Supervisor Christensen.
|
00:35:52
|
|
Thank you. Thank you, Tiffany. I appreciate you and your staff.
|
00:35:58
|
|
This presentation really helped me to understand the magnitude of what a fiduciary does.
|
00:36:03
|
|
And actually, my favorite part was the case managers creed.
|
00:36:08
|
|
And I'm not sure any of us can live up to that.
|
00:36:13
|
|
It's quite a quite a paragraph of qualifications and it is really necessary for you guys to have compassion, patience, all those
|
00:36:17
|
|
things when you when you're dealing with.
|
00:36:24
|
|
People that have mental issues or they're combative because they just don't like the fact that they're getting old and.
|
00:36:31
|
|
They're losing their rights to make decisions because they don't have that capacity anymore. So I appreciate you and your staff.
|
00:36:39
|
|
Thank you.
|
00:36:48
|
|
Yeah, I just have one question on a cell like the personal property, do you have an auction? I mean I've never seen anything for
|
00:36:48
|
|
sale. So I I I guess what I'm wondering and we have probably other people that are wondering how does that get?
|
00:36:56
|
|
You we can have an option. We have had estate.
|
00:37:05
|
|
Our staff has actually put those on. It depends on the value of the property.
|
00:37:09
|
|
Sometimes by the time we get in there, a lot of the contents are ruined and so it's a matter of just getting any valuables out,
|
00:37:14
|
|
getting all personal belongings and paperwork out.
|
00:37:21
|
|
And then sometimes we'll sell property as is it just every case is different. OK. OK. Thank you. I, I have no questions. I just
|
00:37:28
|
|
have praise for all that you guys do.
|
00:37:33
|
|
It's amazing.
|
00:37:40
|
|
Because the more I'm here, the more you see what Gila County actually offers to the constituents of Heel County and it that's
|
00:37:42
|
|
amazing because people complain about their property taxes, but they have no idea.
|
00:37:48
|
|
What some of the responsibility?
|
00:37:56
|
|
That staff carries.
|
00:38:00
|
|
To help people in Gila County because I think if they knew they wouldn't be a bit surprised if we asked for a little bit more
|
00:38:01
|
|
money. But but we're not. But thank you very much for, for doing what you do. You're welcome. Anybody else? Mr. Vice Chairman.
|
00:38:07
|
|
Thank you.
|
00:38:13
|
|
I will state that the fiduciaries creed that.
|
00:38:21
|
|
Tiffany does.
|
00:38:26
|
|
Live up to those of everything that is stated there. She does a great job to it.
|
00:38:28
|
|
I'd like to say that this is so often in government, particularly in county government, we are.
|
00:38:35
|
|
I think viewed as restrictive and what we.
|
00:38:41
|
|
That through the court system, the.
|
00:38:43
|
|
Sheriff's Office through planning, zoning, community development that.
|
00:38:46
|
|
Giving permits and doing those things.
|
00:38:52
|
|
Maintains integrity of the systems that we have and maintain a quality of life. This is one of those things that is completely
|
00:38:55
|
|
different, completely opposite of that that this is.
|
00:39:01
|
|
On Sunday, with a high of 56 helping those that are most desperately in.
|
00:39:07
|
|
Of services those.
|
00:39:14
|
|
Can fall through the cracks.
|
00:39:18
|
|
And they're out living.
|
00:39:20
|
|
Washes and.
|
00:39:23
|
|
Those kinds.
|
00:39:25
|
|
Now Miss Port, she does not get to choose her clients or the people that she gets to provide services to.
|
00:39:27
|
|
Those are determined by a judge and.
|
00:39:35
|
|
Giving to Miss Porch and her team those that.
|
00:39:38
|
|
They don't have anybody else, they don't have anything else. They don't have anybody to make a decision for them to provide
|
00:39:42
|
|
anything for them. But as Miss Porsche said that.
|
00:39:47
|
|
They're disabled.
|
00:39:53
|
|
Emotionally. Physically.
|
00:39:55
|
|
Being disabled in all those different ways they.
|
00:39:59
|
|
Before a client even comes to Miss Porch and her team.
|
00:40:05
|
|
These are the people that are in the greatest need that we have in our society.
|
00:40:08
|
|
And like and like this Porsche said, it is 24/7 but this is a 365 day job that the old this porch is getting calls.
|
00:40:16
|
|
At 2:00 in the morning on Sunday.
|
00:40:24
|
|
Three in the afternoon. On a Tuesday, it's every.
|
00:40:28
|
|
Of the year.
|
00:40:33
|
|
And she responds with a smile.
|
00:40:34
|
|
And willingness.
|
00:40:37
|
|
I do know few people that.
|
00:40:39
|
|
Respond and be able to.
|
00:40:41
|
|
Approach what she does with the attitude.
|
00:40:45
|
|
Loving.
|
00:40:52
|
|
That she.
|
00:40:54
|
|
And so I just.
|
00:40:56
|
|
You and your team are a fabulous example of what a great.
|
00:41:00
|
|
Service that we here as a county that we do provide that's required but.
|
00:41:04
|
|
The way that it's approached and the way the services are given.
|
00:41:11
|
|
A great tribute to you and your team, and so I express appreciation.
|
00:41:17
|
|
And I can't remember which one if you said that we don't pay you enough.
|
00:41:23
|
|
And you're holding. That's absolutely true.
|
00:41:28
|
|
The services that you provide are priceless.
|
00:41:31
|
|
So I.
|
00:41:35
|
|
Thank you, thank you, thank you for all you do.
|
00:41:36
|
|
Thank you. And I just wanted to say I have a great staff. They are amazing, they're very caring, They work really, really hard.
|
00:41:39
|
|
Thank you for all you do.
|
00:41:48
|
|
We have a member of the public here that would like to comment on this item, if that's all right.
|
00:41:52
|
|
Yeah, that that's fine.
|
00:42:00
|
|
They don't want to. Do we have a call to the public? I guess they can go ahead. Do they need to fill out the paperwork? OK, You
|
00:42:03
|
|
need to. Yeah. Come up to the Tiffany. Thank you very much.
|
00:42:08
|
|
Whoever you are, if you want to come up to the podium and give you your name.
|
00:42:14
|
|
And I think that there's a little call the public.
|
00:42:20
|
|
Paperwork that you need to fill out up there as well, so if someone could be sure that you do that.
|
00:42:23
|
|
Please come up and and share your information.
|
00:42:30
|
|
Mr. Vice Chairman, one of the other commenters coming up, I did want to point out that these are people of all ages. It's just not
|
00:42:34
|
|
the elderly that there was a couple examples of elderly. These clients are all ages throughout the spectrum and they're delivering
|
00:42:39
|
|
services to everybody that is in the.
|
00:42:45
|
|
OK.
|
00:42:52
|
|
NIT can we get?
|
00:42:55
|
|
So can I see the full screen?
|
00:42:57
|
|
OK. I can't see if you're there or not, but if you can go ahead. OK, go ahead.
|
00:43:06
|
|
My name is Bev Miller and well, first of all I did want to tell you get an alert you that this PA system inpatient is so bad. It
|
00:43:13
|
|
was kind of hard for me to understand the work. The pictures spoke volumes.
|
00:43:22
|
|
I really appreciate the work that these people are doing. God bless.
|
00:43:32
|
|
But it would be awfully nice to have a better PA system, because.
|
00:43:38
|
|
We just can't hear very well.
|
00:43:43
|
|
Umm. I mean, I kind of feel disenfranchised. I'm sorry, but.
|
00:43:47
|
|
It's a political word, but that's kind of how I feel.
|
00:43:51
|
|
So that's number one, number two.
|
00:43:55
|
|
So I what I'd like to ask is.
|
00:43:58
|
|
You know this Fiduci.
|
00:44:01
|
|
Committee are they're doing such great work, but have any of the church has ever been alerted because?
|
00:44:06
|
|
This is Christian work they're doing and you know.
|
00:44:14
|
|
I would think that the churches would want to know if one of their flock was in such dire need.
|
00:44:19
|
|
I can just.
|
00:44:34
|
|
No, it's a call to the public, Yeah.
|
00:44:36
|
|
Thank you. Go ahead.
|
00:44:41
|
|
Yes. And the 2nd and the second question is, I'd just like to know financially what this is costing.
|
00:44:45
|
|
The taxpayers.
|
00:44:54
|
|
Christmas.
|
00:44:56
|
|
OK, well, yeah, I call to the public.
|
00:44:59
|
|
We can't say much. I mean you're you're welcome to share with with the board and staff what you would like to.
|
00:45:03
|
|
But we we can't really ask questions. We can we can get with staff.
|
00:45:10
|
|
To.
|
00:45:16
|
|
Research.
|
00:45:18
|
|
But but yeah, during call to the public we we can't answer your questions.
|
00:45:20
|
|
Yeah, so I'd like my question answered in the future and my contact information.
|
00:45:27
|
|
I'm sure the board the board has OK, yeah. What you can do is reach out to your supervisor individually and perhaps maybe he can
|
00:45:34
|
|
gather some information for you.
|
00:45:39
|
|
Yeah, that's that Supervisor Christmas then. So he's standing right there. Are you sitting right there?
|
00:45:45
|
|
Thank you so much. OK. Thank you, Mr.
|
00:45:52
|
|
There, there was a complaint, and I may address the complaint that the facilities department has been.
|
00:45:56
|
|
Charged with working on the AUD.
|
00:46:03
|
|
For the Tommy Klein Martin.
|
00:46:06
|
|
Facility.
|
00:46:08
|
|
And so that facilities, we are aware of that and that issue is being addressed.
|
00:46:10
|
|
I know the courts.
|
00:46:16
|
|
Raise that issue as well and we are working closely with courts. We've brought in experts to help us work with that audio system
|
00:46:18
|
|
there, so.
|
00:46:22
|
|
Again, we are aware of it and it is being addressed.
|
00:46:26
|
|
Pardon.
|
00:46:31
|
|
It's also on YouTube.
|
00:46:33
|
|
That we're doing that.
|
00:46:36
|
|
All right. If there's, if there's nothing further, then I'm going to, I'm going to go on.
|
00:46:39
|
|
Regular agenda Item 3C. Information discussion regarding the process of the flood mapping project.
|
00:46:45
|
|
By the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
|
00:46:53
|
|
For Gila County, good morning.
|
00:46:57
|
|
Good morning. This is a hot subject, so inform us, OK?
|
00:47:01
|
|
Mr. Chairman, members of the board, I'm glad to.
|
00:47:06
|
|
Glad to be here to explain this.
|
00:47:11
|
|
This has been going on.
|
00:47:13
|
|
Oh, OK. Thank you.
|
00:47:16
|
|
This projects been going on for several years.
|
00:47:19
|
|
The.
|
00:47:22
|
|
I think that the LIDAR acquisition was the first step of it and that was started in 2017.
|
00:47:24
|
|
We.
|
00:47:31
|
|
Studies.
|
00:47:33
|
|
Flood zones that didn't have elevations we've had got some of that information.
|
00:47:36
|
|
That was started in 2020.
|
00:47:41
|
|
Last year, I mean early part of this year.
|
00:47:46
|
|
Uh.
|
00:47:50
|
|
We all met with.
|
00:47:51
|
|
And.
|
00:47:53
|
|
Went over our wish.
|
00:47:56
|
|
What all needed to be?
|
00:47:59
|
|
And we're really grateful for them.
|
00:48:02
|
|
To take on Gila County at this time.
|
00:48:07
|
|
I think there are a lot of other areas.
|
00:48:10
|
|
Need the maps updated? We're trying to help people be safe and flood prone areas.
|
00:48:13
|
|
And part of that is helping.
|
00:48:20
|
|
Understand and.
|
00:48:25
|
|
Find ways to comply with the regulations that FEMA.
|
00:48:28
|
|
Has put.
|
00:48:32
|
|
On the flood prone areas and we as a county are charged to.
|
00:48:34
|
|
Never heard anything enforce those regulations for FEMA.
|
00:48:40
|
|
It's been difficult because some of the maps.
|
00:48:45
|
|
KJAA dot very good there.
|
00:48:49
|
|
They.
|
00:48:53
|
|
Some.
|
00:48:55
|
|
Inaccurate topography.
|
00:48:57
|
|
To depict the flood hazard.
|
00:49:00
|
|
A lot of them were done in the early 80s.
|
00:49:04
|
|
And haven't been updated. Some areas have.
|
00:49:08
|
|
Of the Chairman. So we we got this Lidar data which is very accurate.
|
00:49:11
|
|
Very lot. A lot of data points.
|
00:49:17
|
|
That.
|
00:49:20
|
|
Elevation data available in every area that.
|
00:49:22
|
|
That we.
|
00:49:25
|
|
So now they can come.
|
00:49:27
|
|
Represent the real situation as it is now the state of the rivers.
|
00:49:30
|
|
So this is an update on the process that they're doing.
|
00:49:40
|
|
And this is.
|
00:49:43
|
|
Very good for Gila County.
|
00:49:45
|
|
They are doing the work, they're contracting things out. They're funding at 100%.
|
00:49:48
|
|
And.
|
00:49:55
|
|
We are getting our wish list, so we have.
|
00:49:57
|
|
Depiction of the flood hazard that people can work with to protect themselves and the property.
|
00:50:00
|
|
OK, this is what I was just talking about.
|
00:50:17
|
|
And.
|
00:50:24
|
|
You notice this term base level engineering.
|
00:50:26
|
|
And let me explain that a little bit.
|
00:50:30
|
|
That's kind of an automated engineering analysis. They use this.
|
00:50:34
|
|
Topographic.
|
00:50:39
|
|
And.
|
00:50:42
|
|
They.
|
00:50:44
|
|
And when I say horse.
|
00:50:45
|
|
Delineation of the flood prone.
|
00:50:47
|
|
As well as provide flood elevations.
|
00:50:51
|
|
That.
|
00:50:53
|
|
Protect themselves from.
|
00:50:55
|
|
And.
|
00:50:58
|
|
This is used where there's not an existing detailed study.
|
00:51:00
|
|
OK, a lot of these borschts have been.
|
00:51:05
|
|
In detail, in the past and this is not used on them, they do another detailed study to update them. This doesn't take into account
|
00:51:09
|
|
all of the.
|
00:51:14
|
|
Culverts.
|
00:51:21
|
|
Road crossings and everything goes in there but it.
|
00:51:23
|
|
Available information, you'll throw it.
|
00:51:28
|
|
They're not going to go out to survey and so on to find things.
|
00:51:31
|
|
So there's a base level engineering, it's a little bit less detailed, but quite honestly it's probably.
|
00:51:35
|
|
Better than some of our old detailed studies in my.
|
00:51:42
|
|
This.
|
00:51:50
|
|
In a lot of areas where you.
|
00:51:51
|
|
A lot of development.
|
00:51:54
|
|
It's about the same thing.
|
00:51:57
|
|
This allows.
|
00:52:02
|
|
Assess the adequacy of exist.
|
00:52:05
|
|
Flood.
|
00:52:09
|
|
Vote and provide elevations.
|
00:52:11
|
|
And increase the accuracy where they don't have any and also to provide.
|
00:52:14
|
|
Flood mapping in areas where there is.
|
00:52:19
|
|
Where it's just a. It's called the zone D which is identified.
|
00:52:22
|
|
Area identified as possible but unknown Flood hazard Which?
|
00:52:27
|
|
Really doesn't help people a lot.
|
00:52:32
|
|
And the flood insurance rates reflect.
|
00:52:35
|
|
That ambiguity.
|
00:52:39
|
|
Mr. Chair for my third.
|
00:52:42
|
|
Let us all know what LIDAR stands for.
|
00:52:45
|
|
Off the top of my head I'm I'm drawing a blank. But what it is, it's it's an aerial technique using LADAR lasers.
|
00:52:53
|
|
And reflecting back off the ground and.
|
00:53:01
|
|
Buildings and whatever.
|
00:53:05
|
|
To give an elevation at a point in there, you might have a square yard and be several elevation points in some cases.
|
00:53:07
|
|
So it's a fairly dense and fairly accurate.
|
00:53:17
|
|
Spot checks we've done with surveys.
|
00:53:21
|
|
To come very close.
|
00:53:24
|
|
So, so back in the 80s when they did a bunch of these math.
|
00:53:26
|
|
What did they use then? Was it just your standard GPS type or was it actual underground surveying?
|
00:53:30
|
|
You know, we we hope they got their benchmarks right.
|
00:53:39
|
|
They.
|
00:53:44
|
|
They created topography that was 4 foot contour intervals.
|
00:53:45
|
|
So every four feet they knew the elevation.
|
00:53:50
|
|
And there's.
|
00:53:53
|
|
Area in between there.
|
00:53:55
|
|
Somewhat inaccurate.
|
00:53:57
|
|
OK, so using this new Lidar technology that gives you all the information.
|
00:53:59
|
|
From ground level up.
|
00:54:05
|
|
Yeah, and they differentiate between ground elevations.
|
00:54:07
|
|
Building elevations and vegetation elevations, OK.
|
00:54:12
|
|
Mr. Chairman.
|
00:54:15
|
|
Lighter is an ACT. LIDAR is an acronym for Light Detection and Ranging.
|
00:54:21
|
|
In light, air, laser light is sent from a source and transmitter and reflected from objects.
|
00:54:27
|
|
In.
|
00:54:32
|
|
The reflected light is detected by the system.
|
00:54:33
|
|
And the time of flight is used to develop a distance map of the objects in the scene. OK, oh, a radar is sent to the ground and
|
00:54:38
|
|
that.
|
00:54:43
|
|
Brought together and now stuff the other topography. So then it's all done by aerial platforms in.
|
00:54:49
|
|
All right. Thank.
|
00:54:57
|
|
So it's it's they can get a lot more easily and more cheaply than.
|
00:54:58
|
|
Ground service and more accurately.
|
00:55:04
|
|
Sometimes. Thank you, Mr.
|
00:55:06
|
|
OK.
|
00:55:13
|
|
What?
|
00:55:15
|
|
These are areas.
|
00:55:18
|
|
That they're using the base level engineering arm.
|
00:55:21
|
|
Watercourses that are being studied represented by these blue lines.
|
00:55:24
|
|
So there are a lot.
|
00:55:29
|
|
A lot of.
|
00:55:32
|
|
Stream miles that are being.
|
00:55:34
|
|
In fact, 815 miles are slated to be.
|
00:55:37
|
|
Through this.
|
00:55:41
|
|
That are not currently mapped by.
|
00:55:46
|
|
So that's.
|
00:55:48
|
|
New information that we can provide to our residents.
|
00:55:50
|
|
Help them protect themselves.
|
00:55:54
|
|
And.
|
00:55:59
|
|
As I mentioned, brick structures such as bridges and culverts.
|
00:56:00
|
|
From readily available.
|
00:56:05
|
|
Can be included in this?
|
00:56:09
|
|
In the north part of the county, we also have.
|
00:56:14
|
|
A lot of areas.
|
00:56:17
|
|
Due to space level engineering.
|
00:56:23
|
|
Now also there are new detailed studies.
|
00:56:27
|
|
And I.
|
00:56:32
|
|
All of the areas that are studied by detailed studies now are being updated.
|
00:56:34
|
|
I know we have.
|
00:56:40
|
|
People that are concerned about the way it's.
|
00:56:43
|
|
And there are.
|
00:56:46
|
|
Areas that really need updating badly.
|
00:56:51
|
|
So that's.
|
00:56:54
|
|
And we'll have 82 new miles of re studies on on the detailed hydraulics.
|
00:56:56
|
|
OK, when they're res.
|
00:57:03
|
|
Some structures and looking at as built plans for.
|
00:57:07
|
|
For bridges and so on, and including all that information in.
|
00:57:12
|
|
This is a list of.
|
00:57:18
|
|
The rest studies that are being done, the detailed studies.
|
00:57:22
|
|
And I'm not going to try to read all those.
|
00:57:27
|
|
Fairly extensive.
|
00:57:31
|
|
Now part of.
|
00:57:40
|
|
Work that's being done is to relook at the hydrology, in other words, the amount of water that's coming down.
|
00:57:44
|
|
This is just preliminary, they're still working on fine tuning it.
|
00:57:54
|
|
But you can see that there is some change.
|
00:57:58
|
|
Largest change seems to be.
|
00:58:04
|
|
Tributaries to Tunnel Creek in Tunnel Bas.
|
00:58:07
|
|
And.
|
00:58:11
|
|
Going up and going down in some areas and going up in others.
|
00:58:13
|
|
Oh.
|
00:58:17
|
|
But.
|
00:58:18
|
|
Updated methodology to get a better handle on that.
|
00:58:20
|
|
Actual.
|
00:58:24
|
|
100 year flows that are coming through these washes.
|
00:58:26
|
|
So, Darden, you're talking about flows. You're talking about when it actually rains and floods those kind of flows?
|
00:58:29
|
|
So at any given year, that can change it. It ain't given place or location, right?
|
00:58:36
|
|
That's right. What they use for and that's what makes it difficult. So they have decided.
|
00:58:42
|
|
That they will use.
|
00:58:48
|
|
A flood that has a 1% chance of occurring in any given year, sometimes referred to as 100 year flood.
|
00:58:50
|
|
And use that.
|
00:58:57
|
|
Flood protection purposes.
|
00:58:59
|
|
Umm.
|
00:59:03
|
|
And obviously.
|
00:59:04
|
|
And then?
|
00:59:06
|
|
You don't know what's going to happen.
|
00:59:08
|
|
That that's what Congress decided was a.
|
00:59:10
|
|
Standard to.
|
00:59:15
|
|
That flood projection too.
|
00:59:17
|
|
I'll be.
|
00:59:20
|
|
So we're using the best available information now.
|
00:59:26
|
|
Estimate that, and a lot of it is.
|
00:59:31
|
|
Due to some research by the US Geological Survey.
|
00:59:34
|
|
And some equations.
|
00:59:39
|
|
Will Gener.
|
00:59:42
|
|
Oh.
|
00:59:45
|
|
Can be used.
|
00:59:46
|
|
Determine the flow rate to use that that's been updated since they were originally done.
|
00:59:49
|
|
I don't want to take up too much time on your presentation, but I have another question for you.
|
00:59:55
|
|
So besides flow rate.
|
01:00:00
|
|
When you when you measure a floodplain, does it come out of the center of the draw or drainage up a?
|
01:00:02
|
|
Amount or feet to be considered in a floodplain at whatever level.
|
01:00:10
|
|
Yeah, that's where the hydraulics come in that that analysis.
|
01:00:15
|
|
And they'll consider the shape.
|
01:00:19
|
|
Water.
|
01:00:22
|
|
Run up through this computer model and.
|
01:00:26
|
|
Determines how high the water would have to be.
|
01:00:29
|
|
Fill up that water course, that Channel shape.
|
01:00:33
|
|
And how high it would come. And then that's intersected with the ground to determine how far it is of a flood prone area extends.
|
01:00:37
|
|
So then, whether or not a drainage builds up with sediment or washes itself out is a big deciding factor.
|
01:00:45
|
|
That's a moving target and.
|
01:00:55
|
|
Yes.
|
01:00:59
|
|
Some stream maintenance does have to be done.
|
01:01:01
|
|
Take.
|
01:01:04
|
|
Debris that washes.
|
01:01:06
|
|
Growth that.
|
01:01:11
|
|
So yeah, there is a maintenance issue to this.
|
01:01:14
|
|
To maintain.
|
01:01:18
|
|
Excellent representation of what's going to happen.
|
01:01:20
|
|
Yeah. And I I think you know from a county standpoint, when I look at a lot of our drainages and I can use Tunnel Creek for an
|
01:01:23
|
|
example.
|
01:01:27
|
|
You know they get so built up with with stuff that and then we can't touch it because the TNA and other factors.
|
01:01:31
|
|
Causes our floodplains to expand, basically.
|
01:01:38
|
|
I guess once you would just put it that way.
|
01:01:41
|
|
That does happen, yes.
|
01:01:45
|
|
And there is aggregation building up of the bottom and degradation, and sometimes it goes up and down over time.
|
01:01:48
|
|
So what we're.
|
01:01:59
|
|
The best representation we?
|
01:02:01
|
|
Knowing that.
|
01:02:04
|
|
Oscillations, if you will, of the.
|
01:02:07
|
|
Parameters of the cricket goes up, down, grows up in vegetation.
|
01:02:11
|
|
Veget.
|
01:02:16
|
|
Washes out or burns out or something. It's dynamic system.
|
01:02:17
|
|
This is an effort to give it the best information that we.
|
01:02:23
|
|
So we can. I really love work.
|
01:02:27
|
|
So with that in mind, guard if you have somebody that's wanting to to build that's right on that.
|
01:02:30
|
|
Edge of a flood?
|
01:02:36
|
|
What would you say or what would you tell them? Because this year you could be right on the edge, next year you could be 10 feet
|
01:02:40
|
|
above it.
|
01:02:43
|
|
You know it's if you're thinking about moving target as far as.
|
01:02:47
|
|
Streams and and build up and everything in there. So how do we?
|
01:02:51
|
|
How do we make those decisions, I guess?
|
01:02:56
|
|
Well, that's where this.
|
01:03:01
|
|
1% chance comes in. It's a statistical.
|
01:03:03
|
|
Average.
|
01:03:06
|
|
Our representation of what's likely to.
|
01:03:08
|
|
Once in 100 years.
|
01:03:13
|
|
It may not happen this year, may not happen the next when.
|
01:03:17
|
|
2.
|
01:03:20
|
|
And adjacent years.
|
01:03:22
|
|
It's a better protection than nothing at all.
|
01:03:27
|
|
And.
|
01:03:31
|
|
We can say that they're reasonably protected and there are other things also.
|
01:03:32
|
|
Right on the Creek bank, we have an erosion set back in the ordinance for example.
|
01:03:38
|
|
That.
|
01:03:44
|
|
Requires people to.
|
01:03:47
|
|
So that's not likely to get a road during that time or a lateral erosion of the bank.
|
01:03:50
|
|
Or to provide bank protection then if they want to build closer.
|
01:03:57
|
|
I ask these questions because a lot of our prime land is already developed and and done. So what we're looking at as far as
|
01:04:05
|
|
development that I see in Heather County as a whole is we're looking at a lot of these areas that have been in question due to
|
01:04:10
|
|
foot lane issues.
|
01:04:14
|
|
And other circumstances. So going forward, me personally, I'd like to be able to.
|
01:04:20
|
|
You know, when I talk to my constituents say, hey, you know, this is a new system that can give us better data and know the system
|
01:04:26
|
|
enough to speak about it and so.
|
01:04:31
|
|
That's why I like board sessions. I'm glad you're here and I appreciate.
|
01:04:37
|
|
Efforts to help your constituents that.
|
01:04:42
|
|
I'm always available for questions as well.
|
01:04:45
|
|
So.
|
01:04:49
|
|
Next slide. Here is what will we receive as.
|
01:04:54
|
|
Deliverable product out of the.
|
01:05:00
|
|
And.
|
01:05:03
|
|
Hydrology updated flow rates.
|
01:05:05
|
|
Hydraulics. Where?
|
01:05:09
|
|
How deep and how wide the water is going to go, How fast?
|
01:05:11
|
|
We.
|
01:05:17
|
|
Terrain information that we didn't have before.
|
01:05:18
|
|
Then floodplain maps will be updated.
|
01:05:24
|
|
Now this current phase of the project.
|
01:05:27
|
|
Will.
|
01:05:32
|
|
Information We can write preliminary flood maps.
|
01:05:34
|
|
Sometime mid 2025, the estimate.
|
01:05:40
|
|
Estimate.
|
01:05:44
|
|
The information will.
|
01:05:46
|
|
The.
|
01:05:48
|
|
Pre.
|
01:05:49
|
|
Mapping.
|
01:05:51
|
|
Will.
|
01:05:53
|
|
Computer models so that if we want to.
|
01:05:55
|
|
Look at a what?
|
01:05:59
|
|
We can plug in some development, see what effect it has on the.
|
01:06:01
|
|
Umm.
|
01:06:07
|
|
And then after you'll receive this data.
|
01:06:08
|
|
There will be.
|
01:06:11
|
|
Public comment, review and comment period.
|
01:06:13
|
|
And then they'll start actually putting this on the official flood maps and generating them. So it'll be sometime.
|
01:06:16
|
|
I don't really have a time estimate I'm going to guess.
|
01:06:24
|
|
At least a year or two after.
|
01:06:29
|
|
We receive the preliminary information.
|
01:06:31
|
|
Have some flood.
|
01:06:34
|
|
It could be a little longer.
|
01:06:36
|
|
Thought I have, I'll probably have more questions for you, but anyway, in the 80s the maps were drawn for floodplains by whatever
|
01:06:41
|
|
method it was.
|
01:06:45
|
|
And so like right down through the middle of.
|
01:06:50
|
|
I keep hearing there's issues in where the floodplain is drawn. Yeah, especially Pinal Creek.
|
01:06:54
|
|
And.
|
01:07:02
|
|
Are are you telling me that this will correct those issues or at least put it?
|
01:07:05
|
|
It.
|
01:07:12
|
|
That's the.
|
01:07:14
|
|
OK, they're using updated.
|
01:07:16
|
|
Ground elevation information.
|
01:07:18
|
|
Updated flow rates.
|
01:07:22
|
|
And.
|
01:07:24
|
|
They should take into account any.
|
01:07:26
|
|
Culverts or bridges?
|
01:07:29
|
|
And so on.
|
01:07:31
|
|
And.
|
01:07:33
|
|
Yes, it should be.
|
01:07:34
|
|
A much better representation given the limits.
|
01:07:36
|
|
Technology and the variability of storms, of course.
|
01:07:40
|
|
That should give us updated information.
|
01:07:45
|
|
Prov.
|
01:07:48
|
|
Much better target to aim for, for protecting our property.
|
01:07:50
|
|
OK, so the the feds are doing this. They're they're they're doing it.
|
01:07:54
|
|
We're in the mix.
|
01:07:59
|
|
As a county.
|
01:08:01
|
|
OK. And then what we receive, we hand over to like the city of Globe or Miami or whoever it is.
|
01:08:03
|
|
Now all the cities and towns were involved in.
|
01:08:11
|
|
The meetings with FEMA to determine their.
|
01:08:15
|
|
And.
|
01:08:19
|
|
They all are going to be part of these new maps.
|
01:08:20
|
|
They'll receive all the information that we receive.
|
01:08:24
|
|
Pertinent to them.
|
01:08:28
|
|
OK, it's all public information. Oh yeah, he's heard. Yes.
|
01:08:32
|
|
Quite honestly, you'd be amazed at.
|
01:08:37
|
|
How not so many public pay attention to that?
|
01:08:40
|
|
And so until it's, it's happening.
|
01:08:44
|
|
Anyway.
|
01:08:48
|
|
Welcome.
|
01:08:50
|
|
This.
|
01:08:54
|
|
List of the expenditures.
|
01:08:56
|
|
For this project.
|
01:08:59
|
|
We'd see. There's about a half million for Lidar.
|
01:09:02
|
|
About 100,000 for base level engineering. That's done so far and there's more still in progress.
|
01:09:07
|
|
Which? Which?
|
01:09:16
|
|
Is included in.
|
01:09:18
|
|
Item 1.2 million.
|
01:09:20
|
|
Update the detailed studies and BLE studies for areas that are currently not studied.
|
01:09:23
|
|
And.
|
01:09:31
|
|
February 2025 I think I've heard this might be.
|
01:09:33
|
|
Mid year.
|
01:09:38
|
|
Sometime in 2025 that we expect to give us that.
|
01:09:40
|
|
Information.
|
01:09:44
|
|
This is this is the overall view of it.
|
01:09:52
|
|
We're in the hydrology, hydraulics, floodplain mapping.
|
01:09:57
|
|
Phase of the project now.
|
01:10:00
|
|
We'll go into the flood insurance rate maps in the next phase.
|
01:10:04
|
|
So what's been going on? A little while, but it's a big project, but it's.
|
01:10:11
|
|
Very beneficial to.
|
01:10:18
|
|
And just a summary of the benefits.
|
01:10:22
|
|
The LIDAR elevation which can be used for many things.
|
01:10:25
|
|
This is available also to the public for engineers to use.
|
01:10:29
|
|
On their projects.
|
01:10:33
|
|
And.
|
01:10:36
|
|
It's available actually on the USGS website.
|
01:10:38
|
|
One of their sites, Well, better information to help protect property owners to be safe and to protect their property.
|
01:10:43
|
|
And to get engineering information defining locations and severity of flooding.
|
01:10:54
|
|
So that future planning can confirm and quantify.
|
01:10:59
|
|
Severity of suspected flood problem areas.
|
01:11:03
|
|
And develop priorities for future planning to mitigate these hazards.
|
01:11:07
|
|
And that's all I have for presentation. Are there any other questions from anybody?
|
01:11:14
|
|
Supervisor, client, thank you. So darn when back that up. One slide please.
|
01:11:21
|
|
The hydrology hydraulic floodplain mapping, August 2023 or February 2025. Is FEMA doing that or are we? Remind me again, FEMA.
|
01:11:30
|
|
FEMA has contracted an engineer that they work with sexually.
|
01:11:41
|
|
Joint venture of two or three engineering firms.
|
01:11:48
|
|
And they are working with us, asking, asking for input and so on. So we're kind of a joint effort.
|
01:11:52
|
|
So they're not held up because of us right now though, right? That's correct. Cool. So if there's any way we can take a sharp,
|
01:11:59
|
|
sharp stick and prod them along and hit closer than 25, that would be really good.
|
01:12:05
|
|
Well, I wish there were, but I know they're doing a lot.
|
01:12:12
|
|
A lot of detailed analysis, and it does take some time. So this this floodplain issue for Hila County is bigger, bigger than a lot
|
01:12:15
|
|
of people realize there's we actually have businesses that are in the flood.
|
01:12:22
|
|
Actually physically, but not mapped in the flood plain.
|
01:12:30
|
|
Which can qualify for different types of loans and things like that. We have other ones that are outside of the floodplain.
|
01:12:35
|
|
Considered in the Flood?
|
01:12:43
|
|
That get that are in a situation where they can't get loans, they can't get grants, they can't get things like that.
|
01:12:45
|
|
That's why when when people talk about floodplain.
|
01:12:52
|
|
Issues.
|
01:12:57
|
|
It isn't just a matter of you pour water down the mountain and it comes out the other end or whatever. It's really the people that
|
01:12:58
|
|
are along those.
|
01:13:02
|
|
Those drainages and stuff and and because of policy and laws.
|
01:13:06
|
|
There's people out there getting hammered that aren't necessary that don't necessarily.
|
01:13:13
|
|
Need to be, they're not in it. And so because of the 80s maps and what I understand you know not only from here but from before,
|
01:13:18
|
|
those maps were incorrect when they were done and it placed a lot of people in some bad bad spots and and so to be able to get
|
01:13:25
|
|
this corrected in my opinion the quicker we get it corrected.
|
01:13:33
|
|
The better some people are going to be and the worst some other ones are going to be. I mean it's it's going to be, it's not going
|
01:13:41
|
|
to be good for everybody all the way around, but at least be correct to the where a floodplain should actually be.
|
01:13:48
|
|
That's what I would.
|
01:13:55
|
|
You know, so that's correct. And it affects also flood insurance rates. Yes, it does and it affects the.
|
01:13:57
|
|
Ability.
|
01:14:04
|
|
Get mortgages and floodplains.
|
01:14:05
|
|
It does. Thank you, darling. A lot of things.
|
01:14:09
|
|
I want to just.
|
01:14:12
|
|
You know, if somebody, there are a couple of locations currently.
|
01:14:14
|
|
Where people are trying to speed it up.
|
01:14:18
|
|
By doing the study themselves.
|
01:14:21
|
|
And submitting it to FEMA. They have a process a letter of map revision.
|
01:14:24
|
|
We have one that they're currently processing for Tunnel Creek on at Bear Flat.
|
01:14:29
|
|
And.
|
01:14:36
|
|
One on a reach of bloody tanks wash.
|
01:14:37
|
|
That private people.
|
01:14:41
|
|
Paid to have a study done and submitted to FEMA. So that's one option if somebody is in a hurry. OK, thank you for that.
|
01:14:46
|
|
Thank you pleasure to present this information.
|
01:14:56
|
|
Supervisor Christensen.
|
01:15:00
|
|
Thank you, Guard. Appreciate it. Very detailed and there's a lot to that. Appreciate everything you do and your team.
|
01:15:03
|
|
Thank you.
|
01:15:12
|
|
Yeah, I think it's great that this was initiated. I think it's great that FEMA is doing it.
|
01:15:15
|
|
Because we've had an awful lot of issues because people.
|
01:15:21
|
|
Are clearly not in a flood, plain or wave, but are on the map.
|
01:15:25
|
|
Because a lot of drainages have changed and those individuals are doing it because they have to.
|
01:15:30
|
|
And so hopefully FEMA when they get finished.
|
01:15:37
|
|
That the people will not have to do their own survey to prove that they're in or out of a floodway because now for insurance
|
01:15:41
|
|
purposes and things of that nature.
|
01:15:47
|
|
People realize, especially with with modern technology, you can check your elevation of your house with your cell phone.
|
01:15:53
|
|
And you look at a map and it's completely a different elevation.
|
01:16:01
|
|
And so you have to go through the money of hiring a survey.
|
01:16:05
|
|
And fight FEMA to get it changed. And so I think it's great. I'm glad that that that the engineering department.
|
01:16:09
|
|
Has sparked with FEMA to get this done for Gila County because our elevations go from 7000 down to almost nothing and and we have
|
01:16:20
|
|
a lot of drainage issues.
|
01:16:26
|
|
And a lot of people are going to be in floodplains that.
|
01:16:33
|
|
And out of flood plains that were and so like you say, we've got a can of worms to deal with and then it goes to the insurance
|
01:16:37
|
|
companies and you know homeowners insurance and things of that nature. But I'm glad that can of worms is open so.
|
01:16:44
|
|
Thank you very much for your presentation and.
|
01:16:52
|
|
Working with FEMA to help us help not only for future infrastructure, but for existing infrastructure that's going to change.
|
01:16:57
|
|
So thank you very much. Anyone else? Mr. Menlo, when I first came here just a couple months before, the current Board of
|
01:17:06
|
|
Supervisors or at least two of you were new onto as newly elected members of the Board of Supervisors.
|
01:17:13
|
|
I came to.
|
01:17:21
|
|
So there's Flood Control District. But the question I asked was.
|
01:17:23
|
|
Uh.
|
01:17:28
|
|
There was no property tax for the flood control district. I asked the question, are there no flood?
|
01:17:30
|
|
Related issues.
|
01:17:35
|
|
In Gil.
|
01:17:37
|
|
The respondent pause for a moment, then said.
|
01:17:40
|
|
There are no issues with flooding in Gila County.
|
01:17:45
|
|
So I express appreciation to you as a Board of Supervisors, to Mr. Veil and Mr. Delarack.
|
01:17:50
|
|
We're taking it serious that there are flooding issues in your county and that you have supported.
|
01:17:56
|
|
Doing this work that is now being done and so I appreciate that and it is necessary and important for us to address flooding
|
01:18:02
|
|
issues in the county.
|
01:18:07
|
|
Thank you for your support, members the board. I do have a question for Mr. Gilroy.
|
01:18:12
|
|
That you kind of have answered it, but.
|
01:18:17
|
|
If I can ask specifically, with all the flooding that has taken place, you've got, you've said that there's $1.2 million that's
|
01:18:21
|
|
being invested in the topography and the LIDAR work that's being done to accurately map all that. We've seen that with the
|
01:18:27
|
|
flooding and you'd say that there's changes.
|
01:18:33
|
|
Is this something that we need to expect that it has to have to continually upgrade these?
|
01:18:39
|
|
All the time? Or is it once we get these maps completely done in 2025, or as soon as they can be done?
|
01:18:45
|
|
Is that something we say? OK, we're good for 10 years.
|
01:18:53
|
|
What is the expectation should? What should?
|
01:18:57
|
|
And you mentioned that things change and we expect that this is continuous.
|
01:19:01
|
|
An.
|
01:19:05
|
|
Analysis of our floodways.
|
01:19:06
|
|
Are we actually we have the expectation that we're good.
|
01:19:09
|
|
10 years and don't need to do anything further.
|
01:19:13
|
|
There, there are there will be a need for continued upgrades.
|
01:19:17
|
|
Hopefully.
|
01:19:22
|
|
We get upgraded more than every 40 years or so.
|
01:19:24
|
|
But every 10 years like you say.
|
01:19:27
|
|
Probably not be unrealistic, given that that rivers do naturally change themselves.
|
01:19:30
|
|
And.
|
01:19:38
|
|
There are changes in the watershed, such as a fire we had here.
|
01:19:40
|
|
You know, that changed the waters.
|
01:19:44
|
|
A lot. And that changes how much water comes down.
|
01:19:46
|
|
Uh.
|
01:19:51
|
|
Runs off the watershed.
|
01:19:52
|
|
So there are things that just happen naturally that.
|
01:19:54
|
|
What affect our flood maps?
|
01:20:01
|
|
Accuracy.
|
01:20:04
|
|
So there should be some continuing update maybe to not every Creek all at once.
|
01:20:06
|
|
But especially after a fire burned 600,000 acres and see what it does to a community. Yeah, now.
|
01:20:12
|
|
There are temporary things that happen, you know, after a fire, there is some revegetation, and so on after a few years.
|
01:20:21
|
|
Umm.
|
01:20:30
|
|
Sometimes.
|
01:20:31
|
|
The community will look at that and.
|
01:20:33
|
|
An interim map developed for their own.
|
01:20:37
|
|
You know, states what's going to be until it revegetates it's back to normal.
|
01:20:41
|
|
And that's.
|
01:20:47
|
|
An option?
|
01:20:49
|
|
Usually they don't change.
|
01:20:51
|
|
FEMA flood maps for something temporary, but.
|
01:20:54
|
|
If it's something that's going to have a long term impact.
|
01:20:58
|
|
Yes, that's something.
|
01:21:02
|
|
Might be needed, Mr. Chairman.
|
01:21:06
|
|
And of course we did that after The Telegraph Fire and all that. We did have an engineering firm, Engineering firm come in and and
|
01:21:09
|
|
give us what?
|
01:21:13
|
|
What?
|
01:21:18
|
|
Flow rates were going to be and so we do address that specifically, but long-term.
|
01:21:19
|
|
A10 year and a 10 year that we should fact.
|
01:21:26
|
|
Work to get those long term maps done every 10 years. Thank you. Thanks for coming down to do your presentation today. I
|
01:21:32
|
|
appreciate you being here instead of there. Thank you very much.
|
01:21:37
|
|
Who's in the back of the box? No. OK, moving on to.
|
01:21:46
|
|
3.
|
01:21:52
|
|
Information discussion regarding services provided by the University of Arizona Cooperative Extension to residents of Gila County.
|
01:21:53
|
|
And a discussion with Gila County management about services resources provided.
|
01:22:05
|
|
To the University of Arizona Cooperative Extension.
|
01:22:12
|
|
Mr. O'Driscoll, good morning. Good morning, Chairman Board. So at your request, I put together this presentation. I and I have
|
01:22:16
|
|
invited the University of Arizona Cooperative Extension to come up and present the services that they provide residents of Gila
|
01:22:24
|
|
County. And then after they get done with a presentation, what I'd like to do is just give you an estimate in some of the
|
01:22:32
|
|
resources that we provide the University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, so you get the complete picture.
|
01:22:40
|
|
What they provide the residents and what we provide the university. So I see Mr. Edward Martin is here at his team and I'd like to
|
01:22:48
|
|
invite him up and go ahead and start the presentation.
|
01:22:54
|
|
Appreciate it. Thank you very much. My name is Ed Martin. I am the Associate Vice President and Director of Cooperative Extension
|
01:23:03
|
|
for the University of Arizona. And with me here today my CFO, Carolyn Greeno, as well as Renee Karstens with the County Extension
|
01:23:09
|
|
Director.
|
01:23:15
|
|
The Hill.
|
01:23:21
|
|
Mr. Clark Richins and Sammy Jenkins, Advisory Board members that actually you have appointed and and approved by the Board. So
|
01:23:23
|
|
what I want to talk to you a little bit today about is the question was where is our money going to for Cooperative Extension for
|
01:23:29
|
|
Gila County. And for those of you who may or may not know, we've been working in Gila County and actually in Arizona for over 100
|
01:23:35
|
|
years and we take the University of Arizona.
|
01:23:41
|
|
The communities throughout the.
|
01:23:48
|
|
We bring research based education to their communities and provide knowledge to help improve lives of the citizens of Arizona.
|
01:23:50
|
|
We have 25 offices. We have an office in every 15 counties.
|
01:23:58
|
|
We also have 4 satellite offices. Several counties have two offices as as you do here. We have 6 tribal offices and we have
|
01:24:03
|
|
agricultural centers, but we also do Cooperative Extension work.
|
01:24:08
|
|
What do we do? We're educators.
|
01:24:15
|
|
We teach.
|
01:24:18
|
|
We have classes. We have seminars.
|
01:24:19
|
|
We work, we teach on the range, we teach in the field, we have in the meeting halls, in the classrooms.
|
01:24:23
|
|
You give public present.
|
01:24:29
|
|
A regular newspaper columns and stories and on the radio and TV we publish reliable research based information.
|
01:24:31
|
|
And the World Wide Web is more needed today than.
|
01:24:39
|
|
And all of this is through research based.
|
01:24:43
|
|
What do we do specifically in Gila County? Well, we work with the agricultural community.
|
01:24:47
|
|
We work with the ranchers in H.
|
01:24:52
|
|
We work with.
|
01:24:56
|
|
Positive youth for each development program.
|
01:24:58
|
|
Yes, these are the folks you see at the at the fair, the kids that show the animals and kids that have the general project.
|
01:25:02
|
|
I can tell you that some of my favorite times are when I go to county fairs and get to work with our 4H.
|
01:25:08
|
|
I take a deep breath and I say our future is OK. These kids are feeling all right. We're going to be OK.
|
01:25:16
|
|
Financial literacy, one of the highest stresses of families.
|
01:25:22
|
|
In the United States is fine finances. We work with families on financial literacy, teaching them about loans.
|
01:25:26
|
|
He would have a daughter of my own, say I got a credit card and said they want me to pay it all back. And I said yeah, you've got
|
01:25:34
|
|
to pay it all back. Now they're charging me extra. I didn't know that.
|
01:25:39
|
|
I felt for sure I hadn't talked about that positive.
|
01:25:45
|
|
Talking about.
|
01:25:50
|
|
Making sure that we're parenting in the right way with our kids and all of the challenges that we have nowadays.
|
01:25:52
|
|
Health and nutrition.
|
01:25:59
|
|
Huge part of our program, not only in HALA County but throughout the state. Keeping people healthy, teaching them about nutrition.
|
01:26:01
|
|
We teach them how to grow the food.
|
01:26:08
|
|
We're going to teach them now how to cook the.
|
01:26:10
|
|
You teach them what the food can do for them. Food that you could eat that can reduce inflammation, Eating with diabetes.
|
01:26:12
|
|
We're going to teach you how to store the food. So when you have a little backyard garden, Lord knows that we've all had that
|
01:26:19
|
|
zucchini plant. We had some of zucchini that the people on the street don't want anymore zucchini bread, and they thank you for
|
01:26:23
|
|
that offer.
|
01:26:27
|
|
Well, how do you preserve that zucchini? What do you do? Do you freeze it? Do you cook it? You blanch it? What can you do? Can you
|
01:26:31
|
|
can it?
|
01:26:34
|
|
And we work with community and home Gard.
|
01:26:39
|
|
You know, we work with folks that are working in, you know, having a community garden with people who go out and grow their own
|
01:26:41
|
|
and also for home gardening. I myself am a transplant. I'll admit it. I came from Michigan 1992.
|
01:26:48
|
|
Came out here in Arizona. They interviewed me in November.
|
01:26:55
|
|
Thought this was the best place in sliced bread coming from Michigan. They started me July 1st. It was so hot I couldn't believe
|
01:26:58
|
|
it, but I stayed here for over 30 years now.
|
01:27:03
|
|
And so we teach people, yeah, these are the plans you should be planning. These are the places you should plant it. Yes, you can
|
01:27:07
|
|
buy it at the Home Depot. Yes, you can buy that plant. But guess what? It's not going to grow here.
|
01:27:12
|
|
It's not going to grow well. This is what you need. This needs full fun light. This need partial sunlight. How do you get that
|
01:27:18
|
|
home garden?
|
01:27:21
|
|
AG Natural resource programs, we have the Master Gardener program, that's a program that's a huge program across the state
|
01:27:25
|
|
volunteers that really help expand our capacity, increase our capacity to teach folks.
|
01:27:31
|
|
Working both with the youth and adults.
|
01:27:37
|
|
For ourselves, we work about work with that in biochar.
|
01:27:40
|
|
Looking at using biochar for fertilizer and other uses in our horticulture program. Reading the range.
|
01:27:43
|
|
We've been working very, very closely with the Forest Service. We just had a brand new agreement with the Prescott National
|
01:27:50
|
|
Forest. I'm reading the range and agreeing on.
|
01:27:55
|
|
As a capacity for our allotments, for the National Forest, for our ranchers.
|
01:28:01
|
|
It's a huge part of what we do. We have livestock producer workshops, we have AI workshops for them. We work very closely with
|
01:28:07
|
|
natural research, conservation services as well as the FSA, making sure that our branches are know what's available, the programs
|
01:28:12
|
|
that are available, how to apply it to where to go.
|
01:28:18
|
|
For each youth development has all kinds of programs for all witches.
|
01:28:25
|
|
Not only do you have to or not only can you raise an animal if you want and sell it at the fair, Yes, we still do that. But
|
01:28:29
|
|
there's other programs, there's programs in civic engagement we have. Can't we have community service that you could do, healthy
|
01:28:35
|
|
Living, STEAM programs, all types of programs.
|
01:28:40
|
|
You know, we even have a program now where we're using 3D printers. They're learning how to do coding.
|
01:28:47
|
|
Really. How do robotics so a lot of opportunity for kids.
|
01:28:53
|
|
We do have tridal extension here in Gila County, San Carlos. I can tell you this right now. Your money does not go towards that.
|
01:28:58
|
|
That's a fur tap program. Federally recognized tribal extension program is funded through the federal government. Did we help them
|
01:29:04
|
|
out? Sure we do. They have a program. They need an extra person to come out and help with the 4H program. Yeah, listen to somebody
|
01:29:10
|
|
else help them out. But they have their own agent. Their own agent is the one who does the programming. They work with us
|
01:29:16
|
|
directly.
|
01:29:21
|
|
Health, Wellness and family programs very strong. Raising resilient youth once again talking about.
|
01:29:29
|
|
Community health fairs and things like that. Teaching people how to eat healthy, teaching kids how to eat healthy. One of the the
|
01:29:37
|
|
nicest things is when you teach the child how to eat healthy, how they take that back to the parents and say, oh we should be, we
|
01:29:41
|
|
shouldn't have to cook it that way.
|
01:29:46
|
|
I want to carry it. I don't. I don't want to change.
|
01:29:51
|
|
And where are we in Hiller County?
|
01:29:56
|
|
We're in three places, right? We're.
|
01:29:58
|
|
We're.
|
01:30:01
|
|
And then of course we're in San Carlos, so we have three offices. You help support two of those offices.
|
01:30:02
|
|
How do you support? Well, we I kind of put this out?
|
01:30:09
|
|
I really wasn't sure what your cash and in time contributions are.
|
01:30:14
|
|
And then what I did is I compared it to what our expenditures are for the.
|
01:30:18
|
|
So I'm looking at her one, if it was $100,000.
|
01:30:23
|
|
Right now we are asking for 70,000 in cash and then.
|
01:30:27
|
|
Mr. Ojisco well addressed the end time.
|
01:30:31
|
|
You know, we spend about $425,000 for in our direct state.
|
01:30:35
|
|
That's wonder. It's a 1 to 4.3. I can tell you this if we took into account, which I did not take into account in this.
|
01:30:42
|
|
We took into.
|
01:30:50
|
|
The grants that we get that number double S.
|
01:30:52
|
|
And you're looking at 1:00?
|
01:30:55
|
|
We get over $400,000 of grants in Hilo County from our faculty and agents that work here in Helen County that you help support.
|
01:30:58
|
|
The day that I go out and they hire people.
|
01:31:07
|
|
And those people pay taxes and those people live here in the county and they buy things from the local grocery stores and they
|
01:31:10
|
|
then also buy things for their grants. Now I didn't include that because some years it's 400,000, some years it's 300,000,
|
01:31:15
|
|
sometimes it's 600,000.
|
01:31:21
|
|
I didn't want to include that. I wanted to be conservative, to just let you know.
|
01:31:27
|
|
Looking at 150,000, which I think we'll find out is probably closer to your cash and in time you know you're still looking at 1 to
|
01:31:31
|
|
2.2.
|
01:31:35
|
|
This year is probably closer to 1 to 4.4 and then 200,000 as well.
|
01:31:39
|
|
The key here is that for every dollar you put.
|
01:31:45
|
|
The cooperative Ext.
|
01:31:48
|
|
Direct.
|
01:31:50
|
|
Direct return of investment into the economy of Healing County.
|
01:31:52
|
|
It's not a 1:00 to 1:00, it's at least a one to two, and it's probably closer to a one to four.
|
01:31:58
|
|
AM 1240 FM 106.1 and online you need assessment. We did a needs assessment across the state.
|
01:32:05
|
|
We did the needs assessment not only here in Hila County, but in every single county across the state.
|
01:32:11
|
|
And across the state, everyone Overall SAD Water's number one water conservation.
|
01:32:17
|
|
Water quality, that's the that's our biggest need, but here in Hiller County.
|
01:32:23
|
|
You were telling wanted attention to qualified teachers was one of your highest.
|
01:32:28
|
|
Issues, priority issues that you want us to address. We have programs in our 4H which actually deliver.
|
01:32:33
|
|
The teachers in the in the schools curriculum that's already set up for the state standards.
|
01:32:40
|
|
So here it is in a box, in a folder. You can put it together. Talks about agriculture, talks about leadership. You can use this in
|
01:32:47
|
|
your in your right in your classroom, preventing child abuse.
|
01:32:52
|
|
And even #4 preventing domestic and violence, I'm not sure I was probably extension fit there. You know we're going back to that
|
01:32:58
|
|
positive parenting and that financial literacy.
|
01:33:03
|
|
Those are the stressors and families and stress families abuse children, Stressed families have domestic violence.
|
01:33:09
|
|
We can reduce the stresses in our families, we can reduce both of those.
|
01:33:16
|
|
And preparing for wildfires, that was a big one here of course. And that of course is the firewise program that we have that we've
|
01:33:20
|
|
talked about and we talked about preventative spaces.
|
01:33:25
|
|
We're looking right now working within a you to hire one of their their folks to help us with that and to start a new program for
|
01:33:31
|
|
us.
|
01:33:35
|
|
We working in cooperation and in partnership with the County Cooperative Extension.
|
01:33:40
|
|
Cooperative Federal government. State government. County government. We count on your support.
|
01:33:47
|
|
Day in and day out, we need your support. We need your support not only to provide.
|
01:33:53
|
|
Buildings for us to operate out, but also support for us for operations.
|
01:33:58
|
|
I want to thank you all for helping us improve the lives in your communities.
|
01:34:05
|
|
Economies across this county, and I want you to also think about the functional.
|
01:34:10
|
|
Impacts that we have, the impacts that we have that I can't put up there in dollars and cents. The 4H kids that are twice as
|
01:34:16
|
|
likely to give back to the community because they're in 4H, the 4H kid, there are three times as much not to use and abuse drugs
|
01:34:21
|
|
because they're in 4H.
|
01:34:26
|
|
The folks that called that Cooperative Extension after the Telegraph fire and said, listen, you need some help? I got cattle. I
|
01:34:32
|
|
got no feed. Do you know someone you can call? Yeah, we can call someone. We called someone, someone called someone else. Did I
|
01:34:38
|
|
deliver Alfalfa to those folks? No, I didn't. Did we didn't make the connections we should.
|
01:34:44
|
|
Again, when you need a fencing, someone who's been working on fencing.
|
01:34:51
|
|
Called this up and said, listen, we've been trying to get this grant from the floor service for fencing. We can't figure it out.
|
01:34:55
|
|
Can you do it? Can cooperative fencing you?
|
01:34:59
|
|
Within a month we had the.
|
01:35:04
|
|
Representative Kirk called us up and said how the heck did you guys get it so fast? And we said because we had sponsor projects
|
01:35:06
|
|
and you know the numbers and you know how to do it through the federal government and now we're putting up fences. That was burnt
|
01:35:10
|
|
out.
|
01:35:13
|
|
So we're here to do things like that. We're keeping people out of your health care system because they're eating better, that
|
01:35:17
|
|
they're learning about it. So there's all those other things that are intangible. I can't quantify it. I wish I could make it
|
01:35:22
|
|
easier and I could tell you that, say the millions.
|
01:35:27
|
|
You know, and health care costs what have you. But I can tell you that we're having an impact and we're having an impact because
|
01:35:33
|
|
we're all working together.
|
01:35:37
|
|
All working together as part of a team that's the team in Hiller County as well as the team in Maricopa County, as well as the
|
01:35:41
|
|
team across the state. And we're here to help you out. So that's where your money's going.
|
01:35:47
|
|
As a final, final note, I know you've heard a lot of news about EU of A and the deficit.
|
01:35:55
|
|
Cooperative Extension funds cannot go towards the deficit at the University of Arizona. Not only especially county funds, but even
|
01:36:01
|
|
state funds are not allowed to be used for that. State funds can only be used for cooperative.
|
01:36:09
|
|
And your accounting funds can only be used not only for Cooperative Extension, can only be used for heel accounting.
|
01:36:17
|
|
Extension. So I can't borrow from Hill accounting in case Greenland County needs a few 100 or $2000. It all stays in your
|
01:36:24
|
|
communities and discounts. So once again, I appreciate the support that you all give us. We really truly do hope that we can
|
01:36:31
|
|
continue this and hopefully you have seen it over the years, the impacts that we have had in Taylor County 2 property extensions,
|
01:36:37
|
|
University of Arizona. So thank you so very much. All right and thank you. Hold on. The Supervisor Klein, do you have any
|
01:36:44
|
|
questions? I do. Thank you.
|
01:36:51
|
|
Mr. Chair So.
|
01:36:58
|
|
Can can you tell me or do you have any idea when EU of A really became active in Gila County back in the day? How how long has you
|
01:36:59
|
|
have they been cooperative extensions been in existence since 1914?
|
01:37:05
|
|
So that's when it was official that the land grant university was, the University of Arizona is we have proper extension and we
|
01:37:12
|
|
started extension offices in all of the comments. So it'd be 1914. So we're coming up on a little over close to 110 years now.
|
01:37:20
|
|
I know for all of my time in Gila County, you know this one place I've lived. But U of A has always been a part of Healing County
|
01:37:28
|
|
through all the years growing up. And of course I I grew up on on several different ranches and seen the impacts there. You know,
|
01:37:34
|
|
whether or not it was.
|
01:37:39
|
|
Monitoring the issues or dealing with the feds or whatever it was, U of A was always in the middle of it.
|
01:37:46
|
|
With with us and and and.
|
01:37:52
|
|
Uh.
|
01:37:56
|
|
The data it provided and everything has always been a big help. The 4H program for all these years, even back when we were
|
01:37:57
|
|
actually when I was a kid. It was huge for for a choice back then too, just from the animal standpoint.
|
01:38:04
|
|
Kids raising animals and stuff like that, so.
|
01:38:11
|
|
OK. Thank you. Thank you, Thank you. Supervisor Christensen.
|
01:38:14
|
|
Thank you, Chairman, and thank you Mr. Martin for the presentation.
|
01:38:19
|
|
Yeah, I think that EU of A does a great job in Gila County and.
|
01:38:24
|
|
We need to keep building on that. I do have a couple of questions.
|
01:38:29
|
|
The you know, the reading, the range, all the stuff that you listed.
|
01:38:34
|
|
Is all very vital to Heila County And then?
|
01:38:39
|
|
We're going to actually, I think, try and expand the shooting sports part of the 4H up here in the Northern party, Gila County.
|
01:38:43
|
|
And so it's all really great. Now I have a question, maybe this is something that Michael is going to deal with in the next
|
01:38:52
|
|
discussion, but when you said that all of the county contributions that we give so.
|
01:38:59
|
|
We have $70,000 we normally give.
|
01:39:08
|
|
To the Cooperative Extension.
|
01:39:11
|
|
There seems to be this year a fee of 26%.
|
01:39:16
|
|
To get that. And you said that all the money stays in Hua County, but I I'm really unclear about how that worked and why that's a
|
01:39:22
|
|
new thing.
|
01:39:27
|
|
So $18,000, right?
|
01:39:33
|
|
If I may start so. So the the difference is is that in the past we have had.
|
01:39:37
|
|
Single Page agreement, which basically has stated that Gila County will supply this amount of cash in support of Cooperative
|
01:39:43
|
|
Extension and.
|
01:39:47
|
|
Operative Extension will operate in Hilla County and it's a single page.
|
01:39:53
|
|
And basically the county would send a check and it would be deposited. This year, the county has requested an IGA, an
|
01:39:57
|
|
intergovernmental agreement.
|
01:40:02
|
|
As soon as we do that, that means that we have to include what we call sponsored projects, which is like the grant. And so it is
|
01:40:07
|
|
treated as a grant, no longer a direct deposit or direct support of Cooperative Extension.
|
01:40:14
|
|
All grants must go through sponsored project.
|
01:40:21
|
|
Since we are off.
|
01:40:24
|
|
I'm not on campus.
|
01:40:26
|
|
Our rate is 26% of indirect at the university would charge any other agency and the other entity in order to do business. If we
|
01:40:28
|
|
were on campus, it'd be 53 or some odd percent. So. So what we have done is we have this, if you want to call it, work around, we
|
01:40:34
|
|
have grandfathered it in. The folks at the university said OK, we'll let you do that. So the county's basically signed this one
|
01:40:41
|
|
page.
|
01:40:47
|
|
That they will give us whatever the amount is for each county and send us a check. And the university does not take a red set. So
|
01:40:55
|
|
because this year you're changing to an IGA, that's where we're losing the 26%.
|
01:41:02
|
|
OK, so I caught most of that like we said before the the.
|
01:41:12
|
|
The speaker appears a little garbled.
|
01:41:17
|
|
Mr. Martin, did you say that you're doing a workaround?
|
01:41:21
|
|
We have, we actually have been for the past.
|
01:41:23
|
|
I don't know how many years, Carolyn.
|
01:41:27
|
|
30 years had this what we call workaround and that workaround.
|
01:41:29
|
|
That you just signed an agreement saying you support Cooperative Extension and here is the amount.
|
01:41:34
|
|
This year you have asked that we have an IGA, an agreement, which? Which?
|
01:41:40
|
|
Forcing us to go through the sponsored project. So we we've we've had that before. I understand from Mr. from Mr. Menlov that
|
01:41:46
|
|
there is a reason.
|
01:41:52
|
|
This is this is happening this year and so he probably can better explain the reason why. But yes, in the past we have had a
|
01:41:58
|
|
simple agreement.
|
01:42:03
|
|
That you sign we.
|
01:42:08
|
|
There is no indirect cost associated.
|
01:42:11
|
|
OK. I appreciate that answer and.
|
01:42:15
|
|
So I just wanted to let you know that the.
|
01:42:19
|
|
Yes.
|
01:42:23
|
|
The IGA was recom.
|
01:42:25
|
|
By our legal team and.
|
01:42:27
|
|
It may affect the.
|
01:42:32
|
|
It may affect the I.
|
01:42:36
|
|
The idea of continuing our funding, I don't know if it will or not, but $18,200 just get skimmed off the top because it's it's a
|
01:42:41
|
|
different category, it's a grant now, right? And so anyway.
|
01:42:48
|
|
That's all I have, Mr. Chairman.
|
01:42:57
|
|
Mr. Chair.
|
01:42:59
|
|
Go ahead. Do you want to go first or you want to wait? Go ahead. OK.
|
01:43:01
|
|
How do you work with the other counties?
|
01:43:06
|
|
You you do. They do they have a process like what we've been working under all these years?
|
01:43:09
|
|
Or have they got you guys rolled into an IGA? Oh no, none of the other counties have IG's. So all the other counties now have the
|
01:43:15
|
|
same process. So the way I was the I was the county extension director for Maricopa County. So every year I in January I would
|
01:43:21
|
|
meet with the county supervisors. I give my plan of work what I plan to do next year. They talk to me all I think we need to do
|
01:43:27
|
|
this, we need to do that. Sounds good.
|
01:43:33
|
|
And then they basically would sign and give me the money would be sent over the next January. We'd look and say this is what you
|
01:43:39
|
|
promised that you did, How did you do? We did pretty good. I missed on this one. Let's work harder this year and that's so that's
|
01:43:45
|
|
how we've worked year in and year out. So all the other counties we do not have this issue.
|
01:43:51
|
|
OK.
|
01:43:58
|
|
If we enter an IGA with you, that kicks it into this other grant correct thing.
|
01:44:00
|
|
Is that by policy of U of A? Can it be waived?
|
01:44:06
|
|
Only if you have something on your website that states that, or in your policies that states that you do not pay any indirect cost
|
01:44:11
|
|
for any grants.
|
01:44:16
|
|
So if you pay no indirect costs to any grant or if you have some limit and you have it written down somewhere that's on the
|
01:44:21
|
|
website or publicly available that people can look up, we can ask for an exception, but we still would be whatever that that
|
01:44:26
|
|
amount is.
|
01:44:31
|
|
Because I I'm not speaking for Supervisor Christiansen, but for me personally, I don't like seeing anything go anywhere but on the
|
01:44:36
|
|
ground. So I I agree if I if I may, speak.
|
01:44:42
|
|
A little freely. You know the other option. It could be that instead of giving us yearly every six months that you send us, we
|
01:44:49
|
|
signed an agreement with you that.
|
01:44:53
|
|
And so it's split up so that it's not a full 70,000 all at one time.
|
01:44:59
|
|
Does that change the 18%?
|
01:45:03
|
|
It doesn't change the, it doesn't change the 18%, but it might change the requirement from the county to have an IGA.
|
01:45:07
|
|
And once again, only the covenant can answer that. That's getting, yeah, Mr. Chairman, Sue Roger Klein.
|
01:45:15
|
|
What that does is it brings up low 50,000, which enables the kind of manager to sign this agreement, which in that case does not
|
01:45:23
|
|
go through legal because it's below a certain threshold.
|
01:45:29
|
|
And in that case not going through legal I can sign it.
|
01:45:35
|
|
And sending the 35.
|
01:45:40
|
|
Every six months or something like that. So that's a technicality that's within HILA County's policies.
|
01:45:42
|
|
Which would work for us because we charge we only charge every every quarter.
|
01:45:50
|
|
OK, just a second.
|
01:45:56
|
|
Members of the board. So yes, we do have that technicality where it's not coming from the table, however in this situation has
|
01:46:00
|
|
already been presented to the County Attorney's office and we do have Arizona revised statute 11-952, which talks about two public
|
01:46:07
|
|
entities joining in a contractual agreement in that in that statute it does indicate the requirements of an agreement that needs
|
01:46:14
|
|
to be listed out.
|
01:46:22
|
|
One of the requirements is that it does need to go through legal.
|
01:46:29
|
|
And.
|
01:46:33
|
|
That would be a choice of the board if they want to utilize that process, but also for U of A's knowledge.
|
01:46:34
|
|
It should be reviewed by an attorney and approved. As to form. I'm not sure if they would have the ability to do that if the
|
01:46:42
|
|
actual IGA does not comply with the statute.
|
01:46:46
|
|
I don't know that I know the answer to that either. Hello, work sessions, a lot of things come out, a lot of visiting, a lot of
|
01:46:55
|
|
visiting gets done. I appreciate your presentation very much. I appreciate all that you do for us.
|
01:47:01
|
|
I'm certain in my opinion we'll continue working together. I'm just not sure how because I think it's a it's it's a great thing
|
01:47:10
|
|
for all of us. And so I I appreciate your presentation very much and I believe here.
|
01:47:17
|
|
Go ahead, Mr. Min.
|
01:47:24
|
|
Mr. Chairman, I want to reiterate from an admin point of view, I know that the board has spoken to you that you support this
|
01:47:27
|
|
Cooperative Extension and the work they do in Healing County. So there's not any question of.
|
01:47:33
|
|
And all that you do, all that you bring, and all that you the work that you've described.
|
01:47:40
|
|
That is appreciated and it is a great benefit to get accounting. There's no question of that as far as I'm concerned in the.
|
01:47:46
|
|
It's this IGA and stuff like that, that the technicalities that are in law.
|
01:47:55
|
|
That we are trying that we are trying to address that.
|
01:48:00
|
|
Where these questions have come up, and I think you're getting to it, Mr. Chairman, but Michael did have.
|
01:48:04
|
|
Some additional information to present.
|
01:48:11
|
|
Yeah, I I know I did see he introduced and sat down. So I appreciate very much and if if it stirs something after Mr. O'Driscoll
|
01:48:13
|
|
gives his presentation, you're you're more than welcome to come back up. And so thank you very much.
|
01:48:22
|
|
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the Board, I'll be brief so.
|
01:48:32
|
|
In order to get a bigger financial picture of what Gila County provides the Cooperative Extension, what I did is I worked with our
|
01:48:37
|
|
facilities, team and.
|
01:48:42
|
|
A marrow and the fleet team to sort of collect some.
|
01:48:48
|
|
Resources that we provide the Cooperative Extension. So the big majority of the resources we provide are at the two locations, one
|
01:48:52
|
|
in Central Heights, the office buildings out there and then up in Payson. And then we calculated an estimate. This is just an
|
01:48:57
|
|
estimate of an annual.
|
01:49:03
|
|
Total cost in rent.
|
01:49:10
|
|
Water, sewer, trash, parking spaces, those kinds of things.
|
01:49:14
|
|
Comes up for a total for both of those locations is about $80,000 a year.
|
01:49:18
|
|
If you add up all of that, and that's just a rough estimate, we didn't really get down in the weeds too much with that.
|
01:49:26
|
|
And also Fleet does provide and maintain the University of Arizona's vehicles.
|
01:49:32
|
|
But Numero did let me know that.
|
01:49:39
|
|
Currently Fleet is building them full cost for labor.
|
01:49:41
|
|
The hourly labor cost includes the labor and load as well, so they're maintaining it, but they're also billing the University of
|
01:49:46
|
|
Arizona for those costs.
|
01:49:51
|
|
So we did not include costs such as some of sometimes our facilities, personnel assist, the University of Arizona putting together
|
01:49:56
|
|
furniture, those kinds of things. I sort of left that out because that wasn't a big part of some of the resources we provide the
|
01:50:01
|
|
rent.
|
01:50:07
|
|
And the utilities are the major part. So it's about 80,000. I'll be happy to answer any questions.
|
01:50:13
|
|
Go ahead and provide.
|
01:50:21
|
|
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
|
01:50:23
|
|
Radio.
|
01:50:28
|
|
Michael, I think, I think for me personally you know knowing that that would be a cost that that that we that we have out there
|
01:50:29
|
|
that we provide.
|
01:50:33
|
|
Personally, the benefit that we get back from EU of A and for what it's done for Gila County through all the years up to currently
|
01:50:37
|
|
and what it's going to do in the future, I think is a cheap price.
|
01:50:42
|
|
And that's where I'm at. It's, it's.
|
01:50:49
|
|
If anything, the what?
|
01:50:52
|
|
What they've done already just in in one part of it, well, two parts of it 4H program and the reading the range program is
|
01:50:55
|
|
absolutely huge.
|
01:51:00
|
|
For.
|
01:51:05
|
|
And in the way it went and what it is saved our constituents that are in those areas is I don't know how you put a value on it. So
|
01:51:07
|
|
when I look at a if if it cost us $80,000 to support somebody.
|
01:51:13
|
|
That works with our constituents like they have done for all these years and continue to do. I personally look at that as a non
|
01:51:20
|
|
issue to me.
|
01:51:24
|
|
If it has something to do with the audits that we've had in the past, I don't mind showing it, but I would never want to charge
|
01:51:31
|
|
it.
|
01:51:35
|
|
You know, I, you know, we can show it as contributed or however we need to do it to show that this is what we're doing. But I
|
01:51:40
|
|
would never want to see that money coming back to us out of the.
|
01:51:46
|
|
I just don't think, you know, Mr. Martin talked and he's absolutely right. You can't.
|
01:51:52
|
|
I don't know where you'd even start to put a value on on the help of for our constituents that EU of A has been through all these
|
01:51:58
|
|
years.
|
01:52:02
|
|
And so that's where I would sit on all this. I look at EU of A and always have as a as a huge partner, you know, especially to the
|
01:52:06
|
|
agriculture side of things.
|
01:52:11
|
|
Which?
|
01:52:16
|
|
Umm, kids in 4H programs, all of that NRCD stuff, the whole 9 yards. U of A has always been kind of right there behind us all, if
|
01:52:18
|
|
not in front and so I think when it comes to.
|
01:52:25
|
|
Space rent how you want to do it? I don't.
|
01:52:32
|
|
I don't, I don't want to ever see us have to take a dollar from these folks. I don't mind showing that it's contributed, but I
|
01:52:37
|
|
don't want to ever see us take a dollar from that, so.
|
01:52:42
|
|
That would be my two cents worth. Thank you, Michael. Thank you Supervisor Christensen.
|
01:52:48
|
|
Thank you, Chairman and thank you, Michael.
|
01:52:54
|
|
Kind of.
|
01:52:58
|
|
Sticky things.
|
01:53:00
|
|
Mr. Martin said that none of the other counties are doing IGA, so I guess my only concern is before this ever comes to a vote
|
01:53:02
|
|
before us.
|
01:53:07
|
|
That there would be an exploration by staff to see whether or not.
|
01:53:12
|
|
There there is something else that we could look at.
|
01:53:18
|
|
And just go from there. But I I also agree very much that this is a very needed program and benefits Gila County tremendously.
|
01:53:22
|
|
Thank you.
|
01:53:32
|
|
OK, my $0.02.
|
01:53:36
|
|
When I stepped in as supervisor, there was a lot of policies and procedures that.
|
01:53:39
|
|
On.
|
01:53:45
|
|
We were seven years behind in our state audits, which kept us away from a lot of grants and things.
|
01:53:47
|
|
We've done a lot of work to catch up our audits, our staff has.
|
01:53:53
|
|
We've done a lot of work to step up for our policies and procedures.
|
01:53:59
|
|
Are above.
|
01:54:04
|
|
I understand all that's being done for us. I appreciate it very much.
|
01:54:07
|
|
And if and if staff and legal thinks that an IGA is important?
|
01:54:11
|
|
Then that's something that we need to workout with.
|
01:54:19
|
|
And and and as far as costs and things, I understand there's no way to put costs on, on the benefits that we get.
|
01:54:22
|
|
But we also have to remain legal and we have to remain.
|
01:54:32
|
|
Level with our audits for the benefits of.
|
01:54:38
|
|
And to keep ourselves out of lawsuits for our general public.
|
01:54:42
|
|
And so I appreciate this work session.
|
01:54:47
|
|
And I know that staff will work and bringing up the fact that we could do it differently.
|
01:54:51
|
|
And stay away from an IGA. Well now the legal team is is already looking at this and so you know.
|
01:54:57
|
|
We do not want to leave our backsides open.
|
01:55:04
|
|
Umm, either. And so I appreciate everything that that's being done.
|
01:55:08
|
|
With the the what you provide us with and I appreciate what staff's doing and I and I'm I'm grateful for this work session so so
|
01:55:15
|
|
you're able to come and present to us and I I appreciate the the work that staff has put in two different costs and things to help
|
01:55:22
|
|
us make.
|
01:55:29
|
|
A better decision as we set with with our attorneys and our accountants and to to make sure that that we continue our good work.
|
01:55:36
|
|
But it but it benefits all of us and and that we're not we're not doing something that.
|
01:55:45
|
|
Might not be completely above board whether the other counties do it or don't do it. We do things that other counties don't. So
|
01:55:51
|
|
it's it's whatever whatever your counting attorney will support you in is what you're recommended to do. And so I appreciate this
|
01:56:00
|
|
work session and all the input of this work session and I guess Mr. Minogue did you have something to add on this one?
|
01:56:08
|
|
Just.
|
01:56:18
|
|
Based on your input.
|
01:56:20
|
|
When?
|
01:56:22
|
|
What I would do is I can reach out to the auditor general's office.
|
01:56:23
|
|
And pose this question, it's it's not like, well, do we want to open ourselves up to the Auditor General? Well, they they know.
|
01:56:28
|
|
And to say, how are you addressing this and what is your recommendation?
|
01:56:35
|
|
Based on their recommendation of covering all.
|
01:56:39
|
|
All 15 counties for the state. What would their recommendation be and try to get their input so I can bring that back to you as a
|
01:56:43
|
|
board and say this is what the Auditor General is telling us to that we're going to work with the county attorneys?
|
01:56:49
|
|
And the auditor general's office and bring that information to you as a board.
|
01:56:55
|
|
If that would be acceptable.
|
01:57:00
|
|
Next step for us is the.
|
01:57:02
|
|
We can only make decisions.
|
01:57:06
|
|
On the information that we receive, so so the more, the better information that we receive.
|
01:57:09
|
|
We can have better decisions made from it. Jessica please VICE Chair, members of the.
|
01:57:16
|
|
So if it was broken down into semesters, I just want to clarify that it would go through the county manager. It would not require
|
01:57:24
|
|
approval as to form by myself. I've already provided my recommendation, so at that point it would bypass the county attorney's
|
01:57:31
|
|
office and so therefore you would just be looking at the recommendation of the auditor.
|
01:57:38
|
|
Yes, thank you very.
|
01:57:45
|
|
So you know these these work sessions are to give us all guidance.
|
01:57:48
|
|
And I believe with the discussions today that we that we have guidance to go forward. So if there's nothing else supervisor client
|
01:57:52
|
|
that that brought up a question for me, James, you know in the years past as.
|
01:57:58
|
|
But you know, as we're going through these audits and what Supervisor Humphrey said about our audits were true, we're way behind.
|
01:58:05
|
|
Is a huge nightmare for our for our staff, but.
|
01:58:11
|
|
Was there ever anything said about the way we were supporting U of A through any of these audits, I mean or do you think they just
|
01:58:18
|
|
didn't see it or?
|
01:58:23
|
|
I mean, it went through everything with a pretty fine tooth comb for the most part.
|
01:58:31
|
|
Mr. Chairman, Stuart.
|
01:58:36
|
|
As a recovering auditor myself.
|
01:58:39
|
|
I I really can't speak to the other, but I am going to make.
|
01:58:46
|
|
The issues with Gila County were so big.
|
01:58:51
|
|
That you want to get to the point where either county is auditable, meaning that they can actually come in and perform an audit,
|
01:58:54
|
|
make a declaration on whether our financial statements are accurate and truthfully.
|
01:59:00
|
|
And that is their intent.
|
01:59:07
|
|
Until they get to that point where?
|
01:59:10
|
|
Take a look at our financial position as a whole.
|
01:59:13
|
|
The other.
|
01:59:17
|
|
It's always relevant, but you could only bite off so much of the elephant at a time.
|
01:59:20
|
|
And.
|
01:59:26
|
|
Correct and get things better.
|
01:59:28
|
|
Some of these other things that may not have come to the surface, they do so.
|
01:59:31
|
|
And so we're at that point. We are caught up.
|
01:59:37
|
|
Thank you.
|
01:59:40
|
|
And team, but we are caught up and.
|
01:59:41
|
|
They are digging deeper.
|
01:59:47
|
|
And have many discussions with Marin about that. They are digging deeper and they are looking.
|
01:59:50
|
|
Individual transactions such as.
|
01:59:57
|
|
Determine.
|
02:00:01
|
|
According to law, like Jessica said, is everything.
|
02:00:03
|
|
Clear and evident in our financial statement that everything is disclosed as it should be.
|
02:00:09
|
|
And that's where these issues are now coming up because we have improved so much in our financial reporting. Does that answer your
|
02:00:14
|
|
question?
|
02:00:18
|
|
It did not. Not quite the answer as one, but it did. Yeah. Thank you, James.
|
02:00:23
|
|
OK. If there's nothing else, I'll move forward. Michael, thank you very much for all you.
|
02:00:29
|
|
I'd like to thank the University of Arizona Cooperative team for coming up here and taking the time for the presentation. They've
|
02:00:36
|
|
been extremely helpful working with them to provide the information to you, so.
|
02:00:41
|
|
Yeah, it's. I have a lot of public meetings and it's great to get everybody in a room because things come up.
|
02:00:49
|
|
And discussions that wouldn't come up otherwise that can help an outcome change. So I appreciate your willingness to to come to a
|
02:00:56
|
|
work session. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. OK.
|
02:01:04
|
|
Moving on to.
|
02:01:12
|
|
Information discussion regarding library services that are provided to community members in Gila County and how the Gila County
|
02:01:17
|
|
Library District facilitates.
|
02:01:23
|
|
No facilitates these services. Elaine, thank you very much. No, I was making sure I didn't mess up. Trust me, I didn't make.
|
02:01:33
|
|
You're good. All right. Thank you. Chairman Christensen, Vice Chairman Humphrey and Supervisor Klein. I'm here today to provide
|
02:01:44
|
|
you with information on the Hewlett County Library District, our seven affiliates on Branch.
|
02:01:51
|
|
And the free services and resources we have to offer our community.
|
02:01:58
|
|
So Hill County Library District partners with libraries in Gila County and we have one branch like everything else, we're divided
|
02:02:07
|
|
from north to South. We've got 4 libraries in the north, which is Payson, Isabel Hunt, which is the Pine Library, Tano Basin and
|
02:02:12
|
|
Young.
|
02:02:17
|
|
And in the South, we have Globe, Miami, San Carlos and Hayden.
|
02:02:22
|
|
And we have a new partnership with the San Carlos Library and the San Carlos Apache College.
|
02:02:27
|
|
We just recently moved into the same facility with them. Our old building was been out there condemned, it's been condemned. The
|
02:02:32
|
|
last rain they had, the light fixture fell down. So I was really glad that we were out of the building and we had a grand opening
|
02:02:38
|
|
in the middle of October. And we are currently and have been doing, adding the collection for the college into our database with
|
02:02:44
|
|
the rest of our public collection. So you can look in and see what collection they have along with all of our Public Library
|
02:02:50
|
|
collections.
|
02:02:56
|
|
All right, Libraries are more than books. They foster community through programming and activities. Libraries work hard to provide
|
02:03:04
|
|
free activities and programming for their patrons to come together.
|
02:03:09
|
|
To learn and have fun in a healthy and safe environment.
|
02:03:14
|
|
Libraries continue to partner and collaborate with other organizations and entities. They regularly partner with other entities.
|
02:03:18
|
|
Promote health.
|
02:03:21
|
|
Wellness and information that benefits the patrons and communities they serve.
|
02:03:25
|
|
There's free access to technology assistance, computers, printing, faxing, scanning, free Wi-Fi 24/7, and digital resources such
|
02:03:30
|
|
as our ebooks, our audiobooks and much more.
|
02:03:36
|
|
Libraries, librarians, and staff are there to help direct and assist you to find resources that fit your needs and most
|
02:03:42
|
|
importantly, they provide a safe space for everyone who enters their doors.
|
02:03:47
|
|
The Hema County Library District partners with each library to provide computer workstations for the.
|
02:03:55
|
|
These workstations are connected to the Internet as well as to our ebooks. Our databases and our resources and computers are
|
02:04:00
|
|
available to all ages, including children because that the little guys that come in parents are available to help them and learn
|
02:04:08
|
|
to use the computers appropriately. We are also SIPA compliant, which is the Children's Internet Protection Act.
|
02:04:16
|
|
And as you all know, we now have Internet, fiber Internet to all of our libraries and schools in Gila County. The last connection
|
02:04:24
|
|
was completed in.
|
02:04:29
|
|
The 1st of June of this year. Hurrah, hurrah. Big accomplishment.
|
02:04:33
|
|
The Hill County Library District understands the importance of early literacy. Public libraries across America have adopted the
|
02:04:40
|
|
concept of talking, singing, reading, writing and playing through the early to the Every Child Ready to Read initiative.
|
02:04:46
|
|
This program was created by the Public Library Association and the Association for Library Services to Children.
|
02:04:53
|
|
Through their early literacy programs, the Gila County Libraries promote and insert these concepts into their story times and
|
02:04:59
|
|
activities for children.
|
02:05:03
|
|
Additionally, during these programs, parents are instructed on simple.
|
02:05:08
|
|
As fun activities to help prepare their children for.
|
02:05:12
|
|
It's not the wrong way.
|
02:05:19
|
|
The next we have is the Dolly Parton Imagination Library, and through a partnership with The First things first, we provide a free
|
02:05:22
|
|
book for all children that are residents of Gila County from birth to age 5.
|
02:05:28
|
|
They received one book in the mail each month until they turn 5. If they started the program when they were a baby and they were
|
02:05:34
|
|
first born, they had about 60 books in their private library at home and these are all age appropriate books that as they grow and
|
02:05:40
|
|
get a little bit older, so do the books.
|
02:05:45
|
|
And this really cool thing is that the books are actually addressed to the child and not the parents. So that's an awesome thing.
|
02:05:51
|
|
A lot of the kids are just waiting every month for that that mailman to come and bring them their book.
|
02:05:56
|
|
Ways to sign up for the Dolly Parton Imagination Library? We do have access online. You can do it online, you can grab a brochure
|
02:06:03
|
|
at any of the libraries and mail it in, Give it back to the library, or you can call our office and we can get you signed up on
|
02:06:07
|
|
the phone.
|
02:06:12
|
|
So our Act One Culture passes are in the library. The Act One Culture Pass will give you and one guest free entry into any of the
|
02:06:19
|
|
participating sites as soon as you can see. We've got a few examples up there, The Reed Park in Tucson, we've got the Desert
|
02:06:25
|
|
Botanical Garden, The Cave Creek Museum, just to name a few. These passes are available for checkout in the libraries only that
|
02:06:31
|
|
you can visit our website and check the availability in your library. There's a total of 19 organizations that you can choose
|
02:06:37
|
|
from.
|
02:06:43
|
|
And as always and everywhere, there are a few rules.
|
02:06:50
|
|
You must have a current library card.
|
02:06:54
|
|
You can't put holds on the passes. You have to go into the library and what they have available that day is what you can check
|
02:06:56
|
|
out.
|
02:06:59
|
|
And you can only check out one culture pass per library card every seven days. And I will mention that this is actually Act One's
|
02:07:03
|
|
policies, not just our library policies.
|
02:07:08
|
|
So to learn more, you can always call the library or again you can always look on our best site.
|
02:07:13
|
|
Your.
|
02:07:17
|
|
So we have two different kinds of.
|
02:07:19
|
|
And what's the difference? Well, our first one is our E Resource card. And this gives you digital access to all of our things
|
02:07:22
|
|
online, including ebooks, the audio magazines and all of our databases that we have. You just simply can go online, fill out the
|
02:07:29
|
|
application and you can get your cards and we'll get it sent to you and give you the number off through an e-mail that you can do.
|
02:07:36
|
|
A full access card is actually one that you have to go into the library to get. You have to prove residency, and it gives you
|
02:07:44
|
|
access to absolutely everything that we've got, including what the resource card does. So you could check out the books,
|
02:07:49
|
|
magazines, CVS can use the computers.
|
02:07:54
|
|
But you do need to go to the library and prove your residency.
|
02:08:00
|
|
The Hill County Library District provides you with access to a wide selection of books.
|
02:08:05
|
|
By visiting her OPEC on the website, you can reserve and check out books online from any of our 8 libraries and pick them up at
|
02:08:10
|
|
your preferred location. That's what we call. If you are looking for a book you're hearing Globe and you found it in Payson, you
|
02:08:15
|
|
don't have to drive all the way to Payson. You can put it on reserve. It's called Interlibrary Loan and I get to be the red bag
|
02:08:21
|
|
Courier, so I get to bring the book from Payson back to Globe.
|
02:08:27
|
|
So it's a service that we we use a lot. People use it a lot in the libraries.
|
02:08:34
|
|
If you're not at your desk.
|
02:08:39
|
|
You can use.
|
02:08:41
|
|
Device any of your applications, your phone and download our La Brista app. And you can do all that on your phone just as well.
|
02:08:43
|
|
We also have a wonderful collection of ebooks, the audio and E magazines that you can access via our catalog.
|
02:08:54
|
|
Did the overguys side or through the app? If you're an e-reader and you love listening to audiobooks, and I do that since I drive
|
02:09:00
|
|
enough, I possibly have an audiobook in the car. You could download it onto your device and take it with you wherever you go.
|
02:09:07
|
|
And if you look up on the right hand part of the list, we have what we buy through OverDrive with our own funding, but we also
|
02:09:15
|
|
have an agreement with our partner libraries within the state.
|
02:09:20
|
|
That if you find a book that you want, say at the Tempe library.
|
02:09:25
|
|
And as long as it's available, you can download their copy and read it as well. The only difference is that you can't put anything
|
02:09:30
|
|
on hold with another library, you can only do that from hours.
|
02:09:35
|
|
We have many digital resources and GAIL is an online learning database with a lot to offer. Adults and children is both a tool and
|
02:09:44
|
|
a resource for the academic, the high schooler, the elementary school student.
|
02:09:50
|
|
The student appearance or anyone for additional learning resources. There are peer reviewed articles, full text, magazine and
|
02:09:57
|
|
newspapers, primary sources, videos and podcasts.
|
02:10:03
|
|
So what it might be of interest to some of you is if any of you are car mechanics and you kind of remember when I'm dating myself
|
02:10:10
|
|
back in the day when you had to go to the library and get the children's mechanic books, remember those guys?
|
02:10:16
|
|
Bin.
|
02:10:23
|
|
They were.
|
02:10:24
|
|
And they're expensive to buy for the libraries. Well, now that's all online. So the only difference between that and going to
|
02:10:25
|
|
YouTube for that information is you can get the schematics that you're looking for. If it's a wiring schematic or something, you
|
02:10:30
|
|
can get that on Chilton online instead of going and trying to hunt for it on on YouTube. So that's just a couple of the things
|
02:10:35
|
|
that we have.
|
02:10:40
|
|
With our databases and you can see lots of other additional things up there as well.
|
02:10:45
|
|
One of them that I'm really excited about is called Learning Express, and it's a great resource for the elementary, high school,
|
02:10:53
|
|
college students and adults. The Learning Express library can help you pursue your PED, providing practice tests, tutorials,
|
02:10:58
|
|
ebooks, study, interact.
|
02:11:03
|
|
In language.
|
02:11:08
|
|
Math, science and social studies and I had a great conversation with actually someone for library yesterday.
|
02:11:09
|
|
Her son was doing the GED testing through the county, and he's passed all of his courses but math.
|
02:11:15
|
|
And he's had a horrible time.
|
02:11:22
|
|
So she actually went on to Learning Express yesterday and thought, I'm going to take that test and see if I can pass it. She's
|
02:11:24
|
|
been out of school for quite some time and she said I just barely passed.
|
02:11:29
|
|
She says. But at least I look to see what he's looking at, what he needs to know, and the tutorials that I'm going to show him to
|
02:11:35
|