|
Everyone, It's just about 9:00. Ten o'clock.
|
00:00:02
|
|
It'd be a good meeting.
|
00:00:07
|
|
Tuesday, February 20th, I'd like to call this meeting to order, and if you would, let's all stand for the pledge. Marian is going
|
00:00:09
|
|
to offer the pledge and then Nick Montague is going to offer our prayer.
|
00:00:15
|
|
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God,
|
00:00:23
|
|
indivisible, with liberty and justice.
|
00:00:30
|
|
For.
|
00:00:36
|
|
Dearly father.
|
00:00:42
|
|
We're thankful for a Board of Supervisors to be able to meet, and we're thankful for the decisions they're able to make. And we.
|
00:00:44
|
|
Are thankful for the county employees who spent so much time helping.
|
00:00:51
|
|
Citizens Field County and we ask the.
|
00:00:56
|
|
Help her spirit to be with them. They won't make the best choices that.
|
00:00:59
|
|
And say these things the name Jesus Christ, Amen.
|
00:01:03
|
|
He's be.
|
00:01:07
|
|
OK, so.
|
00:01:08
|
|
Our first presentation.
|
00:01:12
|
|
Is with Erica Raymond, so it's item 2.
|
00:01:16
|
|
A recognition of Gila County employ.
|
00:01:23
|
|
Who have been employed for 5101520253035 and 40 years.
|
00:01:26
|
|
That's a long time to be with the county. So Erica, just guide us through this and we'll we want to take some pictures and
|
00:01:34
|
|
recognize our employees for all that they do.
|
00:01:39
|
|
So if you all don't mind coming.
|
00:01:45
|
|
In front. As mentioned, this is a nomination or this is recognition of those employees who've been employed in 2023.
|
00:01:48
|
|
We are asking that you all hang out a moment just for a group photo afterwards.
|
00:01:59
|
|
We do have some light refreshments and we are asking that pause be held until the end.
|
00:02:05
|
|
And with no further ado, we'll get started.
|
00:02:12
|
|
So for our five years with the county, we have Ryan Alcorn.
|
00:02:15
|
|
Jamie Lynn Anderson.
|
00:02:22
|
|
Stephen Armstrong.
|
00:02:25
|
|
Bianca.
|
00:02:28
|
|
And if you would like to come up and get your item and party, something like that.
|
00:02:31
|
|
Eric Avalos.
|
00:02:37
|
|
Marin Bell.
|
00:02:44
|
|
Ashley.
|
00:02:47
|
|
Candice.
|
00:02:51
|
|
And we'll take a group photo outside. That way you also.
|
00:02:59
|
|
Apologize. I am Candice car.
|
00:03:03
|
|
Melissa Cervant.
|
00:03:08
|
|
Kenneth.
|
00:03:10
|
|
Stacy Espin.
|
00:03:13
|
|
Daniel.
|
00:03:16
|
|
Justin Gillesp.
|
00:03:19
|
|
Megan Holly.
|
00:03:22
|
|
Katie.
|
00:03:25
|
|
Anna Marie Lo.
|
00:03:27
|
|
Lacey.
|
00:03:29
|
|
Dylan Mojica.
|
00:03:30
|
|
Terry Morrell.
|
00:03:33
|
|
Sorry, Anna Marie.
|
00:03:37
|
|
Then Lacey.
|
00:03:44
|
|
Kimberly O'Rourke.
|
00:03:59
|
|
Rebecca Phillips.
|
00:04:03
|
|
Randall Plum.
|
00:04:06
|
|
Destiny Ro.
|
00:04:09
|
|
Dan Rodrigue.
|
00:04:14
|
|
Chevelle.
|
00:04:18
|
|
Charles Feline.
|
00:04:22
|
|
Amy, stay.
|
00:04:25
|
|
Karen Whiting.
|
00:04:31
|
|
And Paul Walter back.
|
00:04:33
|
|
And that concludes our five.
|
00:04:36
|
|
And next we have our 10 year employees.
|
00:04:45
|
|
We have Bradley Beauchamp.
|
00:04:49
|
|
Stephanie Ch.
|
00:04:52
|
|
Michael Hill.
|
00:04:58
|
|
Betty.
|
00:05:02
|
|
Daniel Irish.
|
00:05:05
|
|
Congratulations.
|
00:05:19
|
|
Daniel.
|
00:05:22
|
|
Steve McFarland.
|
00:05:25
|
|
Paul Miller.
|
00:05:29
|
|
Crystal Montana.
|
00:05:31
|
|
Janet Ostrom.
|
00:05:37
|
|
Patricia.
|
00:05:40
|
|
Patricia.
|
00:05:50
|
|
Brian.
|
00:05:53
|
|
Christian Rosales.
|
00:05:58
|
|
John Shepherd.
|
00:06:03
|
|
Jeff.
|
00:06:06
|
|
Rebecca Taylor.
|
00:06:09
|
|
Allison Tor.
|
00:06:11
|
|
And Scott Warren. And that concludes our ten years.
|
00:06:14
|
|
Next up we have 15 years with account.
|
00:06:20
|
|
We have Brenda Cov.
|
00:06:23
|
|
Lisa.
|
00:06:27
|
|
Brenda Co.
|
00:06:30
|
|
Congratulations.
|
00:06:35
|
|
Joel McDaniel.
|
00:06:42
|
|
Christopher McGrath.
|
00:06:46
|
|
4 nothing.
|
00:06:52
|
|
And Nancy Rutherford.
|
00:06:56
|
|
And that concludes our 15 years with.
|
00:06:58
|
|
With our twenty year employees we have Estelle Velarde.
|
00:07:08
|
|
Christine.
|
00:07:17
|
|
Athena. Good.
|
00:07:22
|
|
Rebecca Guard.
|
00:07:30
|
|
Yvette Hoffman.
|
00:07:37
|
|
Paula Horn.
|
00:07:40
|
|
Terry.
|
00:07:48
|
|
And Sarah White.
|
00:07:57
|
|
For 25 years we have Cynthia cost.
|
00:08:03
|
|
Roy Lean Muse.
|
00:08:15
|
|
And Lindy TR.
|
00:08:18
|
|
Moving on.
|
00:08:31
|
|
Moving to our 30 year employees, we have Amelia Baxley.
|
00:08:34
|
|
Julie Picardo home.
|
00:08:40
|
|
John Costanetta.
|
00:08:48
|
|
In 10 years.
|
00:08:51
|
|
I worked together and the last few.
|
00:09:31
|
|
Lastly, we have Tim.
|
00:09:43
|
|
For 35 years we have Sylvia Hernandez.
|
00:09:48
|
|
And for 40 years we have Jonelle Dreamer.
|
00:09:53
|
|
Anybody.
|
00:10:16
|
|
Feel like I'm on a red carpet.
|
00:10:32
|
|
And that does conclude our meeting. If you don't mind, we'll head out to the front for a group photo.
|
00:10:38
|
|
You look here.
|
00:10:51
|
|
Have a public hearing about item 3A.
|
00:10:56
|
|
Is that what this is for? Samantha, This is Greg Barsness who wants to speak. No, this will be at the end.
|
00:11:02
|
|
OK. Thank you.
|
00:11:09
|
|
All right. I need a motion to recess as the view accounting Board of Supervisors and convene as the Gila County Flood Control
|
00:11:11
|
|
District Board of Directors. So moved Mr. Chair. I'll second that. OK. Moved. And a second all those in favor say aye. Aye.
|
00:11:18
|
|
OK, so we're going to be talking information, discussion and action to approve the amended Gila County floodplain management
|
00:11:27
|
|
ordinance.
|
00:11:31
|
|
And guard, I think you.
|
00:11:35
|
|
Mr. Chairman, members of the Board, I'm glad to be here with you.
|
00:11:41
|
|
And glad to be presenting this.
|
00:11:45
|
|
Amendment to the Floodplain Management Ordinance. 7th amendment has been done since the original.
|
00:11:49
|
|
1986 / a few years.
|
00:11:55
|
|
We'll go through and.
|
00:11:59
|
|
Usually it's after.
|
00:12:02
|
|
The state or FEMA state does it on behalf of FEMA does it?
|
00:12:04
|
|
Basically an audit.
|
00:12:08
|
|
Way we manage the flood insurance program and the regulations that they require.
|
00:12:12
|
|
For us to have that available to our citizens.
|
00:12:19
|
|
And this time?
|
00:12:23
|
|
It's nothing.
|
00:12:26
|
|
We've got a few changes.
|
00:12:28
|
|
That they have requested.
|
00:12:31
|
|
And.
|
00:12:35
|
|
Saw a few things that we needed to.
|
00:12:39
|
|
Fix to make it.
|
00:12:42
|
|
For our residents to understand what they.
|
00:12:45
|
|
Needed to do.
|
00:12:49
|
|
So we did have a work session on this already.
|
00:12:51
|
|
Do you want me to kind of go over the significant changes again or let me ask the other gentleman, Supervisor Humphrey, do you
|
00:12:58
|
|
need a more detail?
|
00:13:02
|
|
I I've I've looked at this so I pretty much understand.
|
00:13:06
|
|
Where we're going and what we're doing, I guess my.
|
00:13:10
|
|
My main point is that those major changes are on our website.
|
00:13:15
|
|
So those of our constituents who would like to see the significant changes.
|
00:13:20
|
|
Can go see those, but for me, I I know of them and I've gone over them with you. So I think it would just be important for my
|
00:13:26
|
|
constituents to be able to see them. Other than that, I'm the chairman.
|
00:13:32
|
|
Mr. Klein.
|
00:13:40
|
|
So I remember when we had this discussion that came out in front of us, I kind of wanted.
|
00:13:42
|
|
More on that, but I probably can just sit down with you.
|
00:13:48
|
|
In person, garden and visit about some of it. I don't have that good of a feel for these changes on this.
|
00:13:52
|
|
And so I am going to need some more information, especially for my constituents, when I get in those meetings.
|
00:14:00
|
|
And I have those questions asked. Um.
|
00:14:05
|
|
You know, it's like I've said before, the floodplain issues is very, very important to Hena County.
|
00:14:09
|
|
And we all live in.
|
00:14:15
|
|
And so I want to make sure I have a good grasp of it.
|
00:14:18
|
|
I'd be glad to meet with you sometime.
|
00:14:23
|
|
We don't have, you know, today's pretty well packed and everything and so I think, I think by sitting down with you I can.
|
00:14:26
|
|
I can get a better feel for what we're going to do, whether I agree with it or not, I guess.
|
00:14:32
|
|
OK, one item from.
|
00:14:38
|
|
Work session that you brought.
|
00:14:41
|
|
The issue of variances issued for violations.
|
00:14:44
|
|
And I.
|
00:14:49
|
|
That with Mr. Dalton from the county attorney's office.
|
00:14:51
|
|
It looks like the way that the state redlined it is that.
|
00:14:56
|
|
Basically.
|
00:15:01
|
|
The Floodplain administrator the.
|
00:15:03
|
|
Is not.
|
00:15:06
|
|
Offer that as an as a solution to solving a violation they're trying supposed to try.
|
00:15:08
|
|
Compliance with the regulations.
|
00:15:17
|
|
However.
|
00:15:20
|
|
If you as the.
|
00:15:21
|
|
Receive a request.
|
00:15:23
|
|
If I receive a request to pass on to you, then that goes on. That does go on to you and there's no problem with whatever action
|
00:15:25
|
|
you want to take.
|
00:15:30
|
|
Well, that's a half a step in the right direction as far as I'm concerned. Guard and nothing against you as the Director of Flood
|
00:15:38
|
|
Pain and all that, but to me it's like when our constituents have a problem with something, it should be up to us to offer some
|
00:15:43
|
|
guidance if nothing else.
|
00:15:47
|
|
You know, within our statutory limits. That's that's the way I look at things.
|
00:15:52
|
|
So I guess, yeah.
|
00:15:57
|
|
Or just that little bit bitty step ahead of what we were when we last had this discussion. But.
|
00:16:00
|
|
You know the thing that is, if our constituents don't know that, how are they to learn that? How are they? How are they to figure
|
00:16:10
|
|
that out if you can't?
|
00:16:13
|
|
Give them some.
|
00:16:17
|
|
Idea.
|
00:16:20
|
|
Yeah.
|
00:16:22
|
|
It's in the ordinance and we can refer them to the ordinance.
|
00:16:26
|
|
We're not supposed to promote that.
|
00:16:30
|
|
I guess if they ask.
|
00:16:33
|
|
Well explain.
|
00:16:36
|
|
At least that's that's the desire.
|
00:16:38
|
|
The state had when they redlined that in.
|
00:16:43
|
|
Getting started. I think Mr. Dalton's got something he wants to tell me.
|
00:16:45
|
|
Help. So I'm reading.
|
00:16:50
|
|
Code of Federal Regulations.
|
00:16:54
|
|
44 CFR 60.6 about variances.
|
00:16:59
|
|
Hold variances and except.
|
00:17:03
|
|
And then?
|
00:17:06
|
|
The Federal Insurance Administrator may.
|
00:17:08
|
|
A community's findings or in this case, a county's findings.
|
00:17:12
|
|
Justifying the granting of variances.
|
00:17:16
|
|
And if that review indicates a pattern inconsistent with the objectives of sound floodplain management?
|
00:17:18
|
|
The federal insurance admin.
|
00:17:25
|
|
Administered and they take appropriate action.
|
00:17:27
|
|
Under and then he goes on to site more law about that action. So.
|
00:17:30
|
|
The thing about variances is that it's not really the same.
|
00:17:35
|
|
Directing someone to a provision.
|
00:17:39
|
|
Floodplain ordinance that would allow them to take a certain procedure. Variances are a unique.
|
00:17:43
|
|
Kind of thing there. Waiver.
|
00:17:49
|
|
Given to somebody telling them they don't have to follow the law that everybody else has to follow.
|
00:17:51
|
|
And those.
|
00:17:57
|
|
Pretty dramatic kinds of things.
|
00:17:58
|
|
When the administrator or the legislative body of the county.
|
00:18:02
|
|
We're giving you a waiver. We have an ordinance and everybody has to follow it.
|
00:18:07
|
|
You don't, that's.
|
00:18:11
|
|
And then with the Court of Federal Regulations is telling us is.
|
00:18:13
|
|
If the insurance administrator.
|
00:18:18
|
|
The granting of variances, and that's plural. That have to be a number of them.
|
00:18:21
|
|
Is inconsistent with the objectives of sound floodplain management.
|
00:18:26
|
|
They're going to.
|
00:18:32
|
|
I think that action is going to be negative action against the county, which is just going to have an effect on the insurance
|
00:18:34
|
|
rates.
|
00:18:37
|
|
That everybody's.
|
00:18:41
|
|
In Canada and so they don't like.
|
00:18:43
|
|
Too many of these that are inconsistent with what they think is is a sound floodplain management.
|
00:18:47
|
|
Or it's jeopardizing the insurance for everybody.
|
00:18:53
|
|
In the county and that's that's why it's a little different to say to.
|
00:18:57
|
|
Well here you need to read this section. The code understand what you do here.
|
00:19:01
|
|
Or in the alternative and say, you know, you can go to us as a legislature and we can give you a waiver.
|
00:19:06
|
|
Or you don't have to follow this law.
|
00:19:12
|
|
That's kind of an extraordinary.
|
00:19:15
|
|
Type of.
|
00:19:17
|
|
That each of you in the position of supervisor may or may not want to suggest to someone.
|
00:19:19
|
|
Or the flood plain administrator may not want to suggest that either because.
|
00:19:26
|
|
Not really following the procedures, here's how you can avoid.
|
00:19:31
|
|
Following the procedure, if you get a.
|
00:19:35
|
|
From us, and that's the reason why.
|
00:19:38
|
|
Treated so differently and.
|
00:19:40
|
|
Dog has run into this.
|
00:19:43
|
|
ADWR.
|
00:19:47
|
|
Game of it. They don't like us to to suggest that to people as our first line remedy.
|
00:19:48
|
|
To someone? Oh well, rather than find.
|
00:19:55
|
|
Face the hearing officer for violation.
|
00:19:59
|
|
You can just try to get the lawn out of flight. That's a way of getting around this. They don't want us to be suggesting that, but
|
00:20:02
|
|
the people whose first line, that's where this is coming from, so I understand that.
|
00:20:07
|
|
So, but you know and for the eight years we've set in these seats, I think we've only seen.
|
00:20:14
|
|
Proposal for a variance come up once when I came to the floodplain.
|
00:20:19
|
|
Issues with the new floodplain policy that's going into effect. You know, we could see it again somewhere along the way in the
|
00:20:23
|
|
next eight years or whatever. But what I'm saying is, is, is for us just to ignore that fact that that's an opportunity or or for
|
00:20:30
|
|
somebody to work a problem out And and when I think about floodplains, we have so much of it in, in Hina County.
|
00:20:37
|
|
You know, we have miles of flood.
|
00:20:46
|
|
Areas. A lot of people live in those areas.
|
00:20:49
|
|
Something could come up just from a simple issue that they need to help with.
|
00:20:52
|
|
I'm not. I'm not personally looking at it as a way of circumventing this.
|
00:20:58
|
|
The policies or anything like that, I'm looking at it more with a situation does arise. How can we work with that and if our
|
00:21:02
|
|
people don't know that, that's in the available.
|
00:21:07
|
|
I think, I think that's.
|
00:21:14
|
|
I don't think that's a good thing on our behalf, but that's where I'm coming from. If if it's because of an unusual situation with
|
00:21:16
|
|
the land was kind of a unique problem that.
|
00:21:21
|
|
The laws.
|
00:21:27
|
|
Work well with then. That's what that's intended to be for.
|
00:21:29
|
|
I agree.
|
00:21:34
|
|
I agree. But somewhere along the way somebody's got to have that ability to say, hey, look, talk to your district supervisor or
|
00:21:36
|
|
whatever, you know.
|
00:21:40
|
|
That's all I'm saying.
|
00:21:45
|
|
Right. And if that's the particular situation?
|
00:21:47
|
|
That would be appropriate, I agree, yeah. But there may no doubt about it. I'm not looking as variances away circumventing our
|
00:21:50
|
|
policies and statutes so.
|
00:21:54
|
|
Thank you.
|
00:22:00
|
|
Welcome, Dard. Also, I think when it comes to community development in general, the county should not be.
|
00:22:02
|
|
An enforcement agency is its.
|
00:22:10
|
|
Option, and I think that's what you're explaining. Let's work with our customer, let's work with the people, let's try and get
|
00:22:12
|
|
them in compliance if there's a very unique situation where.
|
00:22:18
|
|
We're going to need to do something then it comes before the board and that should always be.
|
00:22:23
|
|
Available to all the constituents in the county because.
|
00:22:29
|
|
Community development deals with that stuff all the time. There's always some tree or some roof line or some height or some hill
|
00:22:33
|
|
or whatever.
|
00:22:38
|
|
And you said in the work study on January 30th that much of what we're changing is actually going to be hopeful.
|
00:22:44
|
|
Helpful to the community.
|
00:22:50
|
|
And not, not necessarily more restrictive or.
|
00:22:52
|
|
Harsh. That's the goal, yes.
|
00:22:59
|
|
OK, thanks. Please continue if you.
|
00:23:02
|
|
OK, one other thing that Mister Dalton pointed out.
|
00:23:05
|
|
Is in section 3.9.
|
00:23:10
|
|
Which is a.
|
00:23:14
|
|
Actions that staff takes to.
|
00:23:16
|
|
Try to correct.
|
00:23:19
|
|
Violations.
|
00:23:21
|
|
There was a reference to.
|
00:23:26
|
|
Referring it to the board to order abatement and.
|
00:23:29
|
|
I think was a vestige from old times.
|
00:23:34
|
|
Really old times. Now we have a hearing officer, so.
|
00:23:37
|
|
We're going to take that out and.
|
00:23:41
|
|
Let him go to the hearing officer and they can always appeal to the board.
|
00:23:44
|
|
That takes you out of.
|
00:23:48
|
|
That gives you a little buffer there.
|
00:23:50
|
|
For them to try.
|
00:23:54
|
|
Correct the problem before.
|
00:23:56
|
|
Come to the board, ask for a variance of whatever they're going to do.
|
00:24:00
|
|
Mr. Chair, if I might, yes, please.
|
00:24:08
|
|
So we have several different things that goes to a hearing officer and whatnot like that.
|
00:24:10
|
|
But fact of the matter is we're the ones that's in.
|
00:24:17
|
|
You know, sitting in these chairs to correct problems and hear issues and things like that. So there again, me personally, I don't
|
00:24:20
|
|
know that that I like that, but.
|
00:24:24
|
|
I'm just making that well known.
|
00:24:29
|
|
And I can, Mr. Chair, clarify that as well.
|
00:24:33
|
|
So there's one process where.
|
00:24:38
|
|
The department issues the notice of violation.
|
00:24:42
|
|
To the landowner and then they go to a hearing officer.
|
00:24:45
|
|
And if they don't like that result, they appeal it to the board.
|
00:24:49
|
|
And then they can appeal it to the superior.
|
00:24:53
|
|
That process is in.
|
00:24:56
|
|
The other.
|
00:24:58
|
|
Was as an alternative, they could just fill it directly to or they could just.
|
00:25:00
|
|
Make this go directly to the board.
|
00:25:06
|
|
But no appeal after that to the superior report.
|
00:25:08
|
|
And one of the options was given that the board could offer a variance.
|
00:25:14
|
|
The problem with having those?
|
00:25:20
|
|
Available simultaneously.
|
00:25:23
|
|
They confuse.
|
00:25:25
|
|
The supervisors roles as a judicial body and as a legislative body.
|
00:25:28
|
|
As a judicial body.
|
00:25:34
|
|
As a complaint lodged against them and then they go to a hearing officer.
|
00:25:36
|
|
Hearing officer judges the situation determines whether or not they're in.
|
00:25:42
|
|
And that's appeal to you as the.
|
00:25:46
|
|
And you judge the hearing officers decision and decide whether that was correct.
|
00:25:49
|
|
That's a that's a judicial process. You're acting as.
|
00:25:53
|
|
Quasar judges that.
|
00:25:56
|
|
If they appeal directly to.
|
00:25:59
|
|
About a violation.
|
00:26:01
|
|
And ask for you to excuse it as a vari.
|
00:26:03
|
|
That's a legislative process because now you're not sitting as judges.
|
00:26:06
|
|
You're sitting as legislators who can change the very ordinance itself.
|
00:26:10
|
|
You can pass an amendment to the ordinance saying this ordinance does not apply to this.
|
00:26:15
|
|
And so you wave or erase violation through a legislative process.
|
00:26:21
|
|
And to give a landowner those two options.
|
00:26:26
|
|
In the same situation is very confusing.
|
00:26:31
|
|
And from a legal perspective, I think it's not a good idea to do that. They should go through a judicial process for the
|
00:26:35
|
|
violation.
|
00:26:38
|
|
And see how that goes. And they can feel it all the way through the Superior Court if they want to, even to the Supreme Court.
|
00:26:42
|
|
They want to if they want to pursue A.
|
00:26:48
|
|
Process, which is to ask you as the board to erase the law.
|
00:26:52
|
|
As to their.
|
00:26:57
|
|
That's a completely different.
|
00:26:58
|
|
And they're coming to you in a.
|
00:27:01
|
|
Proceeding asking for a variance saying.
|
00:27:04
|
|
I got a special situation here and I think I deserve a waiver from the ordinance itself.
|
00:27:08
|
|
I'd like to consider that as the county's legislature to amend the ordinance and change the law estimate.
|
00:27:12
|
|
And keep those things very separate.
|
00:27:18
|
|
Rather than mix.
|
00:27:20
|
|
The same options for the same.
|
00:27:23
|
|
That's why.
|
00:27:28
|
|
My further explanation board.
|
00:27:30
|
|
Thank you.
|
00:27:35
|
|
Thank you, explain a lot better than I could.
|
00:27:38
|
|
OK, the the only other thing that came out was that the the.
|
00:27:45
|
|
Definition of.
|
00:27:51
|
|
We had changed it to try.
|
00:27:53
|
|
Include the.
|
00:27:57
|
|
Of the word we're defining in the definition.
|
00:28:00
|
|
Where it was previous ordinance.
|
00:28:04
|
|
Mr. Dalton.
|
00:28:07
|
|
The body of law behind the word hardship and.
|
00:28:09
|
|
Remain in there because of all the other connotations and case law.
|
00:28:12
|
|
So we're proposing also to.
|
00:28:17
|
|
Go back to the way it was in the previous ordinance. Leave the word hardship in the.
|
00:28:22
|
|
So those are.
|
00:28:28
|
|
Things that we're recommending that the ordinance be adopted with these changes? No.
|
00:28:33
|
|
Would you like me to read this?
|
00:28:40
|
|
If you'd like to, that's short.
|
00:28:48
|
|
It is recommended that the Board adopt the proposed amendments to the Hewlett County Floodplain Management Ordinance with the
|
00:28:52
|
|
following changes. Replace the word difficulty with the word hardship in the definition of hardship in Section 2 point.
|
00:28:59
|
|
In Section 3 point.
|
00:29:06
|
|
Paragraph B replace the second sentence.
|
00:29:09
|
|
Quote Such information must be provided to the floodplain administrator within 30 days of such order.
|
00:29:12
|
|
Or End Quote.
|
00:29:21
|
|
And also delete all of section 3.9 B after the sentence.
|
00:29:24
|
|
After the 2nd.
|
00:29:29
|
|
OK.
|
00:29:32
|
|
OK, thank you. Is that OK with everybody? Because I don't know what section 3.9 V looks like. That makes two of us.
|
00:29:36
|
|
I could read that.
|
00:29:45
|
|
Section if you would.
|
00:29:47
|
|
Please.
|
00:29:50
|
|
OK, what?
|
00:30:14
|
|
Proposed.
|
00:30:16
|
|
Ordinance draft that was published.
|
00:30:20
|
|
Is the following.
|
00:30:22
|
|
3.9 B Order the property on order the owner of the property and on which the violation exists to provide whatever additional
|
00:30:25
|
|
information may be required for their determination.
|
00:30:32
|
|
Such as proof of compliance by means of an elevation certificate.
|
00:30:39
|
|
Appropriate flood proofing documentation.
|
00:30:43
|
|
The calculations to show no rise in the floodway.
|
00:30:47
|
|
Such information must be provided to the footprint administrator within 30 days of such order.
|
00:30:51
|
|
And she may submit a report to the Floodplain board within 20 days with the request.
|
00:30:57
|
|
That the flood plain board.
|
00:31:03
|
|
Order abatement of the violation.
|
00:31:05
|
|
At the next regularly scheduled public meeting with Floodplain Board.
|
00:31:08
|
|
Shall order the abatement of said violation.
|
00:31:12
|
|
Floor and we did have grant of variance in there and that was deleted prior to this draft.
|
00:31:17
|
|
So what we're basically saying.
|
00:31:26
|
|
We just provide information.
|
00:31:32
|
|
We ask them to provide information.
|
00:31:37
|
|
Proves their.
|
00:31:39
|
|
Not really in violation.
|
00:31:40
|
|
May appear.
|
00:31:43
|
|
OK.
|
00:31:45
|
|
Mr. Chair, so, so, Guardian. Most, most instances with the new revised maps that we're supposed to get through FEMA.
|
00:31:48
|
|
That should be readily available to you as a director too, right? Correct.
|
00:31:56
|
|
We don't always know how high their floor is though, until they have it.
|
00:32:02
|
|
But I I was under the impression that those surveys will be done prior to this, these maps revised and put together.
|
00:32:07
|
|
The, yeah, the study will be done and the maps will be based on that, on the study that's being done now.
|
00:32:16
|
|
And.
|
00:32:25
|
|
What the ordinance is saying is.
|
00:32:28
|
|
You know, we know the flood.
|
00:32:31
|
|
Issues we.
|
00:32:33
|
|
Necessarily how the building is constructed, What materials? Is it flood proof?
|
00:32:36
|
|
Is it elevated?
|
00:32:41
|
|
So on.
|
00:32:43
|
|
And sometimes.
|
00:32:45
|
|
Things are not real obvious and we think.
|
00:32:47
|
|
Is a violation mostly because it was built without permits, so we didn't see the plans.
|
00:32:50
|
|
And then we would just ask them as a means of rectifying the violation.
|
00:32:57
|
|
Or just show us that you are in compliance with these.
|
00:33:04
|
|
These requirements and ordinance.
|
00:33:08
|
|
That's part of working with.
|
00:33:11
|
|
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. You have anything surpriser, Humphrey? I'm good. Thank you.
|
00:33:14
|
|
Is that all your presentation?
|
00:33:19
|
|
I'm here to answer any other questions you have, but I don't want to.
|
00:33:22
|
|
Delay it if you remember what we talked about in the work session.
|
00:33:27
|
|
It appears that we've asked all of our questions, so at this time, I will open it up to the public hearing portion. Is there
|
00:33:31
|
|
anyone here in the Globe facility that wishes to speak to this item?
|
00:33:38
|
|
No. Anyone in Payson, Lisa.
|
00:33:46
|
|
And Cassandra.
|
00:33:51
|
|
OK. Then I will close the public hearing portion and call for a motion.
|
00:33:53
|
|
Do we need to go back to the Board of Supervisors before we make a motion?
|
00:34:00
|
|
No.
|
00:34:06
|
|
Then I move to improve the Amendment Gila County Floodplain management ordinance.
|
00:34:08
|
|
I'll second.
|
00:34:15
|
|
OK, we have a motion and a second to approve all those in favor. Say aye, aye.
|
00:34:17
|
|
I almost.
|
00:34:22
|
|
Nah, I.
|
00:34:24
|
|
Your post. Yeah. OK, so we have two to one supervisor client, the last minute 3 visions.
|
00:34:27
|
|
I'm sorry, Dart, does that motion include the last minute revisions that I gave to you?
|
00:34:35
|
|
Well, we didn't state that. So Jessica, you need to state that just for the record, go ahead and clarify the motion.
|
00:34:41
|
|
Supervisor, clarify that motion to include.
|
00:34:50
|
|
Recent changes suggest.
|
00:34:55
|
|
I didn't get that sheet of paper. Is there an ordinate number?
|
00:34:57
|
|
I make a motion.
|
00:35:15
|
|
To approve the amended Gila County floodplain management ordinance.
|
00:35:18
|
|
And also to include, it is recommended that oh to include.
|
00:35:27
|
|
Replace the word difficulty with the word hardship.
|
00:35:33
|
|
And the.
|
00:35:38
|
|
Of hardship in section 2.0.
|
00:35:40
|
|
In section 3.9 B, replace the second sentence with such information.
|
00:35:45
|
|
Must be provided in the in the floodplain administrator within 30 days of such ordinance or.
|
00:35:52
|
|
And as deleted as of section 3.9 B after the second sentence.
|
00:36:02
|
|
Are we good with that?
|
00:36:10
|
|
Now we're going to pass this.
|
00:36:13
|
|
Confused.
|
00:36:16
|
|
Bring that, we're going to begin.
|
00:36:19
|
|
So look at section 3.9 B. Replace the second sentence.
|
00:36:31
|
|
Such information must be provided in its Liberal administrator within 30 days of such order.
|
00:36:37
|
|
And also delete all of the section 3.9 B.
|
00:36:43
|
|
After the 2nd.
|
00:36:48
|
|
OK.
|
00:37:01
|
|
OK. Yeah, I don't have any.
|
00:37:10
|
|
Yeah.
|
00:37:15
|
|
It's changing with this advertising newspaper.
|
00:37:26
|
|
Please.
|
00:37:35
|
|
Advertise the changes to the newspaper.
|
00:37:39
|
|
Correct. And then after discussion with our County Attorney and we ate that ADWR and with the information that we received at one
|
00:37:42
|
|
of those work sessions about the work variants, we went back and introduced these changes to what was advertised in the newspaper.
|
00:37:50
|
|
OK. So these are changes that were advertised to the news.
|
00:37:58
|
|
What what Dark stepped up to ask for was a change to the ordinance that included what was advertised in the newspaper plus these
|
00:38:02
|
|
amendments to that that was advertised. And that's, and that's what we're asking for today by the way the the variance section.
|
00:38:12
|
|
Was there originally in the ordinance. It's one of eight sections in the ordinance is 4 pages long. The ordinance is about 40
|
00:38:21
|
|
pages. So in explaining a variance in our ordinance is 10% of the words that are used there.
|
00:38:29
|
|
What we did is we took out in abating A violation, we took out the word variance.
|
00:38:37
|
|
But in the Section 4 three section after left of direct but the front plane manager is supposed to do supposed to work out that
|
00:38:45
|
|
there is like ABCDE items work with the.
|
00:38:52
|
|
Ask for additional information, use the hearing officer, consult with the County Attorney, and then if all that fails, then
|
00:39:00
|
|
there's an option for a variance.
|
00:39:04
|
|
Or whatever. That section is referring to what the floodplain administrators supposed to do. So there's no mention of variance
|
00:39:09
|
|
there. But again, it's prominent in the ordinance. It's it's an entire section out to itself.
|
00:39:15
|
|
But I just wanted to clarify what that piece of paper that you're looking for. I'm clear on this, Mr. Chair. It's fine.
|
00:39:21
|
|
So the motion made was appropriate. OK, so legal counsel says the motion was appropriate. We have a motion, we have movement, we
|
00:39:29
|
|
have speeches. So we have a second.
|
00:39:35
|
|
We have a motion in the.
|
00:39:42
|
|
To again approve all those in favor, say aye, aye, aye, those opposed.
|
00:39:44
|
|
Supervisor Klein votes against.
|
00:39:51
|
|
Motion passes.
|
00:39:54
|
|
Thank you, darling.
|
00:39:55
|
|
Would have thought it would be so exciting.
|
00:39:57
|
|
I have.
|
00:39:59
|
|
OK, I will need now a motion to adjourn.
|
00:40:02
|
|
As the he.
|
00:40:06
|
|
Flood Control Direct District Board of Directors and reconvene as the.
|
00:40:08
|
|
Board of Supervisors. So move, Mr. Chair.
|
00:40:14
|
|
Motion in a second to approve that all ones in favor say aye.
|
00:40:19
|
|
OK, item 4.
|
00:40:25
|
|
Information, Discussion Action to receive a presentation by The Globe, Miami Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:40:28
|
|
And to approve or not approve paying the invoice submitted by the Chamber for 2024 in the amount of $10,250, which is $250 over
|
00:40:35
|
|
the amount budgeted by the Board of Supervisors for fiscal year 2024. Good morning, Marriage. Good morning, Mr. Chair. Good
|
00:40:42
|
|
morning, Supervisor Klein. Good morning, Supervisor Humphrey. This morning we have presenters from the Globe Miami Regional
|
00:40:50
|
|
Chamber of Commerce here to share a presentation with you. And then after the presentation, we can talk about the invoice.
|
00:40:58
|
|
OK. Thank you.
|
00:41:06
|
|
Come on up, please. Introduce yourself again, please. OK. Yes. Good morning, Mr. Chairman.
|
00:41:10
|
|
Members of the board, my name is Angel Reese and I am the director for the Global Miami Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:41:16
|
|
Thank you for having us today. We're looking forward to discussing our partnership with Gila County to create win win
|
00:41:22
|
|
opportunities.
|
00:41:26
|
|
Today I brought with me Mr. Phil Stewart. He is the owner of Stewart's Antique Milk in downtown Miami and he is also a chamber
|
00:41:30
|
|
board member.
|
00:41:34
|
|
He is going to elaborate more on how the Heila County funding is being utilized.
|
00:41:39
|
|
Thank you, Angel and good morning. The question has been asked, how does the Miami, excuse me, how does the Globe, Miami Regional
|
00:41:47
|
|
Chamber of Commerce use the funding provided by Gila County?
|
00:41:52
|
|
Let's get into it next slide.
|
00:41:58
|
|
We promote activities and events in Gila County using a variety of technologies.
|
00:42:03
|
|
If you look at the Chamber of Commerce website.
|
00:42:07
|
|
Next slide.
|
00:42:12
|
|
As you can see up there on this is a screenshot of the.
|
00:42:15
|
|
Landing page you have our logo and right below.
|
00:42:18
|
|
Dominantly displayed is a working hyperlink of the seal appealing.
|
00:42:22
|
|
So our users can go.
|
00:42:27
|
|
Click and go right to your website.
|
00:42:30
|
|
And then as you get further into.
|
00:42:34
|
|
The landing page again displayed as a working active.
|
00:42:37
|
|
Hyperlink directly to the county.
|
00:42:42
|
|
The Chamber of Commerce also utilizes Facebook, Instagram, and we're also researching other technologies such as YouTube.
|
00:42:46
|
|
Hulu and a few more options to further promote Gila County in the communities that the Chamber of Commerce interfaces with
|
00:42:53
|
|
directly.
|
00:42:57
|
|
Next slide.
|
00:43:03
|
|
Your funding helps Contin.
|
00:43:05
|
|
To drive these services that the Chamber provides.
|
00:43:08
|
|
I'm sure some of you on this board have been to the Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:43:11
|
|
I know some of the Gila County Supervisors area.
|
00:43:15
|
|
And the most recent speaker was US Senator Kyrsten Sine.
|
00:43:20
|
|
Was at our Chamber of Commer.
|
00:43:23
|
|
The Chamber of Commerce is a community rallying.
|
00:43:26
|
|
We're the prisons out there on the highway that people come.
|
00:43:29
|
|
And inquire about our area here in Gil.
|
00:43:33
|
|
Out of town visitors will stop by frequently wanting to know about.
|
00:43:37
|
|
What's happening here? Where can we go? What can we do? What can we see?
|
00:43:41
|
|
And we're happy to tell that story.
|
00:43:47
|
|
We're open six days a week and we do this with one full time staff.
|
00:43:49
|
|
And one part time staff.
|
00:43:54
|
|
So we're very leaning.
|
00:43:56
|
|
The Chamber of Commerce Foster's community outreach.
|
00:44:00
|
|
During the initial COVID COVID-19 outbreak.
|
00:44:03
|
|
The chamber was a rallying.
|
00:44:07
|
|
For the.
|
00:44:09
|
|
Collections and distribution hub of hygiene and cleaning supplies.
|
00:44:12
|
|
So with that said, I'll turn the presentation back over to Angel and she can continue.
|
00:44:16
|
|
So our community. So at the Chamber, we hold key events in our communities, which brings visitors to Hewlett County.
|
00:44:23
|
|
Just to name a couple, our Ann.
|
00:44:32
|
|
Or the Arizona Poppy Fest. It's an entire celebration of our puppies.
|
00:44:35
|
|
Every weekend there's something going on in Old Man.
|
00:44:41
|
|
Which so many people come to enjoy.
|
00:44:44
|
|
Apache G is an extremely popular cultural event.
|
00:44:47
|
|
That brings in people from all over the state, including our neighboring.
|
00:44:51
|
|
So the common denominator of our events is they bring in people in revenue to heal accountable.
|
00:44:56
|
|
So.
|
00:45:03
|
|
So to summarize this, if I could have the next slide please.
|
00:45:08
|
|
The Chamber of Commerce is very appreciative of all the support.
|
00:45:12
|
|
That Board of Supervisors have given our organization over the years.
|
00:45:17
|
|
We look forward to continue to work with you.
|
00:45:22
|
|
As our communities grow.
|
00:45:27
|
|
What we're asking you to do is please contin.
|
00:45:31
|
|
Help us help.
|
00:45:34
|
|
Make our communities thrive and become a key destination point in the state of Arizona.
|
00:45:37
|
|
We thank you for your time.
|
00:45:43
|
|
And if you have questions, we'd be glad to.
|
00:45:45
|
|
Thank you, Mr. Stewart, Supervisor Humphrey.
|
00:45:48
|
|
Yeah, you also do out of town events for Flyers and things like that, or promoting Gila County.
|
00:45:52
|
|
Yes, Sir. Yeah. So it's not just all on the Internet and stuff. You actually go to places and and and I knew that. That's why I
|
00:45:59
|
|
brought it up, because you didn't cover it, because sometimes we do great things but we don't tell great stories. So that's just,
|
00:46:05
|
|
that's just a feather in your hat as far as I'm concerned. It's going to other events to hand out Flyers and let people know in
|
00:46:10
|
|
person.
|
00:46:15
|
|
Of the promotion here.
|
00:46:21
|
|
That's all, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Supervisor Klein. So thank you for the hard work you guys do. And I am a really ordered
|
00:46:23
|
|
Chamber of Commerce. I I just really feel without the element being in the middle of everything that's going on, I I think we'd
|
00:46:28
|
|
lose.
|
00:46:32
|
|
There's a lot, so thank you for doing that. Thank you.
|
00:46:37
|
|
And yeah, I'll thank you too. So we have two very good Chambers of Commerce in Gila County rim country and you Miami Globe and and
|
00:46:40
|
|
we support both.
|
00:46:46
|
|
We're going to, we're going to talk about the finances here in a minute, but.
|
00:46:54
|
|
Oh, I thought I had a .0. Yes, Mr. Stewart, what was the business that you said? You?
|
00:46:58
|
|
My wife and I own Stewart's antique nook in downtown Miami.
|
00:47:03
|
|
That sounds like my kind of place, yeah.
|
00:47:08
|
|
So thank you for your presentation.
|
00:47:11
|
|
And Marin, you.
|
00:47:14
|
|
OK.
|
00:47:20
|
|
So we're here this morning in part because the presentation needed to be made and also because this year the.
|
00:47:30
|
|
The invoice? Typically, we budget $10,000 for Globe Miami Chamber of Commerce, $10,000 for rim country, the Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:47:39
|
|
And $5000 for Tonto Basin Chamber of Commerce. And this year, the invoice for Global Miami Chamber of Commerce came in at $10,250.
|
00:47:48
|
|
Finance doesn't have the capability to pay an invoice in excess of the budgeted amount.
|
00:47:57
|
|
To pay that, we would need your approval and then I believe the county Attorney's office has a question about.
|
00:48:07
|
|
Past agree.
|
00:48:15
|
|
And whether this is an economic development grant or if it's dues and services?
|
00:48:18
|
|
Chairman, members of the board, in the past this has been passed as a economic development grant where the board has determined
|
00:48:28
|
|
that it's for the benefit of the public. Here today it wasn't presented that way, but we would like to amend it so that it could
|
00:48:33
|
|
be an economic development grant. And so if you do find that it's for the benefit of the public, then you can go ahead and make
|
00:48:38
|
|
the motion.
|
00:48:44
|
|
Supervisor.
|
00:48:53
|
|
I have no questions other.
|
00:48:58
|
|
Mayor, thanks for bringing up Tunnel Basin because I was going to Mr. Chair, you said we had two. Great Chamber of Commerce's we
|
00:49:00
|
|
had three.
|
00:49:03
|
|
You know, just thank you for informing. I didn't. I didn't realize that.
|
00:49:07
|
|
In That's OK with my mind. So that's OK Only have three? Great.
|
00:49:12
|
|
Supervisor.
|
00:49:19
|
|
I think James May have something to say further before I say anything.
|
00:49:20
|
|
Go ahead.
|
00:49:26
|
|
I I I don't. I think it is for the benefit of the public that's that was always been my feelings towards this and I think that it
|
00:49:28
|
|
still is. So the only question I would have is, is where did the 250 come from?
|
00:49:36
|
|
We have an increase in.
|
00:49:44
|
|
We had an increase in our membership dues.
|
00:49:48
|
|
It was raised all around. I have a letter that we sent with the invoice.
|
00:49:50
|
|
That said that we were going to in 2020.
|
00:49:54
|
|
Is when we raise. OK, thank you. You know, it isn't much of an increase. I just curious it went from 3000 to 3000 to 50. So thank
|
00:49:57
|
|
you.
|
00:50:02
|
|
If I if I may have further point of clarification in reviewing the due structure and review.
|
00:50:09
|
|
Our expenses for the year is everybody here in this room can attest everything has inched its way up.
|
00:50:15
|
|
And so, reluctantly, we decided to take this course. Just because.
|
00:50:22
|
|
When we maintain the brick and.
|
00:50:28
|
|
Expenses go up, insurance, utilities, everything goes up and I'm sure I'm speaking to the choir here.
|
00:50:31
|
|
But I just did want to point that out. So thank you, thank you. Thank you both for.
|
00:50:37
|
|
James, did you have something to add?
|
00:50:42
|
|
I do, Mr. Chairman. OK And there is a board.
|
00:50:44
|
|
Which has been an economic development grant. Just some things to remember is.
|
00:50:48
|
|
There's a member sub dues for 3000.
|
00:50:54
|
|
That leaves either $7000 or $6750 that Gila County is supposed to receive a direct benefit.
|
00:50:57
|
|
From an Economic Journal Grant.
|
00:51:07
|
|
So what has been described? What happens with the Chamber of Commerce that there are events that are sponsored brings?
|
00:51:09
|
|
Activity people into the area.
|
00:51:17
|
|
Hopefully brings in excise tax. Those are considered by.
|
00:51:21
|
|
Case law that they are not direct benefits to the county cannot be considered as a direct benefit.
|
00:51:26
|
|
Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:51:34
|
|
Describing to us or letting us know what direct.
|
00:51:37
|
|
The County Rece.
|
00:51:41
|
|
From that.
|
00:51:44
|
|
6750 dollars, $7000, whatever it might be.
|
00:51:45
|
|
So something to consider.
|
00:51:50
|
|
It can be for the public.
|
00:51:53
|
|
But by case law, it still has to be a direct benefit account.
|
00:51:55
|
|
That makes sense. No? Mr. Chair, are you saying that direct benefit is not described today?
|
00:52:01
|
|
Or because I know what you're talking about, I'm not going to make that declaration. Whether it is not that's, that's up to your
|
00:52:08
|
|
discretion. I see. As to whether it is, I do. I do want to hand the Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:52:15
|
|
For credit that last Chamber of Commerce we had come in that they.
|
00:52:22
|
|
Who were the most significant? We were the major contributor to the Chamber of Commerce as a county, and yet the county was not
|
00:52:28
|
|
even mentioned on the website.
|
00:52:32
|
|
The club Miami Chamber of Commerce has has the.
|
00:52:37
|
|
Helena County prominently displayed.
|
00:52:40
|
|
As a partner.
|
00:52:44
|
|
Participant with Chamber of Commerce. So I'm very thrilled, very excited to see that actually that Hill County is considered a
|
00:52:47
|
|
partner with the Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:52:51
|
|
Just with an economic development grant, those are some of the things to make sure that we consider.
|
00:52:56
|
|
That we are getting a direct benefit. Direct benefits are.
|
00:53:05
|
|
Can be.
|
00:53:09
|
|
We we give money and I'm sorry, just to jump in, we did put the invoice up on the board just so everybody can see.
|
00:53:13
|
|
This is why we didn't present it as an economic development grant this morning. The invoice is broken out 3254 Diamond membership
|
00:53:20
|
|
and then $7000 in advertising.
|
00:53:26
|
|
Just in case you you needed.
|
00:53:33
|
|
Definition of what that direct benefit?
|
00:53:36
|
|
Can I ask one more question, Mr. Chairman? So I believe it's in the past, but it's always.
|
00:53:39
|
|
Better concern for me and just would wonder why there was a time that there was some turnover some change in the in the global
|
00:53:45
|
|
Miami Chamber Chamber of Commerce.
|
00:53:50
|
|
And Gold Miami Chamber of Commerce. The board voted.
|
00:53:55
|
|
Not support.
|
00:54:00
|
|
Discover he.
|
00:54:02
|
|
That they there is a spot of the of the five what was then 5 member board of the of Discovery Hill County.
|
00:54:04
|
|
The gold.
|
00:54:12
|
|
Or Chamber of Commerce board voted not to have a representative sit on the discovery of the county.
|
00:54:15
|
|
And I.
|
00:54:21
|
|
I said.
|
00:54:23
|
|
But there was a period of time that the the.
|
00:54:25
|
|
I've called Miami Chamber of.
|
00:54:29
|
|
Elected.
|
00:54:32
|
|
We support and don't care if I may James that this is in the past why we even bringing it up.
|
00:54:33
|
|
We're we're working on trying to figure out how it's a benefit and you're getting in the past that doesn't even belong anymore
|
00:54:39
|
|
because we do have someone who's on the board, I mean.
|
00:54:44
|
|
You can go backwards if you want to, but I don't think there's a time and place Mr. here. Thank you Mr. Klein, anymore to add.
|
00:54:50
|
|
I'm not sure.
|
00:54:57
|
|
No, I just make a statement that anytime in my opinion and I don't know how the law come to be or anything.
|
00:54:59
|
|
But it for me personally anytime we talk about Chamber of Commerce, the promoting of everything, we know that it's bringing in
|
00:55:06
|
|
revenue, we know that it's attracting people and people are being money is being spent. So that's that's just a comment for the
|
00:55:11
|
|
need.
|
00:55:17
|
|
That's to me just a no brainer. But I.
|
00:55:23
|
|
I don't know about the law, Jessica.
|
00:55:27
|
|
Well, I would suggest when we do make a motion that we would also include in it for the benefit of the public just to be.
|
00:55:31
|
|
And Mar.
|
00:55:39
|
|
Well, and James as well, I think that if we are going to vote to.
|
00:55:41
|
|
Funding with one chamber we should consider in the future then.
|
00:55:47
|
|
To reflect that with the other two as well, OK, we're not voting on that today.
|
00:55:52
|
|
Chairman, Members of the board. And so in previous discussions with you members, we did discuss what legally the direct benefit
|
00:55:59
|
|
means.
|
00:56:04
|
|
In prior economic development grants, what that looked like, the consideration that the county has accepted is that the nonprofit
|
00:56:11
|
|
organization or the other governmental entity is going to provide advertisement to the county.
|
00:56:18
|
|
It's up to your discretion if you believe that that is a direct benefit or not. If you want to get into the caveats and legalities
|
00:56:26
|
|
then I would recommend an executive session.
|
00:56:32
|
|
Either the other two supervisors believe we need an executive session at this point.
|
00:56:42
|
|
If you let.
|
00:56:47
|
|
I don't feel as if I need and neither do I, so with that I will call for a motion.
|
00:56:49
|
|
Yeah. And just just before I make a motion, I would like to say that by them sponsoring like Apache G Day and some of those
|
00:56:56
|
|
events.
|
00:57:00
|
|
If an accountant wants to sit down and figure out the sales tax of those multiple people in our motels, restaurants, downtown
|
00:57:05
|
|
buying gifts, then let them tell us that it's not a benefit that he Will County as far as I'm concerned.
|
00:57:12
|
|
As well as many other that you sponsor like the mining days and we can go to Poppy Fest and on and on. If somebody wants to sit
|
00:57:19
|
|
there and tally sales tax, I'd like them to tell me that it's not a benefit to you.
|
00:57:26
|
|
So anyway, with that said.
|
00:57:33
|
|
Mr. Chair, I move to approve paying the invoice submitted by the Chamber for physical year 2024 in the amount of $10,350 and Mr.
|
00:57:36
|
|
Charles second.
|
00:57:42
|
|
Would you like to include in your motion Mr. Humphrey and its benefit of the public?
|
00:57:50
|
|
As an.
|
00:57:57
|
|
Grant for the benefit of the public.
|
00:58:00
|
|
I'll second that one. OK. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor say aye, Aye.
|
00:58:05
|
|
Aye, aye, motion passes. Thank you.
|
00:58:10
|
|
Thank you. Thank you guys for being here.
|
00:58:14
|
|
OK, I'm gonna turn again item 4, the information discussion action to authorize the advertisement of requests for proposals number
|
00:58:18
|
|
011224, Cost Allocation Plan Services and.
|
00:58:24
|
|
CFR. Cost allocation plan services.
|
00:58:31
|
|
Good morning, Mr. Chair, Supervisor, Client, Supervisor Humphrey. The Finance Department has a cost allocation plan every year
|
00:58:36
|
|
that we are required to obtain in order to charge indirect costs.
|
00:58:43
|
|
To our federal and state grants.
|
00:58:51
|
|
Our current vendor is no longer offering this service.
|
00:58:53
|
|
We have.
|
00:58:59
|
|
Visited with various vendors that are available for property purchasing agreements. They are not taking new clients at this time,
|
00:59:00
|
|
so we do need to go out for proposals.
|
00:59:06
|
|
To make sure that we are in compliance with.
|
00:59:14
|
|
The Code of Federal Regulations. Be happy to answer any questions you have, supervisor.
|
00:59:18
|
|
Yeah, I have a lot of questions, but there's nothing we can do anything about.
|
00:59:27
|
|
No, Sir. OK. No, I'm good. We need to do this. We do good as well.
|
00:59:31
|
|
So with that, I'll call for motion.
|
00:59:37
|
|
Mr. Chair, I'll make the motion to authorize the advertisement of request for proposals number 011224.
|
00:59:40
|
|
Mr. Jarrell, second motion and a second to approve those in favor. Say aye. Aye, Aye, aye. Thank you, Marin. Or we're moving along
|
00:59:49
|
|
now. Item 4C. Information discussion action to approve the.
|
00:59:55
|
|
Of the State of Arizona Contract number Ctr. 059886 for the purchase.
|
01:00:02
|
|
Is for the purchase of 16 laptop computers, 41 desktop computers from micro age in the amount of $81,952.50.
|
01:00:11
|
|
As part of the IT Department's computer replacement plan for fiscal year 2024.
|
01:00:21
|
|
Kelly, good morning, Chairman, Christensen and Board members. As part of our commitment to keeping the county technology up to
|
01:00:28
|
|
date, we've identified 16 laptops and 41 desktops that are due for replacement during the physical year 24.
|
01:00:34
|
|
We're proposing to use the state.
|
01:00:40
|
|
Ctr. 059886 to purchase these computers for microwave. The total cost for this upgrade is $81,952.50. The funding was.
|
01:00:42
|
|
Has been thoughtfully allocated from the capital budget which was already approved in the physical year 24 budget, if you have any
|
01:00:53
|
|
questions I feel.
|
01:00:56
|
|
Would be willing to answer that for you. Thank you Carrie Supervisor Humphrey.
|
01:01:00
|
|
Yeah. I guess my question is, what are we going to do with the computer and laptops that we're replacing? Are they going to go up
|
01:01:04
|
|
for auction? Do we trade them in? What? What do we do?
|
01:01:08
|
|
So the computers that we get back from that are out, out of date. We all we sometimes use them for the school district the the
|
01:01:12
|
|
school needs them for different projects and stuff and then the ones that are not usable we pull the hard drives and then
|
01:01:18
|
|
decommission them.
|
01:01:23
|
|
So we donate them.
|
01:01:29
|
|
Or throw them away, correct.
|
01:01:32
|
|
OK, and we're not going to get in trouble for donating.
|
01:01:34
|
|
County equipment not getting any funds for.
|
01:01:37
|
|
That's like a different thing. Here we have vehicles that were working with other governments.
|
01:01:46
|
|
That that is something that is loud, that we.
|
01:01:51
|
|
On occasion, question is asking.
|
01:01:54
|
|
Yes, chairman, members of the board. So the gift clause does not apply when it's another governmental entity, The school district
|
01:01:58
|
|
would apply to that. Well, I'm glad that someone's benefiting from them and that's why I was asking the question.
|
01:02:03
|
|
And so I fully am in compliance and and I think it's great that the schools are getting the computers that we can't do.
|
01:02:09
|
|
OK, Supervisor.
|
01:02:19
|
|
Oh, I think it's great. You know, if anybody else can use those, those old computers, that's great. Whatever else, we can recycle
|
01:02:21
|
|
them.
|
01:02:25
|
|
Fashion, whatever. So thank you, Carrie. Good job. Thank you, Carrie. With that, I'll call for motion. Mr. Chair, I move to
|
01:02:28
|
|
approve.
|
01:02:32
|
|
State Arizona Contract number Ctr. 059.
|
01:02:37
|
|
886 as presented, I'll second that Mr. Chair motion to approve and seconded all those in favor. Say aye. Aye, Aye. Thank you.
|
01:02:41
|
|
Item 4G Information Discussion Action to Authorize an Online Public Auction through Public Surplus on March 29th, 2024 Sell
|
01:02:52
|
|
surplus or Obsolete county.
|
01:02:57
|
|
And equipment after the notice of the auction has been published in the Arizona Silver Barrel and Pacing Roundup newspapers 30
|
01:03:03
|
|
days before the auction date. So actually we have Sergeant High Street up in Cleveland. I'll answer any questions, but I believe
|
01:03:09
|
|
Sergeant High Street is going to present to you.
|
01:03:15
|
|
Well, I think the other way around. So Marin, if you can just take off.
|
01:03:25
|
|
Sure, I'd be happy to.
|
01:03:30
|
|
We have a variety of vehicles that are eligible to be liquidated in this way.
|
01:03:33
|
|
And today, we would request the board's permission. There's a list of vehicles included in the agenda item here.
|
01:03:40
|
|
The Board of Supervisors pursuant to Arizona Revised statute 11251 nine.
|
01:03:49
|
|
Has the capacity to sell at public auction after 30 days previous notice.
|
01:03:57
|
|
Any property belonging to the county that the board deems unnecessary for use by the county. These vehicles are currently in the
|
01:04:01
|
|
impound yard.
|
01:04:06
|
|
Sergeant High Street has done all the background paperwork, make sure that all of these vehicles are they have clean titles,
|
01:04:12
|
|
they're able to be taken care of in this way and we would like to use the public surplus website.
|
01:04:20
|
|
To liquidate these items. We believe that that will increase the likelihood of having a successful auction and be able to reach
|
01:04:29
|
|
more constituents and be more time effective and resource effective for the county as a whole.
|
01:04:38
|
|
And I believe there's a bullet here. The 4th bullet does need to.
|
01:04:47
|
|
Change to show that this would be on March 29th, not March 20th, but you.
|
01:04:55
|
|
Your proposed motion is correct for March 29th.
|
01:05:03
|
|
And the way this would work is anybody who wanted to participate would set up an account with the public surplus. They would make
|
01:05:08
|
|
a.
|
01:05:12
|
|
So basically, like earnest money.
|
01:05:17
|
|
And then if they chose, if they were the successful bidder on something, that $150.00 would go toward that purchase. If they
|
01:05:20
|
|
didn't end up being a successful bidder on anything, they would get their $150.00 back.
|
01:05:27
|
|
Thank you, Mayor and Supervisor Humphrey. Any questions?
|
01:05:36
|
|
This one Where Where can these these vehicles be seen?
|
01:05:40
|
|
I mean, if you're going to have an online auction, I think there are people that would like to go see them prior to being on them.
|
01:05:45
|
|
So the online auction does require that we show various views of them.
|
01:05:51
|
|
They are at the Star Valley Impound Yard and.
|
01:05:57
|
|
Sergeant High Street, If people wanted to, could they make arrangements with you to go see them in person?
|
01:06:01
|
|
Sure. I think the best thing to do is on the website will probably put my cell phone number so we can allow access to these
|
01:06:07
|
|
vehicles. That way I can navigate through my schedule.
|
01:06:12
|
|
But they're currently being held and all of them are at 5310 E Highway 260. That's the Star Valley yard that we use for all these
|
01:06:17
|
|
vehicles. We did have these vehicles located all over county. This is one of many auctions that will likely have, given that we
|
01:06:23
|
|
have quite a bit.
|
01:06:29
|
|
But.
|
01:06:36
|
|
Having an instrument made it easy for me to process all the paperwork, but the public can reach out to me and I can make
|
01:06:37
|
|
arrangements with meeting them and show them the vehicle while we're on site.
|
01:06:42
|
|
OK. Yeah. Thank you. Because like I said, if I was going to bid on one, I'd like to go kick the tire to be sure what I was bidding
|
01:06:50
|
|
on.
|
01:06:54
|
|
You know, anyway, thank you and and you said in the advertisement you're going to give your cell phone numbers to someone to make
|
01:06:58
|
|
an appointment to go get tires.
|
01:07:02
|
|
Yes, Sir. That'll be probably the easiest way for us to navigate that.
|
01:07:07
|
|
OK, I hope you get lots of calls and and we do well with the object.
|
01:07:12
|
|
Sure. Thank you, Klein. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So Mayor, is there going to be a list coming out pretty quick to supervisors on
|
01:07:16
|
|
these vehicles or are we going to agenda item?
|
01:07:22
|
|
OK. OK. Right on.
|
01:07:28
|
|
And then each one also indicates why it's in county possession, such as evidence seizure.
|
01:07:31
|
|
And if it was related to a fund or if they are.
|
01:07:40
|
|
Surplus vehicles that have been inactivated from the fleet.
|
01:07:46
|
|
Where those service funds are so that as revenue comes in, it goes back to the original purchase source or the original work
|
01:07:50
|
|
source.
|
01:07:55
|
|
So I see that we're coming up on our next agenda item. There's going to be some of these vehicles going to another agent.
|
01:08:01
|
|
So with like the the reservations, the tribes I deal with every once in a while, they're looking for something specific or a
|
01:08:09
|
|
school district or whatever it is, fire district.
|
01:08:15
|
|
So if there's something on this list, that's one of these other entities are looking for.
|
01:08:21
|
|
What would be my protocol to pull that off and?
|
01:08:28
|
|
Change it to an agenda item.
|
01:08:32
|
|
That you could reach out to Sergeant High Street and let him know. We have had a couple instances where.
|
01:08:35
|
|
Other agencies have asked, and we've had to tell them, what a fair market value is and the process has stalled there.
|
01:08:42
|
|
Because they.
|
01:08:50
|
|
Want us to hand over keys and we can't do that.
|
01:08:52
|
|
Without. Without you all approving it, right? No, I get that. And I'm looking at this here. But when it comes to another
|
01:08:56
|
|
governmental agency, Jessica.
|
01:09:01
|
|
The statement you made a while ago is this. The gifting clause doesn't apply.
|
01:09:06
|
|
Correct. Chairman, member supervisors. You do have to have appropriate authority, so in this instance.
|
01:09:11
|
|
11-251, subsection 9 There is authority in there. By unanimous consent of the board, you guys could vote to not have an auction
|
01:09:19
|
|
and sell to another governmental entity like you do have the authority to do that. There is a caveat, however. Today you're making
|
01:09:26
|
|
the motion to go forward with the public auction with these items.
|
01:09:34
|
|
And so it may be an issue for you to pull.
|
01:09:42
|
|
Vehicles off of the list if you don't have another board meeting.
|
01:09:47
|
|
Indicating that you're not authorizing those vehicles to be put on the auction list. So are you talking vehicles as a whole, or if
|
01:09:52
|
|
there's just one specific vehicle in the lot, a specific vehicle?
|
01:09:58
|
|
So basically.
|
01:10:06
|
|
OK. Yes. So today you're making the motion to move forward with the public surplus auction.
|
01:10:09
|
|
On March 29th. And so if you're intending to pull any sort of vehicle off of that, it would have to be quick and you would have to
|
01:10:15
|
|
have another board meeting to make an amendment to that publication.
|
01:10:21
|
|
OK. Because I don't know for sure that that would be the case, I.
|
01:10:28
|
|
Would be looking at anything specifically, you know, I just hadn't seen this list.
|
01:10:32
|
|
Until, I guess it teach me not to pay attention.
|
01:10:38
|
|
So just now, but.
|
01:10:41
|
|
So we're probably set in motion as it is and if something comes up I can just tell them where to bid.
|
01:10:44
|
|
Correct, correct. But I believe we have these auctions often.
|
01:10:50
|
|
And there's inventory fluctuating through the Sheriff's Office. So you could also reach out to Deputy High Street and he could let
|
01:10:56
|
|
you know if there's other vehicles that do become available.
|
01:11:01
|
|
Thanks. Thank you.
|
01:11:08
|
|
I have one question, where does the money go that is generated through the auction?
|
01:11:11
|
|
It depends on where the vehicle originated from.
|
01:11:16
|
|
So and.
|
01:11:20
|
|
These little parenthetical references next to them show where they came from. So like.
|
01:11:22
|
|
That, for example, the 2008 Suzuki scooter says it's an abandoned vehicle general fund. So those funds would any funds generated
|
01:11:30
|
|
from the sale of that would go to the general fund. And the next line down the 1996 Dodge Ram indicates that it's a.
|
01:11:37
|
|
Vehicle. So those funds would have to go back into the.
|
01:11:45
|
|
Fund so that we were being the best possible stewards and keeping everything in line correctly, OK.
|
01:11:50
|
|
So they are identified vehicle by vehicle going through this list.
|
01:11:57
|
|
OK, great. It looks like a 20-30 vehicles, I mean quite a few. So we'll see, we'll see.
|
01:12:02
|
|
Well, if there's nothing else, then I'll call for a.
|
01:12:10
|
|
Mr. Chair.
|
01:12:16
|
|
I'll make the motion to authorize an online public auction through public surplus on March 29th, 2024.
|
01:12:18
|
|
To sell surplus or Oxley County vehicles and equipment is presented.
|
01:12:25
|
|
Mr. Chair, I'll second that motion, and a second to approve all those in favor. Say aye, aye.
|
01:12:30
|
|
Thank you, Marin. Item 44 E and an Officer High Street as well 4 E Information Discussion action to approve by unanimous consent
|
01:12:36
|
|
of the Board without a public auction intergovernmental agreement number.
|
01:12:45
|
|
02162024 with the Superior Police Department, which authorizes the sale of three county vehicles.
|
01:12:53
|
|
For a total amount of $750, of which these vehicles have been identified as surplus or obsolete county equipment.
|
01:13:01
|
|
Good morning, UH.
|
01:13:11
|
|
Mr. Chairman, Supervisor, Client, Supervisor Humphrey There are three vehicles on this list that are of interest for the superior
|
01:13:14
|
|
Police Department.
|
01:13:19
|
|
Their uses are.
|
01:13:25
|
|
Enumerated.
|
01:13:27
|
|
In the attachment and the attached IGA.
|
01:13:29
|
|
One will be for, I'm sorry, They will be for administrative undercover operations.
|
01:13:34
|
|
And when?
|
01:13:41
|
|
The fair market value of each of these is $250, so the total price of $750.
|
01:13:44
|
|
Is is fair consideration for them?
|
01:13:54
|
|
As County Attorney's Office has clarified, that is your discretion under ARS 11251 NINE.
|
01:13:57
|
|
OK. Thank you, Supervisor Humphrey.
|
01:14:07
|
|
So Supervisor Klein brought up this list and we can't sell anything off this list, but now we can sell something off. These three
|
01:14:10
|
|
are not included, OK. So those those were those were decided upon prior to this list or not added to this list that we just
|
01:14:17
|
|
approved?
|
01:14:23
|
|
Correct. OK.
|
01:14:30
|
|
That's the only question I had. So if I'm, I'm good, Mr. Chair.
|
01:14:32
|
|
This is Vita Klein.
|
01:14:39
|
|
I I think if Superior has used for these vehicles, that's great.
|
01:14:42
|
|
Whoever did the appraisals on those vehicles, we need to keep them around. So thank you, Jessica.
|
01:14:48
|
|
Yes, Chairman, member supervisors.
|
01:14:54
|
|
To my knowledge, I don't have anything documenting like a Kelley Blue Book evaluation or anything. However, the statute does not
|
01:14:58
|
|
require any sort of value be given to these vehicles. There is specific authority there that if the board is determining
|
01:15:05
|
|
unanimously that an option is not needed, then they can go ahead and utilize that property for another governmental entity with no
|
01:15:12
|
|
violation of the gift clause.
|
01:15:18
|
|
So what you're saying in short is we could give it to him and say charging them $750, but you would have to sell it to them?
|
01:15:26
|
|
For a dollar.
|
01:15:33
|
|
That's not your description. I mean, we're talking $750 for three vehicles. That's just not much anyway, granted, but.
|
01:15:35
|
|
OK, so we have the option to make a motion at our discretion.
|
01:15:46
|
|
That's my understanding. If there's nothing else, then I will call for.
|
01:15:52
|
|
Mr. Chair, I move to approve intergovernmental agreement.
|
01:15:56
|
|
02162024 with the Superior Police Department as presented.
|
01:15:59
|
|
I'll second that, Mr. Chair. Well, we have a motion and a second to approve. All those in favor. Say aye. Aye, aye. Motion passes
|
01:16:06
|
|
unanimously. Thank you.
|
01:16:12
|
|
Item 4 After information discussion Action to approve Amendment #1 to A.
|
01:16:18
|
|
Agreement Contract #543-23 between the Arizona Department of Housing and the Gila County Public Health and Community Services
|
01:16:23
|
|
Department.
|
01:16:27
|
|
To extend the contract to June 30, 2024 and increase the contract by an additional $63,190.99 for a total contract amount of
|
01:16:31
|
|
$189,572.97.
|
01:16:39
|
|
One of the things that we do with this grant is we do allow it. It does allow for like the purchase of tents.
|
01:17:17
|
|
So it seems like a pretty good grant. I got to really look at what we spent money on over the last year and and it's been used
|
01:18:38
|
|
very well to help kind of keep people into their homes and keep them working, which is what we really want.
|
01:18:43
|
|
Thank you, Josh. Supervisor Humphrey. Yeah, a question. And the homelessness?
|
01:18:49
|
|
It do they need to be?
|
01:18:57
|
|
OK, without a home they don't have, they're not healing county residents I would get, but is there some consideration in being
|
01:18:59
|
|
healing county residents?
|
01:19:03
|
|
And the reason I ask that is because I know in homelessness there's a lot of them that commute winter to summer depending on where
|
01:19:40
|
|
they want to be homeless.
|
01:19:45
|
|
And so you know the people that are.
|
01:19:49
|
|
That are homeless and have been residents of Hila County. I'm just glad to see that they kind of get a thumbs up with this funding
|
01:19:52
|
|
and it's not just for whoever cares to blow through Hilo County to be honest there that month.
|
01:19:59
|
|
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'm pleasure.
|
01:20:07
|
|
Mr. Chair, Thank you, Josh. Thanks. First off, I want to tell you you got really good publicity on the radio here about the
|
01:20:10
|
|
combination.
|
01:20:14
|
|
Community services in your health department, too. So it was.
|
01:20:18
|
|
Secondly, when we did that, when we agreed to pursue the continuum of care some years ago.
|
01:20:23
|
|
You know, the county hadn't had that until we stepped on board here and we got it. That has been a really, really big plus for the
|
01:20:30
|
|
county.
|
01:20:33
|
|
For all the grant issues.
|
01:20:38
|
|
I you know looking at this I'm.
|
01:20:40
|
|
Just pretty happy to see the the way this money can be spent and what we can do to help these folks.
|
01:20:42
|
|
And I'm really thankful that we took that step.
|
01:20:48
|
|
Five years ago, six years ago, whatever was to do that as well. So thanks.
|
01:20:52
|
|
Thank you, Josh. Yeah, it's it's really refreshing to hear how it's helpful.
|
01:20:58
|
|
That this stuff really helps people. You learn new words. It's we never talked about transitional.
|
01:21:03
|
|
Housing or people in transition from being able to afford to be in their house, but the one breakdown away from losing their jobs.
|
01:21:09
|
|
Something And so it's it's very needed. So thank you. And with that I will call for a motion, Mr. Chair, I'll make the motion to
|
01:21:19
|
|
approve amendment number one to Arizona Department of Housing funding agreement contract number.
|
01:21:26
|
|
54323 as presented.
|
01:21:33
|
|
Mr. Chair, I'll second that motion in a second to approve those in favor. Say aye. Aye. Thank you, Joe.
|
01:21:36
|
|
Consent Agenda Items We have a consent agenda, item 5A through.
|
01:21:44
|
|
Supervisor Humphrey, would you like to remove one or more of these items for discussion? Mr. Chair, there's nothing I care to pull
|
01:21:50
|
|
and discuss individually. How about you supervise the client?
|
01:21:56
|
|
I think I'm good. Thank you. OK, then I'll call for a motion on our consent agenda items. Mr. Chair, I move to approve consent
|
01:22:03
|
|
agenda items 5A through.
|
01:22:08
|
|
5 E and I'll second that motion to approve, and 2nd those in favor say aye A.
|
01:22:13
|
|
Aye, Motion carries. And now we'll move on to item number six and call to the public. This is a portion of our.
|
01:22:18
|
|
Meeting where the Board of Supervisors on any issue within the jurisdiction of the Board.
|
01:22:27
|
|
Can listen to the public and but we cannot discuss.
|
01:22:35
|
|
Or vote on anything specific that's not on the agenda. So and that's in.
|
01:22:39
|
|
ARS38-431 point 01.
|
01:22:45
|
|
And so I will call, see if there's anyone present here. Are you Mr.
|
01:22:50
|
|
Bars.
|
01:22:56
|
|
Please come up and introduce yourself.
|
01:23:00
|
|
Very part time account 76. He was doing free work.
|
01:23:06
|
|
But have.
|
01:23:12
|
|
My colleagues up in Payson are there.
|
01:23:16
|
|
Apparently.
|
01:23:20
|
|
They had an idea that we were going to.
|
01:23:22
|
|
Ask for a hand count on.
|
01:23:25
|
|
Presidential preference election in.
|
01:23:27
|
|
Currently I got dropped that I got a notice this morning.
|
01:23:31
|
|
I'm not going to do that. So that's why I thought I scheduled this to be here and.
|
01:23:34
|
|
I have many other things in my schedule, like many of you do, but I wouldn't want you to keep open to the ideas of election
|
01:23:41
|
|
integrity. Anyhow, I know that you've already approved the voting machines and I was here a couple months ago when you did all
|
01:23:47
|
|
that and you know, I I'm not asking for a change there, but.
|
01:23:52
|
|
You know the the state.
|
01:23:59
|
|
The legislature did pass a bill recently on election integrity. Finally, Kitty Hobbs finally approved woman after rejecting 88% of
|
01:24:03
|
|
the other ones.
|
01:24:07
|
|
That were proposed. So I think one of you with got.
|
01:24:12
|
|
A movie sent to you. You Mr. Christensen, let my people go and it's a two hour and 10 minute movie. I saw the movie Very good, has
|
01:24:20
|
|
a lot of things in it that are related to the January 6th people that are still in jail.
|
01:24:29
|
|
They didn't do anything. They had no weapons, They didn't do any crime. There's no and they're still in jail. Also dealt with the
|
01:24:40
|
|
election issues, even in the state.
|
01:24:44
|
|
I recently had a talk with Eric and I let him talk for a long time on. He's very strong supportive of what we what you do here and
|
01:24:51
|
|
I'm not contesting that that in our county, it's pretty honest.
|
01:24:58
|
|
But in statewide, you know he defends the state tool and that there's no that there's no there's no real issues in the in the
|
01:25:07
|
|
state I went online and since 2020 there are 10 criminal convictions of people that were fraudulent in the elections. I can list
|
01:25:14
|
|
their names. Gloria, Nadia, Victor, Tracy, Marsha Johnson.
|
01:25:21
|
|
Either guilty of fraudulent use of absentee ballots or.
|
01:25:29
|
|
Ineligible voting.
|
01:25:35
|
|
And so there are things in a minor scale. But then I also talked to a man named Mark Hook who helped with this movie. He also
|
01:25:37
|
|
helped count the ballots and when they were questioned as far as the signature verification. And he said he was there when he
|
01:25:45
|
|
helped cone him and he showed the actual signatures and they did not match. There were not even there. And it wasn't just a few.
|
01:25:52
|
|
He said there were 100,000.
|
01:25:59
|
|
That did not match in any way, shape or form. That's mostly in Maricopa Other county. I know that. But I ask you to keep your eyes
|
01:26:07
|
|
open and and listen to that movie if you can, if you can share that with your partners here, I would encourage you to do that
|
01:26:14
|
|
because you know, I read this morning, I'm reading the attitudes. I'm a former pastor and I do missionary work. Still I see a
|
01:26:20
|
|
gospel tracks wherever I go.
|
01:26:27
|
|
But Matthew Henry Commentary. One of the oldest commentaries in the Bible, by the way.
|
01:26:35
|
|
Is it shares this main principle that whatever you would do.
|
01:26:39
|
|
That men should do views do even to them. It's called the Golden Rule.
|
01:26:46
|
|
So if I might miss 3 minutes are off, am I hearing a note?
|
01:26:50
|
|
Not yet. OK, so Christ came to teach us not only what we are to know and believe that what we are to do.
|
01:26:54
|
|
What we are to do, not only toward God, but toward men, not only towards our fellow disciples, those of our party and persuasion,
|
01:27:02
|
|
but towards men in general, all with whom we have to do. That's a basic prin.
|
01:27:08
|
|
And we should all be alarmed when someone cheats us, someone does something wrong, and as the election comes up, I don't know
|
01:27:15
|
|
whether he may be called to from us who are in the Republican Party to adopt something. I don't know.
|
01:27:22
|
|
This obviously didn't translate her today, but you know, we know in Iowa one person, one vote, it worked in one day. They have,
|
01:27:31
|
|
they are counting. Look at that. It was very valid. So encourage you to encourage you to follow that principle, OK?
|
01:27:39
|
|
That's all. Thank you, Mr. Birchness.
|
01:27:48
|
|
I believe I can speak for all of us saying that we that we want a good and clean election in Gila County and so we are concerned
|
01:27:52
|
|
about that. So thank you for your presentation and your and your shared concern. We have to stay within the statutes that we're
|
01:27:57
|
|
limited to so.
|
01:28:03
|
|
OK. All right. Is there anyone else here in Globe that wishes to speak?
|
01:28:09
|
|
How about?
|
01:28:14
|
|
And on the Internet.
|
01:28:16
|
|
How many do we have?
|
01:28:19
|
|
20, OK. Thank you.
|
01:28:21
|
|
All right then I'll close call to the public.
|
01:28:23
|
|
And Ivan 7.
|
01:28:26
|
|
Is where we have our sharing time, so I will turn it over to County Manager Menlo.
|
01:28:29
|
|
Thank you, Mr.
|
01:28:36
|
|
Last week, they met with trustees for the Arizona Local Government Employee Benefit Trust, which is a group of 6 counties.
|
01:28:38
|
|
Rural counties in Arizona that combine for health insurance for our employees.
|
01:28:47
|
|
The trust is doing.
|
01:28:52
|
|
Financially, we have been.
|
01:28:55
|
|
Are in the back for this year and and it means that our proposed rates for fiscal year 2425 are much more reasonable than they
|
01:28:58
|
|
were a year ago. You recall a year ago we had double.
|
01:29:04
|
|
Inflation related to COVID and everything and so we had double digit increase to our health insurance costs. It's much more
|
01:29:11
|
|
reasonable this year and so I know that.
|
01:29:15
|
|
Pleased with the.
|
01:29:20
|
|
That is much more manageable with our health insurance for our employees coming.
|
01:29:23
|
|
This coming.
|
01:29:27
|
|
Also in the last week of.
|
01:29:29
|
|
Representative Eli Cranes Office Senator Cinema.
|
01:29:33
|
|
And Senator Kelly?
|
01:29:37
|
|
In addition to many federal agencies.
|
01:29:39
|
|
Such.
|
01:29:43
|
|
Your Department of Interior with Homeland Security and with other ones that all relate to interactive what we do.
|
01:29:46
|
|
Our our priorities in Gila.
|
01:29:56
|
|
And so met those and worked with funding on on the federal government a number different directions. That's my report, Mr.
|
01:29:59
|
|
Chairman. All right. Thank you, Supervisor. Hopefully.
|
01:30:04
|
|
Yeah, Mr. Hilda Roosevelt community meeting on February the 12th.
|
01:30:10
|
|
Within KQS on February the 12th at 5:30 PM.
|
01:30:16
|
|
That evening, attended the Town of Miami Hall meeting with the mayor. Council attended an ID, A meeting, Industrial Development
|
01:30:22
|
|
Authority meeting.
|
01:30:27
|
|
We worked with the health department, one of these investment properties that are in limbo for 10 years.
|
01:30:35
|
|
Became such a health hazard that we were able to go in and demo a portion of that, but only the portion that was deemed a health
|
01:30:44
|
|
hazard. We couldn't clear the whole property, but that that's a benefit because we have a lot of these properties. I, I, I, I took
|
01:30:50
|
|
pictures of it and wrote a little story.
|
01:30:56
|
|
Be out in the paper here shortly, thanks to Terry helped me write it. And so anyway, that's a good thing on some of these
|
01:31:03
|
|
properties that are blighted that we at least found a loophole where we can get the health department involved in some of these
|
01:31:09
|
|
that are really, really in bad shape.
|
01:31:15
|
|
And then I'll I'll attend ATRSD Tri-City, Sanitation.
|
01:31:22
|
|
Department.
|
01:31:29
|
|
Tonight at.
|
01:31:31
|
|
I think 5:15.
|
01:31:34
|
|
And so anyway, that's all I have. James and Supervisor Klein, thanks for representing us in Washington.
|
01:31:36
|
|
On your trip, We appreciate you.
|
01:31:42
|
|
Your efforts.
|
01:31:44
|
|
Other than that, Mr. Chair, that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Surprised a client. I'm anxious to hear what happened in
|
01:31:46
|
|
Washington.
|
01:31:49
|
|
So it was a good trip, I think. I think we've had good discussions.
|
01:31:54
|
|
Flew in there Friday.
|
01:31:59
|
|
I attended Public Lands Conference all day Saturday.
|
01:32:01
|
|
Had some speakers.
|
01:32:05
|
|
Talked about some different things that's going on in other counties. One thing that came up in that particular discussion was
|
01:32:07
|
|
there are some counties.
|
01:32:11
|
|
North of us Colorado up in there that have really dove into some workforce housing.
|
01:32:15
|
|
And it was brought up through the lands department and stuff like that, how they they went about it. But really what I got down to
|
01:32:21
|
|
was just the money part, you know, some of them.
|
01:32:26
|
|
Bank accounts and money behind them to pull it off and get started. Other ones were looking at bonding out and doing things that
|
01:32:31
|
|
way suppose, but it was a really good discussion there.
|
01:32:35
|
|
Not a lot going on overall in public lands.
|
01:32:40
|
|
Heard from the Natural Resource.
|
01:32:46
|
|
Committee Brandon Miller was there, gave a little update on some bills, but pretty much typical stuff going through right now.
|
01:32:49
|
|
They're trying to work on WI are the next.
|
01:32:56
|
|
Was pretty much a recap of public lands. For the most part, it wasn't.
|
01:32:59
|
|
Out of anything different and but it was a good trip All in all.
|
01:33:04
|
|
It was. We came back on Tuesday.
|
01:33:09
|
|
Didn't seem like there's a lot of participation this year. It seemed to me like it was down, but maybe not.
|
01:33:13
|
|
Speakers were a little like, but it was, it was all right, it was.
|
01:33:19
|
|
So you guys just turn next time.
|
01:33:24
|
|
Anyway, going on.
|
01:33:30
|
|
The other day I signed on to a letter to Director Vilsack Department of AG.
|
01:33:33
|
|
Regarding the funding with the four part project and the continued issues with contracts and funding and other counties as well
|
01:33:39
|
|
has done that or supervisors not counties, but anyway we sent them off through ECO.
|
01:33:46
|
|
Through the board, that was we got that done. House Bill, HR 1829.
|
01:33:53
|
|
Passed out of the House and Natural Resource Committee unanimously on February 7th.
|
01:34:01
|
|
So what that means is both bills have now passed out of committee and are and are on the floor for further activity for the vet
|
01:34:07
|
|
center.
|
01:34:11
|
|
So we've we've gotten over a couple really major hurdles, right. So they're sitting on the floor ready to be addressed there and
|
01:34:16
|
|
attached to another bill or how are they going to do it? I I'd kind of like to see them just take them on as its own bill and go
|
01:34:22
|
|
on with it, but but anyway it's it's sitting there.
|
01:34:28
|
|
One thing, one little bit of information we learned was out of all the thousands of bills that that are proposed and and out
|
01:34:34
|
|
there.
|
01:34:38
|
|
Only 11% get to where we are.
|
01:34:42
|
|
With this bill.
|
01:34:45
|
|
So I think that's a pretty good indicator that we're on the right track.
|
01:34:47
|
|
Where that's.
|
01:34:51
|
|
I I was.
|
01:34:56
|
|
Honored the other day I had a invite from Congressman.
|
01:34:57
|
|
To go back to DC on somewhere right around the 6th of March.
|
01:35:02
|
|
And sit with him on the state of the Union address.
|
01:35:07
|
|
So I'm looking forward to that. I hope it goes through and I make it back there. It'll be a quick trip, just two or three days.
|
01:35:11
|
|
But it's something I think would be really cool to sit there in person.
|
01:35:19
|
|
In the middle of it all and listen and watch how all that goes on. So I watched them on TVA lot and but I think from a personal
|
01:35:24
|
|
standpoint being there in person would really.
|
01:35:30
|
|
I got an ECO meeting coming up this Wednesday, February 21st. That's at 2:00 at the State Capital CSA.
|
01:35:39
|
|
Building I'm planning on being.
|
01:35:47
|
|
And the YCC crew update, you know every year we we push for YCC crew and sometimes we don't get anybody applies.
|
01:35:50
|
|
The Forest Service did apply for the funding and hopefully soon.
|
01:36:00
|
|
Maybe this week they'll know whether or not they got the funding for the crew.
|
01:36:05
|
|
Last year, last two years, they had gotten the funding, but we couldn't get the applicants to fill the crew. We got enough
|
01:36:09
|
|
applicants in Globe to fill this one, but we couldn't fill the one.
|
01:36:14
|
|
So I'm hoping that they get the funding again and give us the chance to to put those two crews together.
|
01:36:20
|
|
And then?
|
01:36:28
|
|
Monday 26th we've got a meeting with the state staff here in Arizona.
|
01:36:30
|
|
To discuss the possibility of partnerships with our.
|
01:36:36
|
|
Group or or.
|
01:36:40
|
|
Summer work program.
|
01:36:43
|
|
I brought that up to him in Superior here while back a couple weeks ago to the governor. She was there with her staff and I
|
01:36:44
|
|
brought up our summer youth program.
|
01:36:50
|
|
And her main staffer was very much interested in that.
|
01:36:55
|
|
Hopefully he's going to be there.
|
01:37:00
|
|
Somebody he appoints to be there to talk to us about it. And I can, you know, they know more about what we do. I only had a few
|
01:37:03
|
|
minutes that day, but.
|
01:37:08
|
|
And hopefully he's going to look in there and see if there's some funding from the state level that they can help.
|
01:37:14
|
|
Help with that as well so.
|
01:37:18
|
|
So I'm looking forward to that meeting on Monday.
|
01:37:21
|
|
And with any luck, maybe we can get more money and work with more kids. We had 50 plus kids last year.
|
01:37:24
|
|
But I believe we had some kids that we couldn't work in the funding. Is that right you?
|
01:37:33
|
|
Yeah, not a lot, but a few.
|
01:37:39
|
|
Yeah.
|
01:37:43
|
|
Yeah. So I'm hoping that if the state will, will throw in there with us.
|
01:37:46
|
|
And we can bump that up.
|
01:37:52
|
|
Keep stacking these kids in there and giving them something to do in the summer. It'll be a really good thing.
|
01:37:54
|
|
Yeah. And Pinal County is looking at our program right now.
|
01:38:01
|
|
And they're wanting to sit down and visit with me or Kathy or both of us about what's going on.
|
01:38:05
|
|
Well, so we got it. We're good. Anything from the Blight Blast Buster deal?
|
01:38:12
|
|
OK. We're good. OK. Thank God. Thank you. Good report.
|
01:38:18
|
|
So Speaking of bills, the state legislature has put forth over 16150 some bills at this point and they managed to pass one.
|
01:38:24
|
|
And one was signed into law. And it does.
|
01:38:36
|
|
Affect the elections process.
|
01:38:39
|
|
And I don't know every detail about it but.
|
01:38:42
|
|
It affects dates mainly to provide enough space and room.
|
01:38:46
|
|
To do hand counting or auto recounts or whatever that may come forth. Right now, the county officials are unable to.
|
01:38:51
|
|
Institute many of the things that were requested to do simply because it's not part of the state statute. And so our state
|
01:39:02
|
|
legislature needs to change some things in order to adopt some of the things that we see in these movies or that are recommended
|
01:39:08
|
|
to us so.
|
01:39:13
|
|
I think that that's probably a good thing. Some of the dates have changed as far.
|
01:39:21
|
|
The election and deadlines and things like that. So that's my report on the LPC portion. I wasn't able to.
|
01:39:25
|
|
Was invited to attend the.
|
01:39:36
|
|
What's called the best of the rim?
|
01:39:38
|
|
And that's.
|
01:39:41
|
|
Something the pacing roundup puts on so out of the casino.
|
01:39:43
|
|
Businesses and.
|
01:39:47
|
|
Various organizations.
|
01:39:51
|
|
Are voted upon every year to receive.
|
01:39:54
|
|
What's called the best of the?
|
01:39:57
|
|
And so there, it's an awards banquet.
|
01:39:59
|
|
And so it was really fun to do that. And then also we have the County wide spelling Bee.
|
01:40:03
|
|
Payson at the school, so we had.
|
01:40:13
|
|
Kids from San Carlos from Tunnel Basin Globe.
|
01:40:16
|
|
Hasten.
|
01:40:21
|
|
That were the finalists and they came to the spelling bee and I was honored to be one of the judges.
|
01:40:24
|
|
And I can't spell worth anything, but anyway, these kids were amazing.
|
01:40:30
|
|
They were spelling words I didn't even know existed.
|
01:40:36
|
|
And.
|
01:40:39
|
|
They were doing really well and so the probably was about.
|
01:40:42
|
|
I think it was 36.
|
01:40:45
|
|
And so it was pretty exciting, especially when it got down to the end.
|
01:40:48
|
|
Was on Kmog yesterday. Usually I get a lot of callers and I did as well yesterday.
|
01:40:53
|
|
So once a month I'm on KMOG and so they call in ask questions.
|
01:40:59
|
|
And everyone's interested in Pleasant Valley Retreat. They're interested in the bridge. They're interested.
|
01:41:05
|
|
The fairgrounds, they're interested in all the various projects that that goes on.
|
01:41:12
|
|
So it's usually a very positive experience. And then tonight I noticed that Eli Crane is going to be in Payson at Chinese
|
01:41:17
|
|
Restaurant tonight.
|
01:41:21
|
|
Hosted by the.
|
01:41:26
|
|
Tea party.
|
01:41:30
|
|
Tea Party, so that starts at six.
|
01:41:32
|
|
And also at the end of the month here, I think it's February 29th.
|
01:41:35
|
|
Have an appointment with Senator Kelly's representative.
|
01:41:41
|
|
Miss Rogers and Gary Morris and I will.
|
01:41:46
|
|
Filling her in on the Fossil Creek.
|
01:41:50
|
|
Recreation area issues and.
|
01:41:53
|
|
We've got David Cook, we've got Eli Senator.
|
01:41:56
|
|
Kelly and a few others that are starting to converge on.
|
01:42:01
|
|
To where we can maybe get some things improved there for public safety.
|
01:42:07
|
|
So that's all I have. So if there's nothing else in that list, yes, Sir. Yeah, it kind of sparked something for me. If I can have
|
01:42:11
|
|
just another minute.
|
01:42:16
|
|
You know and and a lot of this is thanks very much to staff and the approval of the board. But we're working on the, the payment
|
01:42:22
|
|
project from Daishila from the top of the hill down.
|
01:42:27
|
|
We're working the the bridge is supposed to be open probably in March, but not finished in completion until April or May.
|
01:42:33
|
|
We're working on a drainage project at Roosevelt on Stagecoach that's about halfway down or or close. It's a real mess right now,
|
01:42:43
|
|
but but it's going to get better because it's going to drain that area and then we've done some some Rd. surfacing and working on.
|
01:42:51
|
|
Roads and tunnel basin like Crappie Lane and some of those we're putting on a different surface material.
|
01:43:01
|
|
And so trying to make our roads last a little better.
|
01:43:08
|
|
And now they're doing rollers to compact what we do put down on the back of the blade. So hopefully we'll be able to get more life
|
01:43:12
|
|
out of the roads that we do and Mr. Chair, that's it. I just, I just wanted to do a hats off to staff and and appreciate the board
|
01:43:17
|
|
and helping with these projects.
|
01:43:23
|
|
OK, very good. Real quick, Mr. Chair, on that side, I'm glad you brought those rollers.
|
01:43:30
|
|
Supervisor Humphrey, so thank you for purchasing those.
|
01:43:35
|
|
Homero Because everybody seems real happy with them and looks to me like they're going to work good on these roads. Really, Kind
|
01:43:39
|
|
of.
|
01:43:43
|
|
Tamp them down good.
|
01:43:47
|
|
Thank you. We can only purchase them because the board supports it well. It was, it was a good purchase. So I appreciate that.
|
01:43:49
|
|
Great. I have nothing else. If there is nothing else, then we'll move on to our last item.
|
01:43:57
|
|
Item 8A. It's a work session.
|
01:44:03
|
|
So we're going to have information and discussion regarding the Pleasant Valley Veterans Retreats draft policy.
|
01:44:07
|
|
Named Cost, Schedule and Fe.
|
01:44:15
|
|
Joseph, good morning, German morning.
|
01:44:18
|
|
As you mentioned, this is a pretty straightforward policy that's directly supporting the Pleasant Valley Veterans Retreat. It is
|
01:44:22
|
|
the cost schedule.
|
01:44:26
|
|
This is just an opportunity for us to bring the baseline up to the board.
|
01:44:30
|
|
To be able to get feedback and recommendations. So even though this is formatted as a policy.
|
01:44:36
|
|
This is just a discussion to see how we want to proceed forward. So on the front end, I'll go over the eligibility and then I'll
|
01:44:42
|
|
step into how we came to the fees and payments.
|
01:44:48
|
|
And then we'll step into the fees and.
|
01:44:53
|
|
The eligibility facility rentals are available to active duty all veterans of all eras. Eligible members are welcome to bring
|
01:44:56
|
|
their immediate family members and those of immediate family members or spouse, children and parents.
|
01:45:03
|
|
One of the requirements outlined here are Verification of Eligibility providing official Department of Defense DoD documentation.
|
01:45:11
|
|
And that is going to be a military ID or a DD214.
|
01:45:18
|
|
Joseph, can I just ask you a question at this juncture? Yes, please. So when you say.
|
01:45:25
|
|
All veterans.
|
01:45:31
|
|
That's sort of.
|
01:45:33
|
|
Vague to me. Would it also then include those in the National Guard?
|
01:45:35
|
|
Would it include?
|
01:45:40
|
|
More abstract, what you wouldn't consider necessarily a veteran, but was part of a military structure of some sort.
|
01:45:43
|
|
Folk art on you know, I know, Coast Guard the department.
|
01:45:51
|
|
Yes, you understand what I mean.
|
01:45:55
|
|
Anyone Any veteran of any sort?
|
01:45:59
|
|
Chairman, Board of Supervisors. That is correct. So it'd be any.
|
01:46:04
|
|
Military personnel that are active duty or a retired veteran.
|
01:46:08
|
|
OK. All right. Thanks.
|
01:46:12
|
|
No problem.
|
01:46:15
|
|
So just briefly, we did.
|
01:46:17
|
|
Couple.
|
01:46:20
|
|
Case studies from peer review.
|
01:46:21
|
|
That were very similar in size and objective when it came to A501C3 retreat and others locations that were maybe not a retreat but
|
01:46:24
|
|
did support veteran causes similar to what we're trying to drive forward.
|
01:46:32
|
|
What we identified there is we.
|
01:46:40
|
|
And there there was a lot of things that we were able to learn from those case studies and examples.
|
01:46:43
|
|
And through those conversations, but at the end of the day, we're given the opportunity to create something that directly
|
01:46:50
|
|
supports.
|
01:46:54
|
|
The Pleasant Valley Veterans, Ret.
|
01:46:58
|
|
The cost that we came up.
|
01:47:02
|
|
Are directly connected to the operational status of the site.
|
01:47:05
|
|
There is no profit in line with this.
|
01:47:10
|
|
So we did a cost.
|
01:47:13
|
|
Across the entire site, how much does it cost us to operate on a daily?
|
01:47:15
|
|
But also what's rolled into it is the sustainability practice.
|
01:47:21
|
|
Of direct replace.
|
01:47:25
|
|
For the site.
|
01:47:27
|
|
If we know we're going to be replacing HVAC systems in the next 25 years, we need to start investing in that now.
|
01:47:30
|
|
And that's rolled into the cost. So please keep that in mind.
|
01:47:36
|
|
The single family cabins is a flat rate that we're looking at for $230.
|
01:47:41
|
|
The multi room Barrett costs are 58.
|
01:47:47
|
|
And just kind of give the board a little bit of a recap the cabins can support. It's a 3 bedroom.
|
01:47:50
|
|
Can support a.
|
01:47:57
|
|
The multi room.
|
01:47:59
|
|
Are a common facility.
|
01:48:02
|
|
With single.
|
01:48:05
|
|
The other thing that we broke out into this cost schedule is something that is in line with.
|
01:48:10
|
|
One of the primary goals of the Pleasant Valley veterans Ret.
|
01:48:16
|
|
And that is to create a landing for 501C3S and other partners that directly support.
|
01:48:20
|
|
Supporting veterans.
|
01:48:26
|
|
A broad title.
|
01:48:28
|
|
With that, we gave it a sliding scale of cost.
|
01:48:32
|
|
When it comes to supporting those 501.
|
01:48:37
|
|
What we tied that into.
|
01:48:41
|
|
The number of veterans, qualified veterans that they're bringing in to be able to support.
|
01:48:44
|
|
So when we go through the qualifications, it's a pretty straightforward qualification.
|
01:48:51
|
|
We are able to verify if they're A501C3 that directly supports veteran causes.
|
01:48:55
|
|
And of course, the quantity of veterans that they're going to be bringing in to support.
|
01:49:01
|
|
As a quick example, Tier 4 is a nonprofit that supports one to five qualified veterans.
|
01:49:07
|
|
And have a 501C3 qualification are eligible for a 25% REL.
|
01:49:14
|
|
Now that's on the bottom end or the top end of the scale, depending on how you look at it.
|
01:49:19
|
|
On the other end of the scale, the Tier 1 nonprofit support that supports 15 or more qualified veterans.
|
01:49:25
|
|
And have a 501C3 qualification or eligible for an 85% relief.
|
01:49:31
|
|
Again, these are some of our recommendations based off of our peer-to-peer reviews and our research.
|
01:49:35
|
|
We are absolutely open to any thoughts or recommendations for that. I'd like to open the floor for any questions.
|
01:49:43
|
|
Or comments?
|
01:49:51
|
|
Thank you, Joseph Supervisor Humphrey.
|
01:49:53
|
|
Yeah, I guess I'm confused.
|
01:49:58
|
|
Because my deal centers here, says.
|
01:50:01
|
|
Work session.
|
01:50:04
|
|
So OK, I guess my deal is with all of the costs and stuff.
|
01:50:08
|
|
And what you come up for cost of the 230?
|
01:50:17
|
|
With an 85% rel.
|
01:50:21
|
|
Then how do you?
|
01:50:24
|
|
How are you gonna replace stuff in 25 years if if you?
|
01:50:26
|
|
Given 85%.
|
01:50:31
|
|
To people who are.
|
01:50:33
|
|
That chairman, Board of Supervisor.
|
01:50:35
|
|
Humphrey.
|
01:50:38
|
|
What we're looking at doing is so if an individual as a veteran or his family wants to come up.
|
01:50:41
|
|
They will not qualify for.
|
01:50:47
|
|
Slideshow A501C.
|
01:50:49
|
|
That comes in typically bringing those higher numbers.
|
01:50:54
|
|
It's just an opportunity for them.
|
01:50:57
|
|
Be able to support.
|
01:51:00
|
|
While at the same.
|
01:51:02
|
|
Making it affordable for some of those larger 501.
|
01:51:04
|
|
An example, we have some that were coming in around 15.
|
01:51:08
|
|
They're looking to.
|
01:51:13
|
|
If we charge them the normal rate.
|
01:51:15
|
|
That we would be looking at about a 10 to $12,000 fee for them.
|
01:51:17
|
|
Now don't get me wrong.
|
01:51:23
|
|
That would really put us in a great place from.
|
01:51:24
|
|
Practice or.
|
01:51:28
|
|
Maintenance side of it.
|
01:51:30
|
|
However, we don't require that on the first year.
|
01:51:32
|
|
That's something that we're looking to gain over a long period of time.
|
01:51:35
|
|
Is.
|
01:51:39
|
|
The thought that the tiered.
|
01:51:43
|
|
Will not have a negative effect on our ability to be sustainable over the long period of time.
|
01:51:46
|
|
Anything else supervisor? Yeah, I guess another question is we have other facilities that we.
|
01:52:08
|
|
In charge for people to have functions there.
|
01:52:15
|
|
Do we have the same sliding scale?
|
01:52:21
|
|
For those facilities.
|
01:52:24
|
|
You don't have to answer that right now because we're on a work session for Pleasant Valley, but that's one I wanted to throw out
|
01:52:26
|
|
there for when we have a work session on some of those other facilities.
|
01:52:31
|
|
That we're leasing out good news. We're looking to apply the same thought process and technique across the board.
|
01:52:37
|
|
Nothing else, Mr. Chair.
|
01:52:47
|
|
Supervisor.
|
01:52:49
|
|
Thank you, Mr. Chair, so.
|
01:52:52
|
|
So I'm just going to jump into it. I don't believe we used to charge veterans anything.
|
01:52:56
|
|
I personally believe you veterans, and I'm not a veteran, but you veterans have already paid the price for anything that's going
|
01:53:01
|
|
to go on on this particular site.
|
01:53:05
|
|
And with that, I want to clarify that because this site can only be used for veterans.
|
01:53:10
|
|
It's not a fairground, so we can have fairs or rock shows or gun shows or anything like that. It can only be used for veterans or
|
01:53:17
|
|
in support of.
|
01:53:21
|
|
So to me, a couple things. Like I said once, as far as I'm concerned, all you veterans, everyone of you out there, whatever branch
|
01:53:28
|
|
it's in, has already sacrificed and paid that price. Secondly, I look at this site a lot differently in the fact it was given to
|
01:53:33
|
|
us.
|
01:53:39
|
|
We didn't build.
|
01:53:46
|
|
It was already built and we repurposed.
|
01:53:48
|
|
And I think as as far as I'm concerned, that's a way that I feel like I can give back to you folks that was out there, you know
|
01:53:51
|
|
overseas and loading square for all that time that I wasn't.
|
01:53:58
|
|
And that's and I and I know what you're saying about the cost.
|
01:54:06
|
|
Whether it's an HVAC system or whatever.
|
01:54:10
|
|
What about the cost you guys put in there?
|
01:54:13
|
|
And so when I look at this, that's what I really see.
|
01:54:17
|
|
And I I would feel.
|
01:54:20
|
|
I would be fine if there was some kind of donations that could be out there, whatever, but overall for for what This site is and
|
01:54:23
|
|
what it's purposed for.
|
01:54:28
|
|
And for what you folks have.
|
01:54:34
|
|
No, I don't think there should be a cost. I think that's something that the county.
|
01:54:37
|
|
Can hold up and that we can work with through whether it's other grants, it's other.
|
01:54:41
|
|
Money from from where?
|
01:54:48
|
|
I honestly believe the money will come. It doesn't have to be out your guys's and gals pocket.
|
01:54:50
|
|
That's that's where I'm at with it.
|
01:54:57
|
|
Mr. Chairman, thank you. Thank you. Supervisor Arnold Joseph, how much do you estimate will be the cost of running this facility?
|
01:55:00
|
|
Annually.
|
01:55:08
|
|
Annually.
|
01:55:11
|
|
I don't have that finger in front of me, so I'd have to.
|
01:55:14
|
|
OK, so.
|
01:55:18
|
|
There's upkeep.
|
01:55:19
|
|
There's replacement, there's insurance.
|
01:55:21
|
|
There's.
|
01:55:25
|
|
You haven't any sort of a vague idea of what that looks like. We also have an employee or more.
|
01:55:27
|
|
Those kind of things, Roger, that Chairman, Board of Supervisors, yes, we do have that number. Unfortunately, I don't have that in
|
01:55:33
|
|
front of me, but I'd be happy to get that to you.
|
01:55:37
|
|
OK. Would you say it would be 100,000?
|
01:55:42
|
|
I mean, am I off base? Am I 200,000?
|
01:55:46
|
|
You have no idea. I mean, you don't want to guess, I know.
|
01:55:50
|
|
Correct. So we do have that number, but again, I don't want to give.
|
01:55:53
|
|
So I agree with supervisor.
|
01:56:00
|
|
I think that the fees.
|
01:56:03
|
|
High, actually.
|
01:56:06
|
|
We may. I would accept a much lower fee just to help.
|
01:56:08
|
|
As a kind of a donation situation, maybe 10 dollars, $20, whatever. But if there's going to be an event, maybe there would be a
|
01:56:14
|
|
fee for that where there'd be a whole.
|
01:56:19
|
|
Great. Big event where the impact to utilities and things like that would be there. There could be some sort of a fee.
|
01:56:24
|
|
But I think I agree with him.
|
01:56:31
|
|
That we should.
|
01:56:34
|
|
We should try and pay for this through donations and grants as much as possible.
|
01:56:36
|
|
OK, your tiers here.
|
01:56:42
|
|
I just did some quick math.
|
01:56:46
|
|
If a person went from Tier 4 to tier 3 by just adding one one individual.
|
01:56:49
|
|
They're going to save 25%.
|
01:56:56
|
|
Which they would actually payless to do 6 people than to do the five. So the reduction there.
|
01:56:59
|
|
Quite a bit. I mean it's significant. And then the next one is also another 25.
|
01:57:10
|
|
And.
|
01:57:15
|
|
It would not make sense for someone to come in and say let's sponsor 5.
|
01:57:19
|
|
When let's just grab another one one person.
|
01:57:23
|
|
Will Payless doing?
|
01:57:28
|
|
You understand what I'm saying there? Absolutely. The relief is so much that.
|
01:57:30
|
|
It would not make sense to do 5 or less.
|
01:57:37
|
|
Chairman, Board of Supervisors. That is a very great point.
|
01:57:41
|
|
To the advantage of the tiered system, I think you point out the advantage to it.
|
01:57:44
|
|
It encourages these other 501 CS to pull more into our site, so if they do have.
|
01:57:49
|
|
Say at one of those numbers of the threshold 5, it encourages them to have minimum shrine pull in another one to get into that
|
01:57:55
|
|
other.
|
01:57:59
|
|
Tiered.
|
01:58:04
|
|
Feed pay schedule. Excuse me.
|
01:58:07
|
|
And then so on. So even if a nonprofit has one to five, it would be to their benefit to pull in 15 veterans versus just one to
|
01:58:10
|
|
five.
|
01:58:14
|
|
So I think it goes to one of your points is it encourages them. It encourages it, right? OK.
|
01:58:19
|
|
So I'm going to ask James and then it looks like you have another question. Oh, whenever, James, so the sustainability of this
|
01:58:24
|
|
facility, can you enlighten us on the financial side of this?
|
01:58:31
|
|
Sure, Mr. Chairman, member of the Board.
|
01:58:38
|
|
There's different levels of what you might consider.
|
01:58:42
|
|
Of financial resources that we need for sustainability.
|
01:58:46
|
|
When there's going to be direct costs that relate to individuals that come and stay for utilities.
|
01:58:50
|
|
Just laundry like you would in a hotel room of what those actual costs somebody comes.
|
01:58:56
|
|
And sleeps in a bed, what is your cost to clean?
|
01:59:03
|
|
The arranger house or whatever.
|
01:59:06
|
|
Those would could be min.
|
01:59:09
|
|
The rest of the cost, we have a couple of full time employees that are out there on site managing.
|
01:59:11
|
|
Directing the affairs and trying to keep up with the maintenance of facilities and all such things. So couple of employees that we
|
01:59:19
|
|
have.
|
01:59:22
|
|
Is another level.
|
01:59:26
|
|
That we would have in sustainability and.
|
01:59:28
|
|
What it costs to run?
|
01:59:31
|
|
And then, as Joseph said, we've.
|
01:59:33
|
|
It's a facility that.
|
01:59:37
|
|
When we get, when we get the conveyance, it'll be conveyed to the county at no cost.
|
01:59:40
|
|
For the 232.
|
01:59:45
|
|
And then we have used.
|
01:59:47
|
|
Federal grant money and soon to be state grant money for the facilities.
|
01:59:49
|
|
So as far.
|
01:59:54
|
|
Maintaining HVAC systems and all of that. That is typically something like is mentioned about the fairgrounds.
|
01:59:59
|
|
When we're charging for those facilities, we typically don't build those into what we're going to.
|
02:00:06
|
|
Charge for using the fairgrounds.
|
02:00:12
|
|
And so that may be something you just want to consider, that's just part of our facilities, our ongoing obligation.
|
02:00:16
|
|
Facilities owned by the county and so it's not something.
|
02:00:23
|
|
You may want to necessarily consider recouping those charges for those costs.
|
02:00:26
|
|
Or so there's just different levels of sustainability.
|
02:00:32
|
|
Certainly with the salaries.
|
02:00:36
|
|
Joseph isn't wanting to, but I would put down it. It could be as much as half $1,000,000 a year.
|
02:00:41
|
|
Two for utilities and for salaries.
|
02:00:47
|
|
And having people come.
|
02:00:50
|
|
It could be less than.
|
02:00:52
|
|
That's just a.
|
02:00:55
|
|
Pops into my mind of what it might cost.
|
02:00:57
|
|
Supervisor client, did you have something?
|
02:01:01
|
|
I do.
|
02:01:03
|
|
And so I don't disagree with James.
|
02:01:04
|
|
Joseph too, it's right now we're just in the initial stages, so it's really, really hard.
|
02:01:07
|
|
To really lock down some good solid costs, I think.
|
02:01:13
|
|
And you correct me if I'm wrong, Joseph.
|
02:01:18
|
|
You know, I think as another year goes by, maybe two years, we'll have those, those figures pretty well nailed down. That's what I
|
02:01:20
|
|
think.
|
02:01:25
|
|
The other part of this that we do need to discuss, and I think Kathy would be willing to talk about it, Mr. Chair, if you'd like,
|
02:01:31
|
|
is the nonprofit side of this.
|
02:01:35
|
|
And one thing about this site I want everybody to understand too. This site has got a lot of attention.
|
02:01:40
|
|
An awful lot of attention from some very high up people.
|
02:01:48
|
|
And I just only see that getting bigger and better.
|
02:01:53
|
|
As This site is used and things go on, when we talk, when we're talking about the cost, you know in groups and a group of X amount
|
02:01:58
|
|
of people would get so much of percentage.
|
02:02:04
|
|
Fine and.
|
02:02:09
|
|
Oh, I don't agree with it, but it's those single individuals.
|
02:02:11
|
|
That's hard. I know a lot of veterans.
|
02:02:15
|
|
They can't go out there and pay $230 a night for for house for a man, his wife and kids. They just can't do that. And so by that
|
02:02:18
|
|
we're turning people away.
|
02:02:23
|
|
And that is absolutely 100.
|
02:02:29
|
|
Not what I want to see. Not. Not after we've done all this work to get to where we are today to.
|
02:02:33
|
|
To turn somebody away from that.
|
02:02:40
|
|
And so that.
|
02:02:43
|
|
There again, that's another one of my biggest reasons other than what I've already spoken of. But well back to the 501 C three I
|
02:02:44
|
|
think as as this goes on and more attention.
|
02:02:49
|
|
Is placed on this site.
|
02:02:55
|
|
This 501C3.
|
02:02:57
|
|
Is.
|
02:02:59
|
|
Be more and more.
|
02:03:01
|
|
And and I think that's going to help us offset.
|
02:03:03
|
|
For.
|
02:03:07
|
|
I can't tell you how much I you know. Like I said, time will tell. We need we need another Goodyear.
|
02:03:09
|
|
To really see what it's going to do. But you know, we had one fundraiser in.
|
02:03:14
|
|
And we collected, what, 30 some $1000 off of it just one night.
|
02:03:20
|
|
Few hours one night and so as this continues to build and then we start having fundraisers there on the site other whether it's
|
02:03:26
|
|
other elected somewhere else that want to throw money at it force and help promote it or whatever it is I I I foresee it just
|
02:03:32
|
|
building to offset.
|
02:03:38
|
|
A cost like what Mr. Menlo is talking about.
|
02:03:45
|
|
With that Mr. Chair, if you'd like to hear what Kathy has, I would. Yeah, Kathy, please. Nonprofit.
|
02:03:48
|
|
We've had a discussion with our nonprofit board members and where we haven't.
|
02:03:55
|
|
Formalized an agreement with the county. We've discussed it, but what the nonprofit board members have discussed is.
|
02:04:00
|
|
Annually, quarterly, however we would set it up to do it is to compensate the county for the maybe the number of veterans that do
|
02:04:07
|
|
come in so that we could pay that back. And that's kind of been part of their platform right now. And I should be able to tell you
|
02:04:13
|
|
right off the top of my head, I apologize how much we have our treasury, but I think we have a little over $50,000, but some of
|
02:04:19
|
|
that is committed also to furnishing the game room.
|
02:04:25
|
|
Out at the retreat which we already have gotten started on that thanks to our IT department guys. Anyway that's kind of where we
|
02:04:31
|
|
were at as far as like compensating the county for that because we realized that the that this is a big.
|
02:04:37
|
|
This is a big project for a county. It's not a typical project that a county takes on and we appreciate that. But that is our plan
|
02:04:44
|
|
going forward is to be able to pay the.
|
02:04:49
|
|
Semiannually or annually for some of the guests that stay there and like Joseph mentioned.
|
02:04:54
|
|
Was a couple of weeks ago. We had a group that came out and they've saved there before for justice one night. But they came for
|
02:05:00
|
|
their motorcycle group that operates out of both Arizona and Colorado. And they've been huge supporters for us. I mean, nationally
|
02:05:06
|
|
they've talked about us all over and we've gotten a lot of attention just from them.
|
02:05:11
|
|
When they were planning to come in for two weeks in March, I think they were coming in for two weeks.
|
02:05:17
|
|
And then they had a scouting trip that they'd come in for a few days if we took their two weeks and the number of guys that they
|
02:05:23
|
|
were going to bring in with them and then that would take two barracks in the house. We were talking almost $10,000 for them. And
|
02:05:28
|
|
this group bankrolls their whole this whole trip.
|
02:05:33
|
|
All the people have to do is to fly into.
|
02:05:38
|
|
The airport either in Colorado or in Arizona, and from that point forward, for a week or 10 days, this nonprofit pays for
|
02:05:41
|
|
everything.
|
02:05:44
|
|
So for them to have to pay they almost $10,000, they just told me flat out they weren't coming, that they can't afford that.
|
02:05:48
|
|
And these guys are all getting treated for PTSD, traumatic brain injury, that kind of thing, while they're on this, right? So
|
02:05:55
|
|
these are the kind of groups that we need, and we hated to see them say, I'm sorry, but we can't afford to come there because
|
02:05:59
|
|
that's not an answer.
|
02:06:04
|
|
We ever want to get. We also have tried the donation part of it because we didn't have a fee schedule and that has not worked out
|
02:06:08
|
|
very well because the donations have come in at $0.00.
|
02:06:13
|
|
And I think one donation was.
|
02:06:19
|
|
$10 or a night. So that part of it has not worked out very well for us without the fee schedule. So we need a fee schedule. I
|
02:06:22
|
|
truly believe that.
|
02:06:26
|
|
But then I also think we need.
|
02:06:30
|
|
Put in agreement with that nonprofit to be able to help the county out, however.
|
02:06:32
|
|
Mr. Medlove and Mr. O'Driscoll figure that would be, and Joseph, you know, I know that they're willing to do that. So that's
|
02:06:36
|
|
something out there as well to help out with the fees.
|
02:06:41
|
|
Because I would imagine this is going to cost a little bit to run that place annually.
|
02:06:47
|
|
Mr. Chairman.
|
02:06:52
|
|
Oh yes, Sir, Mr. Member.
|
02:06:54
|
|
Mr. Chairman, remember what? I agree wholeheartedly with Roger Klein that.
|
02:06:56
|
|
Our veterans they gives us, gives us freedoms, gives us, ensures us things that we have in this country.
|
02:07:04
|
|
That we are truly inde.
|
02:07:10
|
|
There are those that have given the ultimate SACR.
|
02:07:13
|
|
I don't want to put rain on the parade, but there is a consideration as a government of gifting.
|
02:07:17
|
|
The facility that there needs to.
|
02:07:25
|
|
Some sort of fee structure, so I apologize for bringing that up, but there.
|
02:07:28
|
|
Is it does need to be considered and so appreciate this opportunity. Just have this preliminary discussion.
|
02:07:34
|
|
And get.
|
02:07:40
|
|
As unless Jessica tells me that no, we don't have to worry about that in this case.
|
02:07:43
|
|
I I believe it's something that has to.
|
02:07:51
|
|
Thank you, Jessica. Please. Yes, Chairman, member, supervisors. So this sliding scale would also raise a concern as well, just to
|
02:07:55
|
|
set the precedent.
|
02:08:00
|
|
Mr. Dalton.
|
02:08:06
|
|
Contribute significant time researching whether or not there could be a comparable scale.
|
02:08:08
|
|
For the fairgrounds, and what he found is that it would be a violation of the gift clause.
|
02:08:14
|
|
So at that point it was my understanding that the fees.
|
02:08:20
|
|
Done away with, recently reinstated. However, if there was some sort of waiver of fees, then yes, it would be considered a
|
02:08:24
|
|
violation of the gift clause because.
|
02:08:30
|
|
We would be gifting something to these nonprofits in that they would not have to be paying paying the fees.
|
02:08:36
|
|
That other individuals were responsible for paying now if.
|
02:08:43
|
|
There was some sort of system set up where there were donations coming in and those donations were allocated towards the sliding
|
02:08:49
|
|
scale, then that might be a possibility, but if the sliding scale was?
|
02:08:56
|
|
Taking away from the governmental entity with not having anything returned to the governmental entity, the county, then yes, that
|
02:09:04
|
|
would be a violation of the gift clause.
|
02:09:09
|
|
Do you want my $0.02?
|
02:09:16
|
|
I appreciate you don't take me wrong, Jessica, I really do. But these folks have already given a lot. They've already paid that
|
02:09:19
|
|
price.
|
02:09:24
|
|
And that's the difference I see between one site and another.
|
02:09:29
|
|
We're not just having somebody come in and do a rock show or anything, we're having folks show up there that have issues.
|
02:09:33
|
|
That have a place to go and have the help they can bring with them or whatever to address issues like that.
|
02:09:40
|
|
Now.
|
02:09:47
|
|
If we have to look at some type of a fee to.
|
02:09:50
|
|
Much as I don't like it, address that gift clause because I honestly believe that's already been paid in full by these folks.
|
02:09:55
|
|
But if we have to do that, it needs to be something really, really low.
|
02:10:02
|
|
Because there is no.
|
02:10:06
|
|
We should ever turn somebody away from that site.
|
02:10:10
|
|
And unfortunately, it's all about money. I get it.
|
02:10:14
|
|
But if you think about it, we have a site that is in the process of being conveyed to us. It's worth how many millions of dollars.
|
02:10:19
|
|
We didn't build it. We didn't buy it. We repurposed it.
|
02:10:25
|
|
We've put some money into.
|
02:10:32
|
|
But most of the money has come.
|
02:10:34
|
|
State Representative Marshall or the ARPA Fund.
|
02:10:38
|
|
Things of that nature where it needed to go back to the people, which was a really good place to go with it, I agree.
|
02:10:42
|
|
As we go along, you know, I'm just going to go back to that, I think with the attention it has.
|
02:10:49
|
|
We are going to start generating more funds from the.
|
02:10:55
|
|
The donation part of it is hard because there are people that.
|
02:11:00
|
|
Give you anything, there's other people that will give you 300 bucks for a night. You know, that's that's the ups and downs of
|
02:11:05
|
|
that. I I get that for a group, you know, like that motorcycle group I think they gave us.
|
02:11:11
|
|
What, 1800 or something like that for one night? Or is that?
|
02:11:17
|
|
APS had a meeting there, so there's different things there that that it fluctuates. There's nothing.
|
02:11:22
|
|
Consistent.
|
02:11:28
|
|
But.
|
02:11:30
|
|
I I'm, I'm going to tell you guys I put a lot of time and effort into this, this deal and thank you all for the support, but there
|
02:11:32
|
|
is no way in hell we want to turn anybody away from that site for whatever reason it is the minute we do that.
|
02:11:39
|
|
We will lose support for that site, I'm telling you that straight up.
|
02:11:47
|
|
And when I talk to people from here to DC.
|
02:11:51
|
|
They're all about it.
|
02:11:55
|
|
That's helped the veterans. Let's do what we can yada yada yada. But if you think we could ever turn somebody away and not hear
|
02:11:57
|
|
about it, you might want to think again because.
|
02:12:02
|
|
It's not right that we would do that. So I appreciate where you're coming from on the gift pass and I know it's statute.
|
02:12:08
|
|