Bookmark list

* use Ctrl+F (Cmd+F on Mac) to search in document
Loading...
Unable to preview the file.

Transcript

Event transcript
Special meeting Tuesday, September 24th. 00:00:02
To order. 00:00:07
And we will have a pledge this morning. Michael, would you like to lead us in the pledge, please? 00:00:10
From the United States of America, for which it stands one nation under. 00:00:19
Control. 00:00:30
Good morning, everyone. 00:00:35
We're going to go right on to regular agenda item 2A and I guess I need a motion to recesses HeLa County Board of Supervisors to 00:00:38
convene as HeLa County Board of Equalization. So moved, Mr. Chair, and I'll second that. All in favor say aye, aye aye. OK. 00:00:47
Information, information, discussion, action to receive and accept Helen County Board of Equalization hearing officer. 00:00:57
UMM H Charles Johnson's decisions regarding appeals of the Assessor's property valuation for tax year 2025 that were heard on 00:01:09
September 20th, 2024. 00:01:18
Do we have anybody? 00:01:29
Discussing the same. Go ahead. 00:01:32
Thank you. So I'm the healer. County Board of Equalization Hearing Officer H Charles Johnson heard the appeals of the assessors 00:01:35
property evaluations the tax year 2025. On September 20th, 9 total parcels were heard. Seven of those parcels were issued and no 00:01:43
change decision. One parcel was decreased and one petition was not accepted in because it was due in the incorrect format. One 00:01:50
parcel is still under Mr. Johnson's review. He will provide a decision on the parcel within 10 business days at which time. 00:01:58
Bring that information back to the board. So per the contractual agreement between the hearing officer and the board of 00:02:05
equalization, the board of equalizations review of the hearing office is limited. The county receives the decision of the hearing 00:02:10
officer and shall uphold the decision of the hearing officer unless there is substantiated contradictory presented and I'm happy 00:02:16
to take any questions. 00:02:21
OK. I don't have any thinking, Sam. Yeah, I don't have any questions either. I'm I'm sure glad that that he's able to do this for 00:02:26
us. I can remember when the Board of Supervisors did that and as far as the formulas and stuff of appraising property, it was a 00:02:34
difficulty. Anyway. I'm glad that we have somebody professional in doing that at this point. So if there's no further questions or 00:02:41
comments, I'll call for motion. 00:02:48
Mr. Chair, I'll make the motion to receive and accept in the County Board of Equalization Hearing Officer H Charles Johnson's 00:02:56
decisions regarding appeals of the Assessor's property valuations for tax year 2025, and I'll second that. 00:03:04
And all in favor say aye, aye aye. 00:03:12
Passes unanimous. 00:03:18
Oh, and. 00:03:21
I was just a little late. Supervisor Klein and I are here today. Supervisor Christensen is not going to be here today, so. 00:03:22
It's just going to be the tours. 00:03:31
OK, And on regular agenda item 2B, we need to make a motion to change back to. So I'll make the motion to adjourn as healing 00:03:33
County Board of Equalization and Rick convene as a healer County Board of Supervisors. I'll second that having a motion second. 00:03:40
All in favor say aye, aye. 00:03:47
OK, and we don't need a decision to Table 2. 00:03:54
2D will be tabled because our presenter of that item was unable to be here today. 00:04:00
So we're moving on to regular agenda item to see information discussion regarding potential capital funding options and funding 00:04:08
process information for Hilo County's infrastructure and capital improvement project. Mark reader and. 00:04:18
Good morning. Good morning. We'll get you started with these first couple slides and then we'll turn it over to Mark Reader, who 00:04:29
will provide you with a little bit more information. 00:04:35
Mark has given you hopefully print out of this PowerPoint presentation. Since the projector is not working today, we want to make 00:04:43
sure that you've got that. 00:04:47
We were expecting to be like an hour and a half later in the agenda. 00:04:57
OK. 00:05:07
Oh fantastic. 00:05:17
So after your cover, you've got. 00:05:19
County leadership and then. 00:05:23
On what is page three, you have a list of the next five years estimated high priority capital projects for public works. So 00:05:28
management asked Homero and his team to put together their list of what they think it's going to take to get us to 2030 coming out 00:05:36
of the public works department. 00:05:45
As far as roads and other types of projects. 00:05:54
And in addition to putting together a list of projects, we asked Tomero and his team on this page, and then Joseph and his team on 00:05:59
the next in collaboration with Michael and James. 00:06:06
To evaluate what those funding sources might be for these, as you can see on Romero's list here, some of these funding sources 00:06:14
include Arizona Department of Transportation. 00:06:20
DF FM, which is the Department of Fire and Forestry Management. There are some FEMA resources. There are a few instances where 00:06:27
we'll be partnering with the central Arizona governments and CAG. 00:06:34
And there are some highway safety improvement funds, some Tonto National Forest. 00:06:43
And a couple other sources. So the total of these projects over the next. 00:06:51
Five years is estimated to be $21.7 million if they're at the bottom of Page 3. 00:07:00
Currently public works and management and finance are estimating 4.1 million. Of that 21 million will be sourced from public works 00:07:07
and the other 17,000,016.9 will come from other from these other funding sources that are listed down the right hand side. 00:07:18
So we're just, we're sharing this information with you because right you're. 00:07:29
Generally conservative and like to know that we're planning well in advance and if you don't like big financial surprises, so we 00:07:34
wanted to make sure you have this information today. 00:07:39
So this is projecting out from now until 2030 for public works. 00:07:45
And as you can see, the 4.1 million would be about what Public Works expects to extend and the the other 17 would be coming from 00:07:51
other sources as you flip to the next page. 00:07:58
Our friends and our friends and facilities have put together their list of what it's going to take to get us from now to 2030. 00:08:06
Their total project. 00:08:17
Are about 14.6 million. 00:08:20
Of which they're expecting about 10.3 to counter from the general fund. 00:08:23
And about 4.2 to come from other funding sources, which includes a court project for the security cameras at 30,000 The Road Shop, 00:08:28
Wash Bay. 00:08:37
Don't try to say that fast, which would be splitting half and half between general fund and public works and then looking at 00:08:46
utilizing some of the LATC funds for the Globe courthouse elevator improvements. 00:08:54
The complex roof replacement. The HVAC replacement. 00:09:03
And a couple other projects like that, including the Monroe St. 00:09:10
Adjacent projects, which would be our our parking lots and things like that, as well as parking lot resurfacing. 00:09:17
This also shows where other funding project costs are coming in from other sources, including the Pleasant Valley Veterans Retreat 00:09:26
Center, which has $3,000,000 in state grant funds and 333,000 in a congressional earmark. 00:09:35
So the total of those, again the total projected project costs are 14.6 million with general fund carrying 10.3 million of that 00:09:47
cost and other funding sources of about 4.2. 00:09:54
There are still additional LATCF funds available. This list includes potentially using about 3.9 of those, which would still leave 00:10:03
about 1.1 of LATCF funds. 00:10:12
So that gives you an idea of where facilities is. You previously saw an idea of where public works is. So as we go to the next 00:10:22
slide. 00:10:27
There we go. 00:10:33
We have a couple of pie charts here for you. 00:10:35
This shows the sources for potential funding. So the pie chart on the left hand side is our public works projects. 00:10:41
Which show the different sources for where those are. And you saw the list on the previous page. The right hand side shows the 00:10:53
sources for the facilities projects. And we're here today to bring you an idea. And it's just an idea. This is a work session 00:11:01
item. This is not an action item today. This brings you the idea. 00:11:09
That we could consider going for another pledged revenue bond. 00:11:18
Which would add the capacity for the county to consider some long term projects that would allow us to consider constructing a new 00:11:24
administration building and including this courthouse renovation. 00:11:33
So Mark Reeder from Steeple is here. Mark has been our partner on the last two. 00:11:43
Last two bond issues that we did, one for PSPRS and one for the Tommy Klein Martin building and the animal shelter. And Mark is 00:11:51
going to talk to us about what options are available for Arizona counties and what options other counties have done, what options 00:11:58
are available to us. And some of these have a lot more detail in them than we'll be presenting today. This is information for you 00:12:05
to have. 00:12:12
So that. 00:12:20
If you decide to encourage us to move forward and get more information, you'll have as much information as we have right now. So I 00:12:22
will hand this over to Mark. Hopefully the lag on that slows down and if you have any questions, we're both here for you. 00:12:29
Good morning again, Mark. Good morning. 00:12:40
Oh, yes, the board. Good. Thanks for having me up again. Is Mr. Christensen on the phone or No, He's not unavailable. Oh, he's not 00:12:43
available. OK. All right. 00:12:47
Before I get started, did you have any other questions for Marin on your five year kind of CIP? 00:12:51
Thought that was very well done and good job. As a county you've been largely a pay as you go capital county. All in all over the 00:12:58
years you all work really hard to get as many grant, as many grants as you can. That was in the grid. So I thought the five year 00:13:05
what we call high priority CIP plan was very well done. So I just wanted to before I get started, did you have any questions on 00:13:12
the material that maybe Mayor? 00:13:19
Supervisor client. 00:13:29
Mark, I don't think so. 00:13:31
I think it's very well put together. You know, looking at all the projects that cost projected costs money and all that. No, I 00:13:34
think, I think it's very well put together. 00:13:39
OK, very good. OK, so I'm going to go ahead and talk about this, this idea of. 00:13:46
Maybe down the road would the county be interested in a long term bond financing to finance some pretty major potential 00:13:52
improvements to the county? As I understand it, one is potentially a new administrative complex and Marin and you all are probably 00:13:59
more familiar at it than me. 00:14:05
And. 00:14:13
Repositioning some of the land up here in a new admin or new offices for a large part of the county, OK. And that's my 00:14:15
understanding that this building needs some pretty significant improvements. 00:14:21
And so we are seeing a number of counties having to address their very old facilities. I've got a case study I'll share with you 00:14:28
in a moment for Yuma County. You've all been to Yuma, you've all been downtown and they're literally in 100 year old building. 00:14:36
So they made the decision to spend over 60 million for a new administrative facility. 00:14:45
So we're seeing canals doing a bunch of new improvements, so we are seeing our counties. 00:14:50
You know. 00:14:55
Energy costs are way up. There's some energy efficiency going on that could help you with some savings and all that. So. 00:14:57
Not uncommon to see our counties have to consider a bond you know it's darn this inflation is just really been hard on us haven't. 00:15:05
I mean, we've really seen stuff double. 00:15:13
And especially in the rural areas now you're not quite so rural, but you're still somewhat rural. And when we're opening bits now, 00:15:17
we're kind of falling off our chairs. 00:15:21
Now it's going to take you all a while to get all of your engineering and all your architectural and all of your. 00:15:27
Your master planning documents done. So let's hope over the next year or so we start to see some of that cost rate go down. 00:15:33
OK, umm. 00:15:42
So in talking to Marin and to James a little bit in terms of our presentation. 00:15:42
We started off with, well, what projects might you bond for? We shared that with you. And while you don't really have any cost 00:15:49
estimates at the moment, maybe a little bit what what are you thinking? 00:15:56
So just for starters, and bear with us here because these numbers are definitely going to change if you decide to move forward. 00:16:03
Down below, you can see we're assuming about a $30 million project here between the new administrative facility and the reposition 00:16:10
of your campus potentially and some additional improvements in this building. 00:16:17
Outside what's being budgeted? 00:16:24
All good. So the county's doing a good job with your general fund, you're doing a good job with your cash. And we have to manage 00:16:26
our cash. We have to be, we have to have our cushions, right. But more than likely the county will be able to utilize some cash to 00:16:33
reduce your borrowing if this project moves forward. So we started with 30. 00:16:40
And we assumed a new admin somewhere around 25 in the courthouse renovation somewhere around 5 million. So let's go with 30 00:16:48
million for the moment. OK, OK. That's that's kind of our starting point. 00:16:55
I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this. We've spent time on this before. Counties have a lot of options when they want to 00:17:04
pursue their capital improvement plan. 00:17:08
And the most common option is what we've done for you before and that is the revenue bonds that Mary mentioned, very efficient 00:17:13
ways in which the county would pledge revenues. You're a AA minus county. If you remember, we'll try to get you in that AA 00:17:21
category. You're a strong county. You're very respected in the marketplace. So we would probably. 00:17:29
And All in all, likely go go forward like we have in the past with this revenue bond. 00:17:37
And then all the other options up on top. 00:17:43
All the infrastructure projects our counties do, you can see our PS PRS down down there as well. 00:17:46
On the left hand side, all the options up on the top under state law and having worked with your county for many, many years, I 00:17:53
know that you all take issue and death very seriously and you're very careful and you're very measured. So I don't think you want 00:18:00
to have a property tax. We're not suggesting that that's allowable under the law. And the rest of them are just other options out 00:18:07
there. So we're going to focus on the revenue bond unless you tell us otherwise. 00:18:14
That's more than likely the direction we're probably going to go. 00:18:22
OK. So we won't spend a lot of time on that? 00:18:25
This is your outstanding debt we've had the privilege of working with you all here over the years and I think what I'm going to do 00:18:29
is go to this pie chart that we did was really good I. 00:18:33
This thing's a little sensitive, isn't it? OK. 00:18:40
So you've got me back up here a little bit, sorry. 00:18:43
You have about 25,000,000 in debt. 00:18:47
Bottom right hand corner. 00:18:51
Page. 00:18:53
Page 8. This is a summary of all your debt. 00:18:58
On the left hand side is our copper administration building down below that's coming off the books this year. You had your final 00:19:02
payment is done OK. 00:19:07
We then did. In 2019 we did. 00:19:12
A bond issue for. 00:19:18
An animal shelter and TCM complex. I forgot what? Oh, that's that. Tommy Martin with Tommy Martin Thomas. Thank you. 00:19:20
OK. So that was about 8.7 million for capital improvements and then in 2019 we get a refunding, saved you a bunch of money. 00:19:28
As you can see. And then in 2020 we get a $16.8 million pension bond, remember. 00:19:42
So good move on that. 00:19:50
We got 2 to 3% money if you remember to refinance, 7.2% money. 00:19:53
And we saved the county over 14,000,000, what they call expected savings. 00:19:58
We wired 18,000,000 to PSPRS. 00:20:04
In 2020, we're in 2024 now pushing 2025 and that money's been working pretty strong because the markets have been up. 00:20:08
So you won on low interest rates and so far we've won with performance at PSPR, so all good there. 00:20:17
That was a. 00:20:27
I know that you all took that very seriously. We ended up doing it and All in all, I think everybody's happy with our pension 00:20:28
bond. So I guess my point on this was a. 00:20:32
Your public pension is the largest component of your balance. 00:20:39
And as you know, public pensions have what? 00:20:44
The unfunded liabilities of public pensions, including ASRS, are something that we all have to deal with on a budgetary basis, but 00:20:47
they're large unfunded liabilities. 00:20:52
So we tried to address yours with the pension bond and so far so good. 00:20:57
OK. So that's give you a reminder on the history. This is the various debt service payments. You're about 2.3 million a year, 00:21:01
pretty much level on all of those debt obligations. 00:21:07
So as a percent of your budget, that's very reasonable. OK, Your county's been very careful and very measured with regard to 00:21:14
issuing bonds over the years. So let's go 2.3652 point 3,000,000 if you want around. 00:21:22
And if I look in the interest rate column, I really like 1 and 2% money. I even like that .505 to 2.3 on a pension bond, if you 00:21:30
remember. 00:21:36
OK. The 10 year treasury was less than 1% and it hit 4 1/2 this year as you know. 00:21:42
So we took advantage of our opportunity on that. So I like, I like all this so far. 00:21:50
And then this is a nice little pie chart and what I just went over for you. 00:21:55
On your debt, On your debt load. 00:22:02
At 2.3 million per year, OK. These are pledged revenues. If you remember all counties, how all counties do it, we've simplified 00:22:04
this and turned it into a very strong credit for our Arizona counties and you had about 16,000,000 there in 2324, total revenues, 00:22:11
pledged revenues. 00:22:18
My apologies here, darn it. 00:22:26
So. 00:22:29
If we do a bond issue in the future, of course this is the pledged revenues, which is primarily your county general fund. 00:22:32
You had a Goodyear about 4.9 million in 2223. Looks like 2324 estimated be about 4.6 million, so not too far off. 00:22:39
Our state shared revenues are pretty consistent, pretty strong at about nine and a half million a year. 00:22:50
And as you know, we got to deduct our all techs and our access, right? 00:22:55
That's your portion and they net that out before it comes back to the county. 00:23:00
So that's a net, what we call a net state shared pledgeable revenue. Our vehicle license taxes remain strong. I just bought a new 00:23:05
vehicle and I about fell off my chair when I saw what the BLT was. We've all been there. 00:23:12
But a great revenue stream for our cities and our counties. 00:23:20
OK Pelt, pretty strong, so good job there. Umm. 00:23:23
2324 looks like you're up a half a million. 00:23:28
So we'll take it. And then you conservatively budget for 2425. So let's go 16,000,000 on pledged revenues, strong number. 00:23:32
And then let's get down to the bottom line. As we wrap up here, interest rates are, as you know, dropping. 00:23:40
So here's here's the there's the spike in interest rates over the last couple of years driven by what inflation, right, that we're 00:23:47
all we're all struggling with. And the Fed, as you know, has been tapping the brakes and they tapped them last week at 50 basis 00:23:54
points. So we're hoping going into 25 and the fourth quarter of 24, we're starting to see rates kind of go back down. Mortgage 00:24:01
rates are dropping a little bit, right? 00:24:08
Very much needed. 00:24:16
And so I guess on this little spreadsheet here is to give you an idea, if you look in this column right here where it says AAA 00:24:19
rated. 00:24:23
Tax exempt bonds, 2:30 to 352. 00:24:31
We did, we did boss one year boss from Healer County. We'll start with 2:30 to 325. You're not a AAA yet, so you have price a 00:24:35
little higher than that. So I'm thinking if you were in the market today, we probably have you know, 35375 line. 00:24:43
Not bad, we like 2% money. We got a little spoiled. 00:24:51
Right. We had 2 1/2 percent mortgage money. Remember I got 2 7/8, so I was lucky. So I don't know that we're ever going back to 00:24:57
those, but I would say three and a half, 375. 00:25:04
4% money is pretty good money. 00:25:12
So we ran some numbers here in a moment at 4 1/2. I think it is. So we're going to be, we have to be conservative. 00:25:14
OK. I'm moving along here and then I'll pause in a moment. OK, a lot of numbers here, but here's basically what what Meredith 00:25:23
asked us to do. 00:25:27
If we could afford a $2,000,000 long term payment out of our budget. 00:25:35
OK, reasonable. 00:25:41
Out of your general fund budget for the next 20 years and they're they're comfortable with that number at the moment. 00:25:44
And we amortize the bonds over 20 years and we use 4 1/2%. Marin asked me how much do we raise? So it's really simple math. 00:25:50
There's a 2 million in column 6. 00:25:56
And I solved it at 4 1/2 percent we get you 26,000,000. 00:26:04
OK. 00:26:09
That's close to the numbers that we talked about. I've got 30 million for the two projects. And then we said, well, let's just 00:26:12
share with the board. 00:26:16
Again, we know. We know you're careful. 00:26:21
If you want to go out 25 years, these buildings last. As you all know, they last a long time. 00:26:24
And maybe one of the pros of debt is you amortize it over a longer period of time to let future generations help pay for some of 00:26:30
the debt service. 00:26:35
That's the advantage of going longer. That's kind of a policy decision by the board. 00:26:40
But if we go out five more years, we'll get you another $3,000,000 Simple now. 00:26:46
So call that pushing 30. 00:26:51
If we wanted to go a little longer on our amortization. 00:26:54
OK. Let's wrap up and then we'll have some questions of the Board. Here's our Yuma project in the event itself, where you may have 00:27:00
heard about it from your colleagues on the Board. 00:27:06
There's their building. It's downtown. They actually purchased a building and tore it down. 00:27:12
Location, location, location, right? And they wanted to have it downtown. 00:27:19
And they're right in the middle of it. They're halfway done as they're going vertical. 00:27:23
And that budget somewhere around 60 million and we got the detail in there for you to look and I think all and everybody's pretty 00:27:29
happy with it and I think it's All in all coming on or around budget. 00:27:35
With no major change orders that I'm aware of. 00:27:42
$60 million administrative facility in downtown. 00:27:46
OK. Hope that's helpful to you. 00:27:50
Next Steps Chatted with with Marin and James and the team. 00:27:53
About next steps, of course, would be to hire your construction professionals and your architects. 00:27:59
And. 00:28:07
Yuma County did this where you, they hired an owner's representative and Mr. Humphrey, I know you're a contractor. You, you know 00:28:09
this way better than I do. 00:28:13
But hire a consider hiring a construction Rep or what they call an owners Rep. 00:28:18
There's a couple of them out there. 00:28:25
Bring them in the room to help you get your arms around your projects. They know construction costs, they know cost per square 00:28:27
feet, and they can help. Then if you want help, retain an architect. 00:28:33
I have a team of people here and then once an architect is on board. 00:28:40
And you start the design process by meeting with all appropriate county staff and elected officials. 00:28:44
What do you want? I'm talking about the new building, for example. How do we want to design it? How many square feet do we need in 00:28:51
the treasurer's office? All of those things go into it. 00:28:56
And then start to put together the design. And then based on the design, start to put together the cost testimonies. 00:29:02
Now that's probably going to take you a year. 00:29:10
Depending upon how fast you want to move it. 00:29:13
And then once the design is done and then you figure out your construction procurement a couple different ways on that. 00:29:18
See them at risk with a guaranteed match price or you do a traditional design bid build. Again, that's where an owners Rep and an 00:29:26
architect can be helpful in the bidding market. What is in the best interest of the county? 00:29:32
So that's that's down the road for you, but for you to be thinking about. 00:29:40
So that's, I know staff's been in touch with a few professional firms in that regard. 00:29:44
Continue to communicate with our Board of Supervisors. 00:29:51
Keeping everybody up to date on the cost estimates and the design process. 00:29:55
And then if you want to proceed and you want to do a bond, we'll probably talking first quarter of 26, second quarter of 26. 00:30:01
Or faster, depending upon, again, how fast the county wants to move. 00:30:12
And then construction will commence shortly after the sale of bonds and when you award some form of a construction contract. 00:30:16
So with that, that concludes my presentation. I hope that was helpful to the board and. 00:30:24
All glad to answer any questions. 00:30:29
Thank you very much for the presentation, and thank you very much for all that you've done for us in the past in helping us get to 00:30:33
where we are today. Supervisor Klein. 00:30:39
Mark, thank you. 00:30:46
Good, good information, all of it. I mean, there's, there's a lot to think about on this. It really is. And, and you've worked 00:30:50
with this enough to know that we are pretty conservative when it comes to money and everything else. But so that's, that's going 00:30:56
to be the big question. We're living in a world right now with a lot of uncertainties until after probably the first of the year 00:31:02
and, and so. 00:31:08
You know, I there, there is a lot to discuss and there's a lot to discuss with the group and, and everything as far as that goes. 00:31:14
We do have a lot of needs, legitimate needs. It's just for me personally, how do I balance that with my, our taxpayers? You know, 00:31:21
that's where that's where I'm at. So, but this is really good and it's something I want to keep looking at and talk about some 00:31:28
more. 00:31:34
Yeah, I, like I said, I, I appreciate all you've done. I I like looking forward and, and it and it and I'm the kind of guy rather 00:31:45
than put a Band-Aid on it, let's, let's fix it because it's just going to get more expensive down the road if we put a Band-Aid on 00:31:52
it. A new facility. I didn't know anything about a new facility or maybe I just didn't pay any attention when that came up because 00:31:59
I, I think we have some good facilities. 00:32:07
A lot of a lot of work. But anyway, yeah, I, I, you know, like you say, without raising taxes, this is a good way to go if, if we 00:32:14
can get money reasonable enough, rather than to break the Piggy Bank, it's better if you can get low interest money and spread it 00:32:23
over a period of time. So, you know, 2 million, two million a year. 00:32:31
Gets you 30 million. Like I say, a stitch in time saves 9. 00:32:40
So with construction costs, I, I don't see them going down. Everybody says, and they've gone down a little bit, but that's like 00:32:44
gas prices. Once they get it up there, you're not going to see dollar fifty gas. I don't think so. But anyway, I, I thank you very 00:32:52
much for taking the time today. I apologize that Mister Menlo's not here and Mr. Christensen's not here. I'm sure on a work 00:32:59
session there would be probably a lot more comments and maybe more questions. 00:33:06
Come up. But I know you're available and you've helped us a lot. And, and like I say, I appreciate you being here today and, and 00:33:14
the presentation and, and the way this is laid out. It's, it's very nice and, and easy to understand of, of where we've been and 00:33:21
where we would be if we choose to go forward with a lot of these projects that we, that we need to get done because we've got, 00:33:29
we've got more projects than, than we have. 00:33:36
Finance money right now and so. 00:33:44
It's a good way to go. And thank you for your presentation. Thank you for the compliments. I appreciate that. I hope to see you at 00:33:47
CSA soon. 00:33:50
And then I had a question in terms of going back to Phoenix. I got to go to the airport. Should I go up through pumpkin center 00:33:54
Roosevelt or should I go back around Kearney? And I would go around the lake If I yeah, it it's it's a lot better view, lot better 00:34:02
Rd. You know, because the road from from here to Jakes corner is a brand new road. You can set cruise control snakes road. And 00:34:09
then you hit the the B line, the 87 and it's a a straight shot down to Phoenix. The other one is. 00:34:17
Haley and Windy and kind of crazy. No sheriff, son. Don't worry about any sheriff. 00:34:25
I just have called Supervisor Klein if you. 00:34:30
Drive careful, Mark. 00:34:41
Keep in touch and Mary did a great job on this. She told me to simplify it, so yeah. 00:34:44
Thank you so much. 00:34:50
And we'll see you guys soon. I got some questions for you, Mr. Chair, if I may. Yes, please do. 00:34:52
So. 00:35:02
You know, we've had a lot of conversations on different things and us as a county, we're just very spread out building wise. And 00:35:04
so you know this you're looking at this and looking at some options that is a way of consolidating some things. Has there been any 00:35:12
discussion say like if we took out the the building at Apache Blvd. 00:35:20
The building down here, some other ones, how much money would that save us a year and just maintenance. So that's something that 00:35:29
we are going to. 00:35:34
Depending on your perspective, we're hoping to bring forward a proposal to work with an architect to come up with that calculation 00:35:40
for you. We know at the very least it would save us the cost of the roof and the HVAC on the Central Heights project, which is 00:35:47
over two and a half, $1,000,000. That's a year of debt service right there. And part of what we run into, as I'm sure you remember 00:35:55
from previous discussions is. 00:36:02
We have our expenditure limit. 00:36:10
And the state tells us we can't spend our own money. You have money in the bank that you can't use without facing a penalty from 00:36:13
the state. Whereas when you leverage debt service, the debt service is removed from that calculation. 00:36:21
So this would, if you chose to move forward with project financing, that would free up funding to use throughout the year on 00:36:30
projects without having to pay the state a penalty, which is a challenge. Alan McGuire was at the last conference we were at. I 00:36:37
don't know if you remember him from some of your CSA projects, but Alan was on the original group that built that expenditure 00:36:43
limit. 00:36:50
And he's working with several counties to try to get it fixed. 00:36:58
Because it is problematic. It's especially problematic for all the counties because the opioid settlement money that I'm sure 00:37:02
you're familiar with from the one Arizona settlement is not excludable from your expenditure limit. So. 00:37:10
Several counties are facing an opportunity. 00:37:21
Where they're going to be choosing between whether they spend their opioid settlement monies to achieve those necessary outcomes 00:37:26
or if they have to go out. And it's called a certificate of participation. It's a short term bond for 366 days where you borrow 00:37:35
the money that you need to stay under your expenditure limit and then pay it back the first day of the following year. 00:37:44
And I know that that gives you both. Well all three of you have Supervisor Christensen was here. It gives you all. 00:37:54
The beginnings of an ulcer because you hate the idea of borrowing money just to play games with numbers. So we're trying to 00:38:01
proactively think of ways that we can help you serve the constituents better, help you be more energy efficient if possible, and 00:38:09
still stay within that expenditure limit without having to do anything goofy. 00:38:17
That I'm right, and even as I'm saying it sounds goofy, like I should be here with a shovel. 00:38:27
Just piling it on because it sounds like nonsense when I say it and we're in a ranching area, so there's plenty of that already, 00:38:32
right? But the cost savings would that would require some engineering to evaluate for us to get back to your original question, 00:38:40
the engineering firms that we've just talked to to find out if they offer those kinds of services. 00:38:49
It looks like what they would start with. 00:38:59
They would take our existing square footage, the departments that are housed in those square feet, and how the space both serves 00:39:02
the public and internal departments, and they would compute. 00:39:09
Like a working average. So let's say that Supervisor Humphries offices a certain size and Supervisor Klein's office is a certain 00:39:17
size and Supervisor Christensen's office is a certain size. They would make sure that that size and efficiency stayed the same in 00:39:25
the new facility. And then they would use that data across all the healing county departments to make sure that. 00:39:33
There could be the same level of service that there would be room for growth and that if you choose. 00:39:42
To consider new construction. 00:39:49
That we would reduce duplicate spaces. So like let's say right now across all of the HeLa County offices and Globe, we have 10 00:39:53
different kitchens and lunch rooms. Well, if we were all in one building, we wouldn't need 10 different kitchens, but you wouldn't 00:40:00
need 30 microwaves or what have you. So they would propose consolidating to save funds that way, right, So that you don't have 00:40:07
duplicate uses of space. 00:40:15
They would also propose things to save money, like going with a high energy efficiency building so that the building itself would 00:40:22
just cost less in your monthly APS bill and things like that. But these are pieces that we would need your permission at a regular 00:40:30
meeting to go forward and even ask those questions officially, right? Not just us, like asking while we're networking with people, 00:40:37
like what the options are. 00:40:45
But to actually have a formal consultation where an organization would come in and talk to us and they wouldn't try to fit us. I 00:40:52
thought the presentation was was still up. They wouldn't try to fit us into like a, a scaled version of Yuma County. They would do 00:40:59
what what Gila County needs and what Gila County's people need to ensure that our constituents have access to everything they 00:41:06
need. 00:41:13
And the way that. 00:41:21
We asked Stifel to put this together would include. 00:41:23
The facilities that we own being updated and being. 00:41:29
Sort of retrofitted to do what we need to do. So like the elevator out here. 00:41:34
And the roof and things like that would still get done, right? We wouldn't wouldn't continue to forestall preventative maintenance 00:41:40
and you know, and sort of moving forward to make sure that that we don't run into what we're in right now, right when you have 00:41:47
sticker shock when facilities brought you the list of projects that needed done because they had been put off by previous 00:41:53
administration. 00:41:59
We are going to be living with the consequences of previous administrations choices for a while. 00:42:07
And unfortunately, they're not here for us to throw wet noodles at. So those of us who are here are, are going to, you know, face 00:42:14
the, the firing squad for that. And, and that's OK. That's a responsibility that we all accept. And, and we're willing to to face 00:42:22
that difficulty in order to make sure that going forward, we don't get back in this situation. 00:42:31
So, Mr. Chair, for me, Marin, we have like the property on 260 in Payson. 00:42:40
You know, my opinion is it's worth quite a bit of money that we're never going to use ourselves. I don't see us ever using that. 00:42:47
The proper building down here, the modulars, they have about outlived their lifetimes, you know, and so we have these things 00:42:54
sitting out there. So, so, so let's take like the property on 260 if we all came to terms and we wanted to go ahead and pursue 00:43:00
selling that property. 00:43:06
Then that would just be put into an account that would help us pay like towards this $2,000,000, let's just say a year or 00:43:12
something like that. Or that would be up to the board. And that is something that if you wanted the engineers to evaluate what 00:43:21
that could do, they could build that into one of their or several of their. 00:43:29
Approaches, right? Because they're not just going to bring you one plan and be like here, this is it. Do it. They're going to 00:43:39
bring you choices. 00:43:42
So that you have the information that you need with the professional preparation without worrying whether all the questions have 00:43:46
been asked, right? Because you'll have that opportunity to ask those questions and will be. 00:43:54
Assuming you, you choose to move forward will be engaging the professionals. So you're not counting on us as staff to to ask 00:44:02
questions that maybe we're not astute enough to to ask or we're not because we're not in the business of doing that. We don't know 00:44:09
to ask ahead of time. 00:44:15
No, but you're gonna get the questions to ask on the dollars though. Absolutely. So questions on the dollars, I'm fine answering. 00:44:23
It's, it's the questions on how do we make the buildings more efficient and how do we serve our people that I struggle with. 00:44:30
And we were dealt the hand we have, you know, when we came on board, we were dealt with a lot of a lot of stuff that needed fixed. 00:44:40
And, you know, I don't know what Supervisor Humphrey thinks, but when I look back at it, we've come a long way already. We've done 00:44:46
a lot, you know, and so. 00:44:52
It's just to me, I wish I had that crystal ball that you could look in the future because you know, yeah, you could go. We could 00:45:00
go on and and fix just about everything that needed fixed, but. 00:45:05
I'm still concerned. 00:45:11
About our constituents in Hilah County and tax bases and things like that. You know, it's, it's like. 00:45:14
Do we want to drive something out to work at the bottom does fall out like back in 08 or something like that? Then what do we do? 00:45:22
Can we handle it with what we got without raising the taxes still and doing things like that? Oh, those are the kind of questions 00:45:27
that I have. 00:45:32
The other thing I think it really. 00:45:38
Really, really needs to be hammered down. 00:45:41
Just exactly what do we need? 00:45:46
We can all sit around and create a wish list, that's easy. But what is it? Do we absolutely need to function as a county? And so 00:45:49
so just just so you. 00:45:55
Can sleep tonight. 00:46:03
When I was preparing the 2025 budget, I did project out. 00:46:06
The next. 00:46:11
This is going to sound ridiculous to you both. I projected out the next 30 years and if we were to bond for a significant project, 00:46:13
what that would do, what our ongoing ability to invest in construction would be like so we could make sure that we kept our 00:46:20
preventative maintenance going. 00:46:26
What it would do to our cash flow reserves, right, Because you have the reserve but you want to keep it, you don't want us to 00:46:33
spend it. 00:46:37
This $2,000,000. 00:46:42
In the imaginary presentation that's not there anymore, the $2,000,000 was the number that I came up with based on that was that 00:46:45
that's how much more debt service we can fit in over the next 30 years without adversely affecting your cash balance, which is 16 00:46:52
and a half, $1,000,000 right now. And that's, that's an accomplishment of this board to, to keep that on the balance sheet and not 00:46:59
mess with it. 00:47:06
And that $2,000,000 a year would also ensure. 00:47:14
That we weren't running into the expenditure limit. 00:47:17
So it. 00:47:23
It seemed like overkill while I was preparing the budget, but I keep seeing these growing lists of capital projects and these 00:47:25
lists of incomplete preventative maintenance from from the past eight, 1012 years. And I wanted to make sure that the budget you 00:47:33
adopted earlier this summer wasn't going to put you in a situation that we couldn't recover from. 00:47:41
If the bottom were to fall out. 00:47:50
As you stipulated, it would affect our excise tax and it would affect our state share revenue most, right, because those are your 00:47:52
sales taxes. 00:47:57
That's part of why we built PILT into the pledged revenue bonds when we first went out for PSPRS and Potomac Klein Martin building 00:48:04
and the animal shelter. 00:48:09
Because we wanted to make sure that if something were to happen to the economy, that our constituents, your constituents would not 00:48:16
be facing a tax increase because we can't increase taxes to pay pledged revenue bonds. That's the beauty of a pledged revenue 00:48:23
bond. If you were to choose a general obligation bond, that would require us going to the constituents and saying, hey, we're 00:48:31
going to potentially raise taxes in the future. We would have to put. 00:48:38
On the ballot and it would have to pass for the majority vote from the constituents. That's a perfectly valid option if you would 00:48:46
like to do that. Sledge Revenue is safer for your constituents. It is safer for. 00:48:54
The entire county and it's safer for the investors, right, because they can see, we report every year, they can see that our 00:49:03
revenue was holding up. So when Mark referred to the $16,000,000 earlier and that's $16,000,000 we have coming in, that's 00:49:10
currently paying 2.1 million on the PSPRS bond, the copper building which she said the last payments this year and the Tommy Klein 00:49:18
Martin and animal shelter. 00:49:25
So you've got 16 point, I think it's 16.8, it's 16,000,000 servicing 2 million. So you've got another 14 million in capacity that 00:49:33
you could use. Obviously, we wouldn't want to do that. You don't want to have $16,000,000 in annual debt service. That's crazy. 00:49:42
The other thing that we didn't include in this presentation because we're just not at that point when you choose to go for a bond. 00:49:53
You're required by federal law to expend the money within three years. You're required by federal law to be at least 65% of the 00:50:02
way through the project within the 1st 18 months. 00:50:07
So you have to scale whatever you're borrowing to be whatever you can achieve in that length of time. 00:50:13
Which also drives the dollar amount, right? So it's what you can do in debt service and what you can conceivably get done in a 00:50:19
three-year time frame. If you don't do it within three years, you start paying penalties on the money you borrowed. 00:50:27
So it's sort of difficult to simultaneously scale those things while being aware of, you know, the potential that the economy 00:50:35
might hiccup. But we've tried to bring all those into consideration before we even brought this to you for even as a talking point 00:50:44
today. And, and again, this is a work session item. This is purely information. 00:50:52
We're not asking you to make a decision today. 00:51:01
Should you choose to advise staff to go forward, all we would be doing right off the bat would be potentially bringing you the 00:51:05
state contract to approve us working with Stifel. 00:51:12
And potentially a state contract to approve working with an architect and potentially an owner's representative. And even if I 00:51:21
even if you told me to do it today, we couldn't even have that to you until the second meeting in October. 00:51:29
So I. 00:51:40
I apologize, Supervisor Humphrey, that this conversation didn't get had before. I must have misunderstood something that I had 00:51:41
heard that that we had. 00:51:46
Had management discussions with each of the supervisors about the potential of a new building. I apologize for that. I will make 00:51:53
sure that I. 00:51:57
Follow up better on on those kinds of discussions and not trust that I wrote it down right in a meeting. 00:52:03
The the potential location. 00:52:11
Would require quite a bit of groundwork, but it would be this back corner of the property over here is what would potentially be 00:52:14
the new footprint for that. 00:52:19
And it's it would be a significant undertaking, but looking forward five years in the future, we wanted to make sure that that we 00:52:25
were empowering you to have these conversations and thoughts now so that you have time to think about it and time to evaluate what 00:52:34
your options are. As supervisor client said, there are plenty of facilities and properties that we could definitely. 00:52:42
Include in an evaluation. 00:52:52
So, Mr. Chairman. 00:52:55
You know. 00:52:58
There's there's more than one goal. I mean, one of the goals would be is just a consolidation of of county people. 00:53:01
You know, and, and, and quit this scattered out stuff. You know, we've, we've, we have these buildings, we still have the 00:53:09
Michelson building setting down here right to, to do something with the ad that's. 00:53:15
Don't we have an idea with the city of Globe on that job? 00:53:23
We did have. I don't think the city of Clovis got their funding to do their part. 00:53:28
They've gotten. 00:53:33
The ICA was prepared. 00:53:38
I'd prefer to three months ago. 00:53:43
I don't know what it is. 00:53:47
OK, Michael, go ahead. You're a supervisor's. Yeah, as far as the Microsoft goes, I can give you a quick update on that. So as Joe 00:53:48
said, the city of go overseas, Dearmont money about two years ago, $750,000 and they have to come up with a 25% match. That money 00:53:56
is going to be used to remodel the entire inside of the Michelson building to make a incubator for local businesses. 00:54:05
And on Gila Counties end, Mr. Menlove has instructed our facilities department to remove all the old equipment and furniture 00:54:14
that's damaged as being stored in the building on the 1st floor. We're going to be removing that. And then we're also going to be 00:54:21
getting a contract price on demolishing the entire inside to get it ready for the City globe to do tomorrow. So that's where we 00:54:29
are right there if you have any questions. 00:54:36
Be happy to answer that. 00:54:44
So there was there was a one point in time, a discussion about. 00:54:48
An IGA with the city of Globe and Gila County. 00:54:53
For the CD Globe to turn over the earmark money to Gila County so our facilities department can manage the, you know, the model 00:54:57
project. But I think that hit a snag with federal requirements right now. My last conversation with City Globe is that they 00:55:04
believe the federal guidelines will not allow them to give the money to Gila County to manage the project. They have to manage the 00:55:10
Romano project themselves. 00:55:17
So refresh my memory, Michael, when this is all done on the Michelson building, were we still going to own that building or we 00:55:25
were we going to work a deal with Globe to for them to take ownership of that? We have owned the building, but it's going to be a 00:55:31
joint incubator for business building use. That's exactly that's where they'll be used for. 00:55:38
Okay, you know, I had these questions, you know, because this seems to be dragging on that particular project quite a bit. So I 00:55:45
was curious where we are and where Globe is and. 00:55:50
All that, it's been a challenge in talking with the city of Globe, it's been a challenge accessing this $750,000 so we could start 00:55:56
doing model of that. 00:56:01
They've had a challenge getting through that 750,000. 00:56:07
Is that because of their match money or no? They have the match money, it's just the process and how they have to go about access 00:56:12
the grant money on the federal side. 00:56:16
Because as we all know, we learned a couple years ago when the earmarks came back into play, the federal government would give the 00:56:22
money to a department that they felt was best suited to pass the money through for the local organization. And a lot of times 00:56:29
those federal agencies do not have a process in place to be passed through grants. They actually have to create a new pathway, 00:56:36
which can take a little bit of time on the federal government side. 00:56:43
So I would think that, you know, if there's a way that we could ever work towards consolidating more people, getting us on these 00:56:51
buildings, getting rid of some of these buildings, that's going to generate savings to the county. 00:56:57
Just from the facilities part, maintenance and so forth. 00:57:04
To some extent, I mean isn't going to pay for everything we would want to spend to to build new stuff or fix stuff, but it would 00:57:09
help. I mean that would show. 00:57:14
So it's being pretty responsible for our properties at the county owns and everything. And we've still, we've talked about it, you 00:57:21
know, in other lands we've talked about is Buckhead Mesa once that's done and maybe consolidating the Pine Road yard, the 00:57:27
Buckhead, Buckhead Mesa, which gives us more property to get rid of. 00:57:33
We still have 7 pieces of property in Winkelman and Aden the county owns outright. 00:57:39
That we needed to let go, get it sold, get it out there and back on Tactical so. 00:57:45
These are all questions that I see for me that that are pretty important. We can't just keep. 00:57:52
Adding building, whatever you may say and keep scrolling out, we need to, we need to somehow rein that in and do what we need to 00:57:59
do there. And Lord knows we have a plenty to fix legitimate issues to fix Fairgrounds Electric, this building and you, you have 00:58:05
seen a long list of projects. 00:58:11
Mr. Chair, right now, that's all I have. OK. Yeah. I, I kind of feel like I was led down a path today to create a new magic 00:58:18
building that's going to fix everything, and I don't, I don't. 00:58:24
I didn't, I didn't come prepared for a new magic building. It's going to fix everything. I thought we were going to reach for some 00:58:33
money to kind of repair the things that we have and work within the things that we have. Because I, you know, if I've got an older 00:58:40
truck that needs an engine, is it, let's just throw it away and go buy a new one because it's cheaper to pay $2,000,000 a year 00:58:46
than it is. 00:58:53
Whatever it is to fix it so and there again, I don't know if we borrow money, if we have to spend it in three years. 00:59:00
We can't spend it in fixing some of the older buildings. That's why we're just going to build a new magic building because we can 00:59:07
do that in three years and that'll lead up to $30 million instead of trying to do the electrical in this building that may take 00:59:14
three years just to get that organized, so. 00:59:20
As this list as the list, I apologize that that wasn't clear. As the list lays out, we would still be fixing this building. 00:59:28
This building, when we get the new Magic building, what are we going to do with all these buildings that we've been fixing? 00:59:37
Well, some of them like like the Apache Blvd. the school over there, we would just be turning that back. Yeah, we don't own the 00:59:47
Central Heights building. I understand, right. And this building with the expected growth in court services in the next 5 to 10 00:59:54
years, we would this entire building could be used by court services. 01:00:00
OK. And by this is the first I've heard of that. 01:00:08
We're sort of at that difficult teeter totter of. 01:00:14
Giving you too much information and apparently not enough information. So again, I apologize. I had been told you don't you don't 01:00:19
need to apologize. You know, I mean, that's why we have work sessions and that's why I get frustrated that we don't have more work 01:00:25
sessions. So I don't get kind of pushed in a direction that's a direction we need to go because then I feel like this and it's 01:00:31
like, wait a minute, I I. 01:00:37
I don't know why I'm going down this hallway because OK, in what, in a few years our court system can use this whole building 01:00:44
being I just heard that today. OK, what, what's the state going to kick into that? Or is that the counties responsibility for, for 01:00:51
all of this that's going on? I, you know, I mean, that's why I like to have work sessions because I don't like to walk around 01:00:58
blind. And sometimes I feel that you're just there to say yes and make a motion and pass the motion and. 01:01:06
Take care of everything else. It's like I want to help in those decisions. I want to kind of know what the full, what the full 01:01:14
picture is, not just the piece that that I want to be shown. 01:01:19
That's fair. One of the things that I know was helpful in our previous financing was that we had prepared like a pocket 01:01:26
publication for each of you to have. If you choose to move forward or even if you just choose to move forward with a scaled 01:01:33
version of these projects, we would give you that so that when constituents have questions, you would have like a point of 01:01:41
reference that you could either share with your constituents. 01:01:48
Keep as reference for yourself because you don't want to carry this around. This is too much, right? This is the simplified 01:01:55
version, but it's still too much. And we would make sure that as we were developing that, that we worked with your executive 01:02:02
administrative assistant to make sure that any questions you had such as well, what would we use this building for so that those 01:02:08
are covered there so that you don't feel. 01:02:14
Like you feel today when your constituents have questions for you so that you could feel. 01:02:21
Prepared and empowered to to respond to those and umm. 01:02:26
The feedback that you provided us today is really useful and important and something that we will definitely make sure in the 01:02:34
future that when somebody tells me, oh, yeah, I talked to all three supervisors about this ahead of me coming in here and looking 01:02:41
like a clown actually got done. You don't look like a clown. Oh, I got the big rubber nose. You know, my two cents on all this is, 01:02:48
is like Supervisor Humphrey said this. 01:02:55
These are the only way we can sit down and talk, even me and him. I mean, we, we can't. I've, I've said it before and I'll say it 01:03:03
again, that one of the biggest injustices to me is the open meeting laws and the way they're set up. But when we have work 01:03:10
sessions like this, this is the way we both have a chance to talk and learn and, and, and get better ideas like from Mark and, and 01:03:17
you Marin on all this. I mean, this, this is put together very well. 01:03:24
With, with the projects, with the figures and everything like that and so. 01:03:32
You know, it, it starts making you think on what what's the best way going forward? I mean, if you look behind us, when we did the 01:03:36
Tumble Martin Fine building, when we did the animal shelter, when we bonded out PSPRS, those were absolutely good moves for us to 01:03:42
make. 01:03:47
We saved a lot of money from the PSPRS part of it, the animal shelter. We were getting ready to get kicked out of that over there, 01:03:54
and so we had. 01:03:59
A road to go down that was you didn't have to guess where you needed to go. That's what we needed to do. When you refinance 7% 01:04:05
money for 2% money, no doubt those are almost free, no doubt and and, and yeah, and so. 01:04:12
I think a magic new building would be a great thing, but at the same time I want to know what we're doing with with the other. 01:04:20
And and and properties that are sitting there, you know I. 01:04:27
I have been a supervisor for eight years and asked what's going on with the patient property a million times. 01:04:33
Even put some equipment up there and use the granite on our roads, something and. 01:04:40
And nothing's happened with it and so, but, but we can go forward and build a new one. OK, well. 01:04:48
Let's figure out some of the other things as well and and if and if there's any other more animals like the court system gonna 01:04:55
need this whole building of of years. 01:05:01
What other monsters are out there that you guys are slaying that I don't know anything about? You know, it would be. It would be 01:05:07
nice to know. 01:05:12
Hey, Leviathan Zoology. Next work session, Michael. 01:05:18
Yes, thank you, Chairman. Yeah, the magical new building, you should call it was just a conceptual discussion. It really wasn't a 01:05:22
building that we are designing or planning. Got a location? 01:05:29
They have a location, yes, yes. Anyways, it's a conceptual idea. And then the idea was to to gauge the opinion on the board 01:05:37
possibly moving forward with bonding issues. 01:05:43
And one of the struggles we have is. 01:05:50
Is with the copper building with and the parking lots, the the age of that those trailers that were put together over there are 01:05:52
coming to an end and, and all the repairs with the Central heights. So I believe what I'm hearing from you, Sir, is you want to 01:06:00
see more comprehensive plan from county administration facilities to to address some of these issues. And I couldn't I couldn't 01:06:07
agree with you more. I think that's that's the direction I will talk to Mr. Manblov and my staff about. 01:06:14
Get a more specific plan in place for for all of these bigger issues and present it in one package because I think we're piece 01:06:23
mealing it a little bit. So I agree with you, Sir. And I'll, I'll work with staff to get that done. 01:06:30
I agree with that. You know, if we just have an idea. 01:06:38
Not even an idea. We just have a direction that we all agree on and we're going to work towards going forward. You know that this 01:06:43
is what we want to do. Now, how we get there, that's going to involve some more discussion. But you know, do we want to shrink it 01:06:49
down on buildings? Do we want to fix and leave what's there? I mean, there's a lot of things, but like. 01:06:55
The one that is going to bite us is going to be that copper building down. 01:07:02
That's coming up. Your office might just do this one day, so. 01:07:07
Every time the AC starts, it shakes the wall. Yeah, yeah. And that's, I mean, that's something we were dealt and we deal with it. 01:07:13
That's fine. But. But yeah. 01:07:19
And, and yeah, and, and I understand too that, you know, this is just a work session so we can talk about things. So no, you don't 01:07:26
have the big rubber nose. This is just communication because none of this is we, we don't know of any savings or anything until 01:07:34
like you say, we hire professionals to kind of look at this and give us. 01:07:42
An idea of whether it's best to fix some of the things or or what can we do? 01:07:51
To better move forward. 01:07:57
With the new building or whatever we need to do. And, and so I, I guess what, what I'm needing to know, what I would like to know 01:08:01
is I understand what these professionals are going to do. They're going to look at, at cost and how we can best do what we can do 01:08:10
for the, for the, for the best cost, bang for buck. And, and so do we know really what these professionals are going to cost? 01:08:19
Do we know what what the? 01:08:29
What information we're going to ask them for, like to look at our property values that are sitting there and and what could we do 01:08:33
to bring that in to help the scope of work of what we need to do going forward. 01:08:41
Those would be included in the request for proposal from them. Sure. And so if, if, if this is kind of a work session to I mean, 01:08:49
I'm all for listening to professionals on, on. 01:08:57
On what we need to look at and be cost effective going forward with the space that may be needed going forward. 01:09:06
I, I, you know, I would like to, I would like to see what, what that magic number is, because either we can afford these 01:09:20
professionals, we have to borrow money to hire these professionals to see how we can borrow money to better help go forward. You 01:09:27
know what I mean? But but I would, I would be interested in hearing. 01:09:35
What what we can do to get better efficient? 01:09:44
On on where we need to go. 01:09:51
You know, one of the things I would say to that is too is, is that. 01:09:56
I, I feel like we, we need to start with the professionals we've got that are standing here. 01:10:02
You know, and us you've got ideas, you know, if you think about it while Michael Wood and everybody else, but then come out with 01:10:07
the with the with the consultant type to say, hey, this is what the group came up with the direction. Now how do we get there and 01:10:13
what's it going to cost? 01:10:19
You know how many Michael, how many employees now does he the county have 500 and something. 01:10:26
We have 463 full time active staff at the moment. 01:10:33
And a lot of those are in pacing or some of those are in and then we've got another 100 and 25130 budgeted that are not filled. 01:10:39
Ya. 01:10:47
You know, and so when it gets right down to it, the number of employees and and things like that, that we would if we went with 01:10:48
something to reduce buildings and consolidate, that's something to think about too. How many of those people would be moving been 01:10:54
somewhere else, I don't know. 01:11:00
And so I think that to me it just seems like. 01:11:07
As a county, we kind of need to know what what we want to do. I mean, we've talked about a lot of things here, but but you know, 01:11:12
myself and whoever you guys, you know, we need more thinking about it, but we definitely need more work sessions or another work 01:11:19
session on on something like where, what do we want to do? What are we going to go? And we definitely learned. 01:11:26
Some lessons during the Tommy Klein Martin development process about where we need to draw lines around. 01:11:34
That process so that it doesn't become an endless wish list, right, so that we can be reasonable about it and make sure that. 01:11:43
Our service to the community supports the growth or consolidation that we're looking at and not just Oh well, I want a bigger 01:11:55
office with a window. So where do I get that as opposed to OK, we're going to serve? 01:12:04
350 people a day, how do we make sure that we have enough ingress and egress and adequate staff service so that they can visit the 01:12:14
department that they need get served in a timely manner and then still be able to get on with their day and not take a day off 01:12:22
work, you know, to come interact with our staff and things like that. So and I know that over the past couple years the board has 01:12:29
really. 01:12:36
Smartly invested in digitization and other processes that are projected to improve our community service going forward and our 01:12:44
constituents access to information and those projects have taken longer than you expected. 01:12:53
So we may need to have like a chart on the wall that. 01:13:02
Cases our projects against whether or not we get the Forest Service admin site free and clear from Congress and we'll raise them 01:13:08
against each other and and we'll offer some illegal. 01:13:13
Off books, activities for people to wager on those. You may have to explain that sometime, Mary, but yeah, but think about it. You 01:13:20
could do that and have a fundraiser. Oh yeah, the nonprofit could do it. Yeah, there you go. But. 01:13:28
I know that the only thing slower than bureaucracy is documenting bureaucracy, and you've both encountered that a lot here today. 01:13:37
So I appreciate your patience and your willingness to to even entertain today's presentation. And I look forward to us having 01:13:43
better information for you that answers your questions and opens the door to more questions. The more we can talk, the happier I 01:13:50
am. 01:13:56
Chairman and Supervisor Klein. So yeah, one of the ideas here in this work session was to gauge your your thought process on 01:14:05
whether you'd be open to bonds for some of these projects. So I think, I think the next step is to have several work sessions and 01:14:12
to prioritize the list like Supervisor Humphrey was saying. 01:14:19
Current projects, current buildings, what we need in that we we do have a comprehensive list of what we need in the current 01:14:27
buildings. 01:14:31
They are old and they are, you know, there are similar pairs that need to be done. And then and then since it was just a 01:14:35
conceptual discussion, bring back the possible complex building discussion for, for many more conversations, because that is a big 01:14:43
project that's that would be that would involve staff trying to put together a package to work with. 01:14:51
Consultants to find out how much we would actually save with energy efficiencies. 01:15:01
HVAC's moving out of the Central Heights complex, those kinds of things like what the questions you're asking supervisor, that 01:15:06
would certainly be part of the discussion. So that, I believe is what the plan is moving forward, unless you have other ideas. 01:15:14
Yeah, No, I, I just feel as if we're looking at, at, at, at two different situations 1. 01:15:22
Being able to operate in what we have because. 01:15:31
If the electricity goes out of here, we can't operate in this building, so to me that's one thing. 01:15:36
And some of our other buildings that have aged, we need to function and we can't throw them away, just move into a new building. 01:15:42
So if we spend a lot of money fixing these. 01:15:54
Then to me it's a whole nother deal going forward to look at building something that can be more efficient in the future. 01:15:59
But if and if we do that, then we also need to know what we're going to do with what we leave behind. 01:16:07
You know, kind of like the schools, you see all these old schools that are falling down because the school did something more 01:16:15
energy efficient or whatever they did, but they didn't think about what they were doing with their old falling down schools. 01:16:21
And so to me, we're looking at fixing stuff and then we're looking at a new efficient building and, and to put those all together 01:16:29
as to me as I, I, you know, that's, that's. 01:16:35
That would be an awful lot of expense. And then we've got these buildings that are functional now, but it's got no electricity and 01:16:43
it'll function for a long time, but we're we're, we're building a new one in two years. So what are we going to do with this 01:16:48
efficient building? 01:16:54
That's all. No, I agree, Sir. And we'll keep those projects, if the current projects that we have listed for a priority, you know, 01:17:01
replacing the roof on this building, those kinds of things that need to get done, we'll certainly present in the next work 01:17:07
session, fleshy by the way, in the next work session, we'll certainly keep that separate and give you different lists and keep the 01:17:13
possible complex. 01:17:19
Concept in one work session and then the current project that we need. 01:17:26
It would also help in in in if we reach out for for borrowing money. 01:17:32
What are we borrowing money for? 01:17:39
And and and and where's that money gonna go? And what's that gonna do for us? And I'm all for looking down the road at what a new 01:17:43
facility would do for us. 01:17:48
But I think we have, I think we have more problems. 01:17:54
Right now then. 01:17:59
In the new building. But anyway, if that has been raked over the coals enough, sure, Marin's had all the fun she can have. Oh, I 01:18:01
don't know, we still got what, another five hours here at work today? 01:18:08
Yeah, OK. Supervisor trying to get anything else. No, I'm good. I, I appreciate this discussion and and I really appreciate Mark 01:18:17
and Mary and you guys are working on all this and I look forward to more so. 01:18:24
So we'll bring back more at the October 29th. 01:18:33
Work session that is correct. 01:18:37
You got it. Thank you. OK, thank you. Have a good day. Thanks. 01:18:40
OK, we're going to move on to regular agenda item 2D information discussion regarding an update on the activities of the Community 01:18:45
Development Department. 01:18:52
You got a pretty hard act to follow there, my friend. 01:19:03
It's a good thing there's only two of us today. 01:19:07
Good morning or afternoon close to I'm Randy Plummer of the Community Development Director, as you know morning supervisors. So 01:19:17
today what we're going to talk about is community development, an exciting department that deals with. 01:19:25
Building, zoning and code enforcement. Pretty much the three things that most of your constituents don't like. 01:19:33
But we have been looking at stuff and have been working with Michael and other departments to look at making things more efficient 01:19:42
and better for the constituents to deal with. 01:19:48
As you can see, one of the first things, one of the big questions we usually get asked is when do I need a building department or 01:19:54
building permit for? Well, to be honest with you, that's an impossible question to answer. It's, it's fast. There's a lot of 01:20:00
different things that incorporate into that how it's done, where it's done and all that good stuff. So what we did was, and these 01:20:06
are on our website. 01:20:12
First thing is what you don't need a permit for, so that's easier to address. 01:20:19
What you don't need a permit for, then what you do need a permit for? So we did it for both residential and commercial and they 01:20:26
said these are on our website and we hand them out at our front counters. So when someone comes in, do I need a permit for this? 01:20:35
We tried to hand this out and what we're really trying to accomplish here is to get people to call. 01:20:44
Can I get some of those handouts from my public meetings? Yes, Sir. Thank you. 01:20:54
We're really trying to get people to call in because this has been an issue with, I will tell you at every building department 01:21:00
that I deal with, which is all of Arizona, we have meetings, associations and stuff and getting people to call in and ask the 01:21:07
questions and then ask the right questions because they don't want to get a permit. So they'll turn around and try to tell you I'm 01:21:15
just doing a shed. Well, they don't tell you they're doing a shed in the floodplain next to the. 01:21:22
Yard line next to over the sewer system that is a foot off the property line. So that's where staff comes in and we got to ask 01:21:30
those questions. And sometimes people may or may not want to give us all of the information, but it's staff's responsibility to 01:21:38
help pursue that and to get the information so that we can provide that answer. 01:21:46
And what we've done to help incorporate that is twice a month now I combine both offices through Zoom and we have in house 01:21:55
training on very specific topics. 01:22:01
So that way that hopefully that no matter what office that you go to or what staff member you talk to, you will get the same 01:22:09
answer. And I know that people have complained in the past that oh, I went this way. I hear one thing. I went over here, talk to 01:22:15
someone else, got a different answer. Some of that is true and some of that is because they ask different questions in a different 01:22:22
way. I want this shed on my property. 01:22:29
There's a whole lot different than what I really want to shed in the floodplain. 01:22:36
And then we find out, well, it's next to the property line. So I mean some of the confusion can come from not getting all of the 01:22:40
information and that's what we're working with staff to. 01:22:47
Ask that question. I will tell you tomorrow we will have in house training on investigation and to find out what's going on, on 01:22:55
prior buildings, what happened on prior buildings. So they get a permit. They did not get a permit. Why didn't they get a permit? 01:23:02
Did someone say it didn't need a permit? And so we're going to have all of the staff members. 01:23:09
Not the inspectors, but they'll be out in field doing inspections and all the office staff, permit, tax plans, examiner planning, 01:23:18
we'll all be in that kind of training and we're doing that twice a month. 01:23:24
So this is all good stuff and part of the issues that you guys have helped support is moving towards digitization or digitizing. 01:23:33
We are currently we have no files in any office that has to do with parcels. 01:23:43
They are all at the. 01:23:54
Digitizer guy, Iron Mountain is who's doing it for us. Dave came and got all of the files out of Patient and out of Globe. So 01:23:58
basically I have about 67 empty file cabinets right now. Still have some information on them that we're dealing with and we'll be 01:24:05
moving forward to changing that. But that is one of the things you guys have helped support and are moving forward. We are 01:24:13
actually hoping to get it completed by the end of this year. 01:24:20
Here where everything is copied, digitized and we have access to, and I will tell you currently staff is going through a list of 01:24:27
about 100,000 pieces of paper. We're trying to make sure they're all readable. So literally, I've had people come in on Saturday 01:24:36
for five hours, I haven't come in on a Sunday, and they literally are going page by page by page. 01:24:44
To make sure they're readable and to make sure that they're. 01:24:53
Documented where they're findable. So in other words, doesn't do me a whole lot of good to have 20 parcels digitized, but they 01:24:58
don't have a parcel number on them. I will never be able to research those. So I will tell you staff is diligently and and and. 01:25:07
It's not fun, but it is getting done. So we may be done with the digitizing by the end of the year, but I'm not authorizing final 01:25:16
payment until we get through that list. Because at that first we found all the pictures that we have in these files were black. 01:25:25
And so that doesn't do us any good. So we made them go back and recopy those at a different. 01:25:33
DPI, whatever they call it, stuff to make sure that we could see those and they were part of the file. So that's what staff is 01:25:43
currently doing. 01:25:47
We've also, thanks to your help, have worked on a new permitting system. We went from trackit.net. We are now currently on, it's 01:25:53
called community development, which is from Tracket, newer version, it's online. They're still working on our portal. We just got 01:26:02
credit cards. We're able to go through the portal now so people can pay online at their home and. 01:26:12
Take care of all that stuff. They'll be able to look up their own stuff. So we're hoping that as training goes on, not only with 01:26:22
staff but with the public, that if someone wants a public records request. 01:26:29
For their property go on pull up, you can look where your own septic system is. I will tell you there are a lot of septic 01:26:36
companies that don't keep records because they keep requesting our copies so that they can redesign or or repair a system. So. 01:26:44
It's, it's vastly important. We also are going to tablets. My inspectors will hopefully in the very near future. We went through 01:26:54
two trainings. We're having a little bit of issues with the. 01:27:00
Offline, when they're in a place that doesn't have cell service, which is a lot of healer county, but we have tablets now that 01:27:07
they'll be able to fill in. And actually when they come into a area that has service, it will e-mail the person on the list the 01:27:15
report. So we don't get, well, I never saw the report, The wind blew it away. 01:27:23
All the things that we've had happen. 01:27:32
And it automatically will load into the system. 01:27:35
When the inspector gets back. So we are trying to upgrade these kind of things. 01:27:38
I will tell you we're working on a new building codes. We are currently on the 2012 international code and I will have an IGA in 01:27:44
January. I believe that we're. 01:27:52
Going to be a hard time for. I will tell you it's a vast difference. There's a big difference between 2012 and 2024 code. 01:28:01
And that's going to take a lot of time with contractors and talking and coming up with all that stuff. But if we don't go to the 01:28:10
new code, we are going to get listed as a 8:00 to 9:00. It's one to 1010 being worse, one being best. Right now we're a four. And 01:28:18
that affects our has a possibility affecting. They don't have to accept it, but they do. The insurance companies determine 01:28:25
people's insurance rates. 01:28:33
Based on three things, once your fire system, 1 is your billing department and one is your public works. So in other words, can 01:28:41
they get there? 01:28:45
Tire system, if it's in place, if there is, how was it put in and then what building codes and what they were inspecting to. So 01:28:50
that's a big issue and it's a big thing I will tell you. 01:28:57
Contractors don't like change. They don't want to move forward with this. A lot of it is and as you guys were just talking about 01:29:06
your, your buildings, a lot of the new code is, I mean structural. Structural, don't be wrong. If a beam can hold this much 01:29:13
weight, that doesn't change using the codes, but a lot of where you can place those codes, what hardware you can use for those, 01:29:20
those kind of connections will change, but energy efficiency is a huge part of the code now. 01:29:27
It used to be a separate code. 01:29:34
That was over here. You could adopt it or not adopt it. Now. It's part of the IBC and the IRC that makes you adopted. Now we still 01:29:37
can remember we do not have to adopt the 24 code International as a whole. 01:29:44
It is designed to work from here to. 01:29:52
New York to Hawaii and beyond, what we will do is we'll go through and make amendments to accommodate for our snow loads, our wind 01:29:57
loads, I. 01:30:04
That we don't need to worry about a 90 LB snow lobe when we have it, how we top out at 40 lbs. So we'll be looking at those and 01:30:12
those will be amendments that we'll make to the change and that becomes the building code ordinance. And and that is one of the 01:30:18
new things that we'll have to be working on too. We are currently working with an IGA to bring income in. There's there's expired 01:30:24
increments. 01:30:30
IGA will be. We've got that in. Now we're just waiting for the. 01:30:37
Other board to approve it so that we can get it on the board agenda item for you guys to approve. I just had a phone call 01:30:43
yesterday with the state on our. 01:30:49
IGA for manufactured homes and we want it. We feel that you guys want us to keep that because you do a lot of manufactured homes. 01:30:55
And what happens is if we don't have that IGA, then the state's got to come down every time to do an inspection. And that will 01:31:03
just slow down the process where our guys are driving by anyway are trained there. There's some actual new training that'll have 01:31:10
to go through for the IGA to go through, but our guys are driving by. 01:31:18
House every day. There's no reason we can't look at the Jack or the connection systems that we've been doing for years. But our 01:31:25
current IGA is expired. I have been talking to them to make sure that they allow us to continue to do what we're doing. But the 01:31:32
IGA, they required some training that they don't provide. So there's no place to get the training that they say you have to have 01:31:39
for the IGA. Stuff was kind of been slow in this town. 01:31:45
So that's dealing with building. Like I said, we're we're trying to get people to call us on a more regular basis and we can 01:31:54
answer those questions so that they can get all the information that they need. 01:32:01
The other Part 1 of the other sections is code enforcement and this is what be honest with you. The more people see than than they 01:32:09
know or realize that they know. 01:32:14
Everything that we do in code enforcement is a lot of visual. 01:32:21
You drive by a house that has a bunch of junk contraction debris in it stands out to you. That is not what the county wants as our 01:32:26
face, so we work pretty hard with code enforcement. 01:32:32
Jessica has made some new interpretations that allow us to do some stuff where we used to not be able to. 01:32:39
Site the occupant which is the person causing the issue and if we have an out of state or out of area owner they're much harder to 01:32:49
get a hold of. 01:32:55
We're under the new direction that we've received is we can go site the occupants for the issue and that that's helping. We're 01:33:01
also trying to get to where we get to every code enforcement. 01:33:10
Project every two weeks. 01:33:20
So if someone calls it in we used to not make a case. So if you someone called in a complaint. 01:33:24
We drive by it, but we never documented it. So now if anyone complaints, we make a case because now I have a place to document it, 01:33:33
Say there's it's not valid or it is valid, but now I have a place for those notes to go. We can track that stuff and do better 01:33:41
with that. One of the other things we're doing is making a master list of all of these violations. 01:33:50
Or problems. Supervisor Humphrey uses that list quite often. 01:33:59
I'm currently having staff make a master list of all the areas. So if Supervisor Klein wanted to know what violations are occurred 01:34:04
in Whispering Pines, I will have a list that I can give you so that if you have a constituent and art will be updating that. And, 01:34:11
and as we go out to the site and say we visited, there's been no change. There has been change so on and so on that will be added 01:34:18
on there with the date. 01:34:25
Michaels came up with format so. 01:34:32
It's not what our system currently does, so it's kind of a. 01:34:35
Labor intensive list, but I've actually been in contact with the new permitting system of writing the report in in the format that 01:34:40
we want, the format they have. It gives you a whole lot of information that you will never use. So we're trying to fix that. I 01:34:48
will tell you we're complaint driven. 01:34:56
But that does not mean we don't drive the street. So what I directed code enforcement is, is when they drive the street, so they 01:35:05
got a complaint at house 123 here they drive the whole street and look for any other violation from the street on the rest of that 01:35:11
road. 01:35:17
You'd be surprised how many people call in a complaint and have several violations of their own, but they want to point finger at 01:35:24
someone else and leave me alone. So I don't think that's fair because we've been accused of you're picking on me now we got a 01:35:31
complaint, we deal with that. We used to go to that house. It doesn't matter what we drove through or by, we would turn around and 01:35:38
leave. So now we go there, look at that house, decide what we need to decide. 01:35:46
Drive the rest of the houses around to see if there are any other violations. I will tell you one of the biggest problems we have 01:35:53
is contacting people. 01:35:58
I don't think you guys realize how many dead people there are that own houses. 01:36:05
There's a lot of them. And what the state law requires is that I have to contact someone to be able to pursue and go to hearing 01:36:12
officer or pursue any of the Novs or anything else. And if I. 01:36:19
I don't have the communications to a dead person on a normal basis, so it makes it very hard to move forward. And then you will 01:36:28
have, as Supervisor Humphreys tried to get dealt with at the state. Well, whoever's paying that housing tax or the land tax that 01:36:36
they could be held liable. So far that hasn't gone through. And then we have kids that go out and live in the house. 01:36:45
But have no right to be in that house that's never went through probate. It hasn't gone through. 01:36:54
Wills or anything else. And so I can't I can now cite them because they're the occupants, but I can't cite them as the owner. So 01:36:59
it it's it is a big issue and sometimes people just don't pick up their mail. I mean they see we send out. 01:37:07
Certified Mail. 01:37:17
They don't want anything, they know they're in violation. This is not new and they just don't pick it up. And then at some point 01:37:20
post office returns to us and says sorry undeliverable. We I have been using the constable trying to get out there but just 01:37:27
yesterday I received one at 15 attempts to try to get someone at a house. 01:37:35
And failed on 15 different times. 01:37:44
And had David went to places that the neighbor said, well, he's over here or she's over here. They would go there. They were 01:37:47
really working hard. And I got to tell you, the council's been awesome. They're great to work with. They try hard, but there are 01:37:53
people that. 01:37:58
Don't want to be found and it makes it tough. And then you get the neighbors complaining and then the neighbors come and complain 01:38:05
to you guys as supervisors saying this house is a pile and they're not doing anything. 01:38:12
The only option I've been told that is is out there is that we have to go to the state file and John's financial discussion have 01:38:20
to file a suit. 01:38:25
To force the state to put someone in charge of the probate. Now I can have someone to notify and say I hey, you got to clean this 01:38:32
up. 01:38:36
But unless we go to the state and they. 01:38:43
Put someone in charge. We have a problem and it's a growing problem. It's not getting better. 01:38:46
But I will tell you that Jessica has worked hard with us and she sent us a list of options that 20 different other things that 01:38:54
other counties have tried. I wrote items 12654 and all these different things and she kind of lasts. I don't think supervisors are 01:39:00
going to allow us to kick people out of the house and put it up for any economic support. And I was trying to figure out any way 01:39:07
we could. Michael was a little bit more. 01:39:13
Direct and had an idea, and we're still working on clearing that idea up to see if we can do it legally. 01:39:20
Then we're talking zoning, which is. 01:39:30
A huge part as you guys have been inherited buildings that. 01:39:35
Weren't your decisions. 01:39:42
Our current zoning has inherited things that weren't enforced and weren't done and. 01:39:45
People don't like changes as a whole and we're pursuing that as or as commonly as we can. But it's something that has to be dealt 01:39:52
with and we have ordinances that you guys have approved or or supervisors have approved and we have to move forward with those to 01:39:59
what they say, not what we want to interpret. 01:40:06
We are always looking at new ordinances and zoning. As you know we've been working on short term rentals and we have a new porta 01:40:16
potty ordinance that we're going to have to deal with. We have RV zoning, new building, minor land division, which is now kind of 01:40:25
the hot topic of for a while there was short term rentals. Minor land division is becoming a huge topic down the top. 01:40:34
So in our current ordinance, which is about. 01:40:43
14 years old. 01:40:48
Doesn't address dividing land over 10 acres. It only depends under 10 acres, but it doesn't talk about minor land or lot line 01:40:50
adjustments or anything else. It doesn't address all that stuff, which what our people are doing in the tunnel Bay since the 01:40:57
bridge has gone in. I mean, I'm probably signing. 01:41:05
5 minor land divisions a week there. Some of them I've reported and I will tell you that from our attorney, Mr. Beauchamp and 01:41:14
Michael, we have people complaining about illegal subdivisions going in and we have nothing to say about it. But I report it to 01:41:22
the Realtors, Realtors Association. They they deal with that for the state. 01:41:31
And. 01:41:39
I'm not going to say that they aren't responding, but they're not quick to respond. 01:41:42
So there's a lot of things going on in that area that affect us on a daily basis. 01:41:48
One of the big things that and Michael is is kind of hammered this home is we're working a lot with other departments. Every 01:41:58
Monday we have public works health department. 01:42:04
Building Department zoning Sit down at 9:30 every Monday. 01:42:13
And have at least an hour long conversation going over projects so that we all are on the same page and we all know what's going 01:42:18
on. And we all know that if it's if Alex is dealing with this in the flood, that affects how the health department deals with the 01:42:24
how the building department is. We're in the old ways. You come in, ask the building department the question we're going to 01:42:30
answer. 01:42:36
And we'll talk to them if you want to deal with the flood or you go talk to them if they want to deal with the health department. 01:42:43
And Michael's really, like said, hit home that we all sit down. Michael sits in on those conversations with us. So we have the 01:42:51
other directors of the departments and we go through all the problem projects, any projects that come up since the last Monday. 01:42:59
And and moving forward. So I think that's been a real good. 01:43:08
Solution to some of the issues. 01:43:13
And it works through the week I'll have guys popping up say I stopped by that site and we documented in trackage. 01:43:17
Track It. Michael is beat up on me because I was not always great at this. I will tell you, I'm still not, but I at least 01:43:26
delegated to other staff to make sure it gets put in to track it so that every phone conversation that we're having with an owner 01:43:31
should be in Track It. Every time we go to a site, it should be in track it. 01:43:37
And that's for all departments. And that was tough. Getting that across is that this isn't just a building department software. 01:43:46
This is a zoning software, a code enforcement software, a flood software. 01:43:52
Health Department. 01:44:00
Thing so that all of that information is in there, so that when someone comes in, we can give them all of the information that 01:44:03
they need to make the decisions they need to make, what they want to do. 01:44:08
Look my notes here. 01:44:19
I think that's about the end of it. 01:44:25
In summary, like I said, we we've been working real hard at coming up with. 01:44:29
Handouts that we can give to people. Our goal really is to get them to call in before they start their project. 01:44:34
So that, you know, when someone started a project and they put that shed in there and now it's in a flood and it's a foot away 01:44:44
from the property line sitting over a septic system. 01:44:48
They got to move it. I mean, it's going to have to be repaired and it's going to cost them more. 01:44:55
And so if we can get them to call in ahead of time, we can tell them, OK, yes, you can have a shed. Just make sure you don't put 01:45:01
it here, here, here or here. And you got to be 7 feet away from this line. And then they can make that decision for themselves at 01:45:07
that point and, and move forward and be less traumatic less. 01:45:14
Issues moving forward and cheaper overall for them. 01:45:22
So with that, I'll be more than happy to answer any questions. I see you guys writing down notes, so either drawing faces of me or 01:45:28
making notes for me to answer. 01:45:33
Go ahead, supervisor, client. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, Randy, let's talk about. 01:45:41
Upping the building codes from 12 towards 24 and the relation it has to do with the insurance, because I get this a lot, 01:45:46
especially up there in that rim country, people are being denied insurance, they're being cancelled and on and on and on. 01:45:54
How, how? How should I say that say this? 01:46:03
Is it really our building codes that are that are contributing to this or is it just being, is it just the insurance companies 01:46:08
being difficult to deal with? 01:46:13
Both. So like I said, there's 33 departments that they really look at fire, public works and building. We're not supposed to skip 01:46:18
more than two code cycles and a code cycle is every three years. Now all the building officials in Northern Arizona agreed that we 01:46:26
would look at adopting codes every six years. So we would always skip a code. 01:46:34
Globe just went to their 21 and they were on the 2003. 01:46:43
So they just went to the 21? 01:46:48
Patients talking about going to the 24 and we're talking about going to 24. The only reason I'm going to say the 24 in lieu of the 01:46:52
21 was because we're not real quick at adopting newer things. So why would we start off 1 code cycle behind in the code that we 01:46:59
adopt. So the insurance companies look for reasons to especially having fire it's good and we're public works comes in if we were 01:47:06
allowing. 01:47:14
Buildings to be up on these hills and up in the roads and we can't get to them or the fire department can't get to them. 01:47:21
That's a downside for the insurance company and we've had conversation with the fire department. We used to say if you showed us 01:47:30
that or if if you grew on there that the road was open, they took it, the road was open. Well, now the fire department's actually 01:47:37
going out before they give us a will serve letter that shows that they can get there and there's not a big tree in the middle of 01:47:44
the road that well, we just decided not to build that road. I will tell you we got. 01:47:52
That were approved with access roads that aren't and can't be in won't be in and so we're trying to address that so that. 01:47:59
I'm not going to say it's going to cure the issues, but the insurance companies will have less items to be able to deny people. 01:48:10
Access or deny their serviceability. OK, minor land divisions. This one's pretty interesting to me. So minor land divisions, isn't 01:48:21
that all under state statute? How that how land is divided? 01:48:29
Yes and no. So when they give us requirements, but we have to adopt our own ordinance. So we haven't had an ordinance that we we 01:48:38
have and still do that matches the the requirements of the. 01:48:45
State, but it says you can't divide. You can't divide your land more than five times. That's easy until you sell it to your friend 01:48:54
or your. 01:48:59
Brother or whoever and what the state chapter says is you can't sell this to your friend in order to get around the subdivision 01:49:05
requirements. We can determine if you did it to get around him or if you did it because they wanted to buy some land from you. So 01:49:12
under our requirements, we we're making sure what we're looking for is that they meet Sony, right. So when you divide this land, 01:49:19
as as you know, I've come to the board before when we have substandard lots. 01:49:27
And so I don't let them divide down to microscopic lots. It's got to meet the zoning. So that may be AGU 10,000 square foot parcel 01:49:35
and that they can't go below that where we'll sign it. And what it says if we don't sign it currently what it says is you a 01:49:45
surveyor has to put a note on there that this doesn't meet any code, won't meet any code and isn't accessible and it basically. 01:49:54
Makes it unsellable. So the surveyors want us involved. I will tell you, Scott has done a great job. He helps out all the surveys. 01:50:05
He reviews the minor land. He does the math, so he makes sure that it's meeting the requirements of the state for a survey plan. 01:50:12
He makes sure that the math and the lines close, which I have no idea how he does that, but that's what he does. And then he sends 01:50:19
it to me. 01:50:27
And then my job is, is to make sure that it meets zoning every setbacks because, you know, especially we start dividing land it's 01:50:34
already been built on. OK, well will they put that line that doesn't meet our set back requirements and stuff like that. So do I 01:50:41
take it back to the first time that lot was subdivided? No. And I do I go out and check if you bought this from someone you know 01:50:47
and no. 01:50:54
I go through, I see who's divided it, I see who's on our list. If that went over 5, we stopped. If it's four, we approve it as 01:51:01
long as it meets the other requirements. So it is a big thing and and I will tell you. 01:51:10
I I kind of think some people are jealous because you get someone who went out and bought 25 acres, he divided it five times. He 01:51:20
has now sold it and he gets to sell it for more than he paid for. And then that next person provides it five more times and so on 01:51:27
and so on. And they think there's a subdivision going in which there could be. And I swear after talking with our County Attorney, 01:51:34
he says report. 01:51:42
Every time. And so I fill out a form, you set it off and do what we can to make sure that's not happening. But I don't have staff 01:51:49
to go back to look when this was this number and it was 1000 acres and find out who bought what and divide it down. 01:51:59
So you take that 25 acres and you sell it. Whether you know the people or not, you sell it, they divide it five times. They sell 01:52:10
it, the new owners divide it five times. What acreage can you get down to before you're going to have to quit? Depends when 01:52:16
there's only. 01:52:21
So in other words, we have 35,000 square foot densities, we have one acre densities, we have 10,000, we have a 2000 density. So it 01:52:28
just depends on what it's zoned in that area. So in other words, if you had, I believe it's RR that we require one acre so that 01:52:36
they won't be able to take it down below an acre. 01:52:44
OK, what about places that aren't zoned? 01:52:53
Great question. Don't have a great answer. We would not. I don't even believe I signed the minor land divisions because they are 01:52:59
not zoned just like what right now when we have them over 10 acres. I don't sign because there's nothing I can hold them to. 01:53:06
There's no zoning, there's no set back requirements, there's no nothing. 01:53:14
So most of those just get recorded from the surveyor and go in and and. 01:53:22
Do what they want to do. The problem is, is, is we've had a couple things where codes do kick in. People might not have known it 01:53:27
and then they've done some stuff and now we got to repair that. I think for most areas that I'm I deal with, people want it pretty 01:53:33
open. 01:53:38
They don't want to see the houses stacked on one another and you'll see that whether that's indeed restrictions or or whatever. So 01:53:45
yeah, I mean, most of the smaller stuff is going to be not even tunnel so much. They still want some room, but you go into pine 01:53:51
strawberry where it's infill lots or the guy has an oversized lot. Now he wants two things, sell one of them and stay living where 01:53:57
he's at. 01:54:03
And that happens weekly. We got a guy up there right now who's splitting, doing it down to five lots. 01:54:11
Because he had five acres, so he's, you know, but the problem he's caused is some grading issues and flooding because he's on top 01:54:19
of the hill, so water rolls down so. 01:54:25
I don't think we have a great answer for what you're doing. Yeah. 01:54:33
That works so ordinances so. 01:54:38
Well, and even policy, how are we setting on that as far as ordinances, policy, whatever in your department? 01:54:44
Ornitas priority change monthly, you know, with short term rentals was taking up all the staff time at one point. That's kind of 01:54:52
out there right now. Porta potty was it was a big one because we have a lot of places on our main highways coming into our area 01:55:01
that have big green building sitting there and and one of some of the comments have been well, I'm coming in from. 01:55:10
Phoenix. 01:55:20
I got to use restroom like did you do I understand that, but you passed like 8000 of them on the way. And I don't think our 01:55:21
highway at at the frontage of Pine is a place that that needs to happen. You know, if it's hidden behind the building or 01:55:28
something, we can do that. Like I said, minor land division right now. I just tried to have a meeting yesterday with Scott and 01:55:34
Homer moving forward and I've talked to Michael about that. 01:55:41
That's one of the bigger ones right now. 01:55:48
I will tell you all of our ordinances are outdated and all of them can use a freshening, even my which is one of my newer ones. I 01:55:52
my hearing officer, well, that's going to have to be modified for the new building code. It would have to be modified for the 01:55:59
short term rental. It was going to have to be modified, you know, for any of the stuff the health department's talking about 01:56:06
trying to use the hearing officer more public works just. 01:56:13
Talk about using one hearing officer more. And right now they're not even included in the hearing officer. So we don't have an 01:56:20
ordinance that is not needing at least a refreshing or an update. And so you're going to start working on bringing those in front 01:56:29
of us to do whatever we need to do with them or yes. So I will tell you that management decides when I bring them in front of you. 01:56:37
We brought the short term rental a couple times and we're on hold with that one. The next one I would expect you to see that I 01:56:46
think is written. 01:56:50
And modified and done and gotten is the porta potty. What we currently say is you're not allowed to do it unless you're building 01:56:54
1. We have places in Pine that use them for their overflow during high tourist seasons. So we've taken for depression that back in 01:57:02
and put that as an option and give them around I think it's four months. 01:57:10
That we give them that they can bring a porta potty in for tour seasons. 01:57:19
That kind of stuff. So it's up to management to tell me when they want something in front of you. 01:57:24
So I don't have a schedule. 01:57:32
To go forward, I know we've come in front of you twice for RV's. 01:57:36
Not going to say that hasn't been direction, but there hasn't been clear direction on which way we want to go. We talked about 01:57:42
pulling that out of the zoning ordinance and making ARV stand alone. The minor land, I would be honest with you, it would be the 01:57:49
next one I think would be in front of you and then maybe port a potty or something. And so I don't have a schedule to bring it in 01:57:55
front of you, but. 01:58:01
Just like building. 01:58:09
I've been told to move forward with that because we kind of have to, um. 01:58:11
I waited. I got a study. Um. 01:58:16
And learn what's in there, you know? 01:58:20
And staff's got to learn what's in there. And so the contractors and so we got to have those meetings and that just, that takes a 01:58:23
lot of time to not only get the books in here and the codes in here and learn what's in those things. I can't remember my kids 01:58:30
names now, I'm afraid what's going to happen after I learn a new code. But that's part of it. So I don't know that I have a clear 01:58:36
answer for you, Sir. 01:58:43
Randy, thank you. I look forward to the ordinances and all that and going on room and and working with them so but thank you. 01:58:49
It's in, Mr. Chair. 01:58:58
OK. 01:59:00
I, I appreciate all that you do for planning and zoning. I understand it's a, it's a, it's a, it's an ongoing fight to keep up 01:59:02
with everything and the people doing what they do and also to like with the updates of, of what code were going by. That's, that's 01:59:12
going to cause the new builders a lot of difficulty, but it's going to, it's going to save expense to the existing home. 01:59:22
And so, you know, we kind of have to is there a good decision? Well, it's always what's best for the for the for the people. And 01:59:33
so I appreciate that. And that was one of my questions is how are we with the RV ordinances because I. 01:59:41
You know, that's that was a question asked a lot and so and it still is, but I understand why that's on hold as well. 01:59:51
But but we, we do. Well, I live in a recreational area, Roosevelt. So there's always people wanting to live in one. And I guess 02:00:03
there are some people living in some. It's just that there's really no ordinance now. 02:00:10
And we're working on it. So I appreciate it also to and you say you're encouraging people to call in and and I can appreciate that 02:00:19
as well. But if they do call in and ask for a site visit. 02:00:26
How do you go do site visit? I depends on what for, to be honest with you. If the site is it was to determine flood, those kind of 02:00:34
things. Absolutely what we don't get to and we get a lot of calls for it as well. I just got one from the Forest Service yesterday 02:00:42
where they want me to come out and condemn their building and I. 02:00:49
I'm like, no, that's a third party home inspector that you would use for that. That's not something we would do. So if someone 02:00:57
called us that, it was something we do. 02:01:02
You know construction wise or any of that stuff, then absolutely we go out there. It will not always be the next day, but if if we 02:01:08
have time on a day, my inspector always stop by, I will tell you Kim will stop by. I stopped by going to and from here today. I 02:01:16
stopped on one on coming in and I got 2 going back so. 02:01:24
I can appreciate that because if somebody calls in and says OK, if I've got a shed under 200 square feet, do I need a permit? 02:01:33
Well, no, OK. 02:01:37
Well, like you said, then they put it on the receptive tank or whatever and then it just creates problems down the road. But you 02:01:41
know a site visit, if you just go by and you sure you're going to put a shed where you're going to put it, Don't put it right 02:01:47
there, OK, if it's not on your septic, I don't see a problem. Then there isn't 1. And so anyway that's that would that's going to 02:01:53
be one of my recommendations if somebody asked me, I said if you're going to build something. 02:02:00
Call them and ask them for a site visit and see if planning and zoning will go. Look at what you want to do and where you want to 02:02:07
do it. 02:02:11
So they don't end up with a whole bunch of problems after you start construction. And, and what you said that and a complaint that 02:02:16
I get, especially with the new bridge and things like that, tunnel basin, Roosevelt area and things of that nature. It's been a 02:02:24
complaint since I've been a supervisor. And you said that staff doesn't go back and look. 02:02:32
When somebody broke down 1000 acres who it sold, where it sold to. 02:02:41
Is that would that be the states job? 02:02:47
I guess whose job is it because a lot of the complaints I get is Bill sells it to Fred, Fred sells it to Sam, and then Sam sells 02:02:54
back to deal with you and so Bill gets 15 lots instead of just five. It is the states responsibility to enforce the requirement 02:03:02
that you do not divide it more than five times. 02:03:10
Or make it unauthorized subdivision. That is the state's job. 02:03:19
Ask an answer because everything from the county doing anything about that. 02:03:27
It's because it's the states job to do something about. 02:03:32
That I get those complaints too and that's why I filed the complaint with the state saying I'm being told this is an illegal 02:03:36
subdivision. 02:03:40
Here you go, right. And they have a form that we fill out into and anyone can do that. You can even, I can give that to you and 02:03:45
you can give that to your constituents. If they want to file a complaint. It's the same form I fill out that they can fill out. 02:03:51
Sure. 02:03:57
OK, Well, I don't have anything else. I, I like I say, I appreciate all you're doing as a builder. I appreciate, you know, you're 02:04:04
working with, with the builders and the codes and the ordinances to try to help. 02:04:11
Infrastructure in handcount because it we, we need it. And now with the new bridge, there's going to be more of it in tunnel, 02:04:21
which is created issues for all of us, but I guess we'll call them growing pains. 02:04:28
And I will tell you we have two open positions currently. I'm looking at hiring 1 next week or interviewing for an inspector. 02:04:36
Are both inspector North and South? It'll be mostly inspect. The inspector will be based out of patient. 02:04:48
OK, So you got an inspector nor you said two positions, are they both inspectors and one is the building official, which I've 02:04:54
advertised for about two years and the building official is me. Oh, so I'm, I'm the building official, I'm the director right now. 02:05:03
I was hardest building official on certified building this a lot, I guess. So we're not losing anything. But there really isn't, I 02:05:12
mean, patient right now doesn't have a building official. They're using a third party company because they can't find any. And and 02:05:18
the guy who left there told him he was leaving five years ago and he'd been there for 30 years and they can't find anyone. So I 02:05:24
don't think we're going to be able to fill that position. But I, I be honest with you, it's kind of second nature to me. So it's 02:05:30
pretty easy for me to. 02:05:35
What's a third party cost? 02:05:42
In the lieu of the position, all right. 02:05:46
If they're running from what I've been told about 150,000 a year and the position pays 7D something, OK, so almost twice as much. 02:05:49
But I will tell you Michael is kind of forcing me into. 02:05:57
Getting people ready to take positions and I have a person that is studying for this position and has passed 2 tests. I told him 02:06:06
he needs to take four to five tests to make me feel more comfortable with him and I have it kind of all over He's an inspector, he 02:06:13
passed he's passed his plan reviewer. I want him to pass ADA and I want him to pass a commercial version of that and then building 02:06:20
official and he's working towards that and and I kind of see him being our. 02:06:28
Building official OK good yeah because that it's difficult to wear 2 hats because I know how busy you are and how how much we are 02:06:36
growing in and doing more and more building permits and things so yeah I think it would be it would it would be beneficial to us 02:06:46
the constituents people reaching it if you weren't wearing 2 hats that's kind of like and I will also throw in we. 02:06:55
July. 02:07:05
Of 24, we did 114 homes, new single families, manufacturing and Bissell built this year. We're kind of on the same pace and that's 02:07:06
about average we're between 115 to 120, somewhere in that range, 25 maybe on a year. I went back four years and that's what I came 02:07:15
up with. Right now we're a little bit behind because everyone's waiting until. 02:07:23
The electric interest rates and the elections. 02:07:33
The elections I hear more than the interest rates and that's part of the new code that we'll have to talk to you guys about. We're 02:07:36
currently on the 2000 and. 02:07:42
For evaluation code, that's how permanent pricing is determined. We're charging what our valuations using and the permit thing is 02:07:48
$83.74. And if you can get any home builder to come out to your house for $83.40 some cents, please get them, kidnap them, tie 02:07:57
them down, don't let them leave because people are charging 4 to 600 a square foot. 02:08:06
For custom homes now and we're at 83. 02:08:16
And I don't know that we want to jump up to that price range, but I do think we need to get more in line with. 02:08:20
Where reality is, as far as that goes, well, won't that change when you come up with the codes anyway? So it does not 02:08:31
automatically change the codes. Codes don't set the evaluation rate. The people who write the code, ICC International Code 02:08:38
Conference, they put out a valuation sheet every year, usually twice, one in June, 1 in January. 02:08:44
And they set the price because they mark it across the country and say, OK, an average price is. 02:08:53
200 square foot. So it's a slightly different same company, different thing, but it is part of that and we need to bring that into 02:09:02
in line because basically I'm I'm taking money out of your general fund to cover construction cost. 02:09:12
OK. Well, thank you very much for the presentation, Randy. We appreciate it very much. 02:09:24
Thank you. Anything I can do to help let me know. 02:09:30
Surprise, you've been more than supportive since I've been there. I've had supervisor buy a printer, you know that I couldn't get 02:09:35
it and. 02:09:40
I've always felt that that you guys want with passport with what we're doing and I I thank you for your support. Thank you, Andy. 02:09:47
Okay, well, moving on, we're going to go to three call to the public. 02:09:55
Do we have anybody application? No. 02:10:04
We have no one here. Do we have anyone in computer now? How many people do we have on today? 02:10:07
38 How long did they stand up to you? 02:10:15
OK, well that's good. The other day we had like 50 and now we got 38. So it's great to see more people getting involved. When you 02:10:21
don't see them here, you know they are getting involved in what's going on and so OK, there's no call to the public and we move on 02:10:28
to four. At any time during the meeting for Smart ARS 38 Dash 431.02 K, members of the Board of Supervisors and county Manager may 02:10:36
present a brief summary of. 02:10:43
Events, No action may be taken on the information presented. Michael, do you have anything for us? No, Sir, I am good. Thank you. 02:10:50
Supervisor Klein, do you have anything for us? Not a lot, Mr. Chair. Last week we attended the CSA small counties. That was good. 02:10:57
See everybody and next week. 02:11:05
Mind you, I'll be leaving for Washington state for the war, So. And that, that's it. OK. Well, good. Yeah. I, I met with, well, 02:11:13
Jeremy Plain and Michael O'Driscoll and Randy Plummer was there at Roosevelt to try to work together on getting grants and funding 02:11:21
for a, a floating dock for Roosevelt where we're going to. 02:11:29
Jeremy's wanting to take a whole cold there and turn it into a floating dock kind of beach area so there's more recreational 02:11:38
Roosevelt. So that was a good meeting. It's going to be a it's going to be a long reach, but it's something I think we're going to 02:11:44
try to work together and try to get done. 02:11:50
And then I'll attend A-Team project meeting tomorrow. And so anyway, that's all I have. And if there's nothing else, I think very 02:11:57
much I will adjourn today's meeting. 02:12:03