Bookmark list

Loading...
Unable to preview the file.

Transcript

Event transcript
It is August. 00:00:00
18/20/25 It's 10:00. 00:00:02
I'm going to call this meeting to order and. 00:00:05
I've asked. 00:00:08
With our. 00:00:11
Landfills to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance and then after that, Mister Montague. 00:00:13
Lead us in a prayer. 00:00:18
If you would stand. 00:00:19
And to the Republic for which it stands. 00:00:27
Nation under God. 00:00:30
Indivisible with liberty and justice for all. 00:00:32
Dear my father. 00:00:44
We're thankful for this day. 00:00:45
We're thankful that the BLS is able to come together. 00:00:47
Who ask thee to give them your spirit that they listen to thee agenda items that they will bust. 00:00:50
No one is for the county. 00:00:55
And say these things, the new Jesus Christ. Amen. 00:00:57
Thank you. 00:01:00
I think we're going to have a. 00:01:05
For a schedule today, so why don't we just go ahead and. 00:01:06
It started with our. 00:01:09
Regular agenda items. 00:01:11
We have with us this morning the honorable. 00:01:14
Chairwoman of the. 00:01:16
Total, not total. You have a pie. 00:01:18
Apache Nation. 00:01:21
Tanya Lewis and also with her, Susan Montgomery. 00:01:22
And the item is information, discussion and action for the board. 00:01:27
Of supervisors to convey support for the Yavapai Apache Nation water rights settlement. 00:01:31
And authorized the board chairman to sign. 00:01:37
4 letters of support. 00:01:39
To different Congress people. 00:01:41
Eli Crane, Congressman David. 00:01:43
Schwerker, is that how you said? 00:01:52
Yeah, sorry. 00:01:54
Senator Mark Kelly and Senator Ruben Gallego. 00:01:56
So this item. 00:02:00
Is listed as my item I was asked. 00:02:02
To present this and so. 00:02:05
I think. 00:02:07
Chairwoman has a presentation, would you like to come? 00:02:08
Forward and do that and welcome. 00:02:12
Thank you for coming. 00:02:15
Thank you. I appreciate this. 00:02:16
Thank you for this opportunity. I appreciate it. 00:02:27
Chairman Christensen. 00:02:30
Vice Chair Klein. 00:02:31
And supervise my Humphrey. 00:02:33
Because this is very important in our tradition, I'd like to introduce myself and my in my language. 00:02:34
Before I begin my presentation. 00:02:40
She Tanya Lewis Jones. 00:02:44
Denton Schlemmer. 00:02:48
Standing walnut and sling. 00:02:50
She might eat the Louisiana. 00:02:52
She taught a Lyman, Louisiana. 00:02:54
Reddy Valley. Shakira here. 00:02:56
Good morning. My name is Tanya Lewis. I'm the chairwoman for the Ava Pai Apache Nation. 00:02:58
I am the daughter of the late Ethel and Lyman Lewis. 00:03:02
Arizona. 00:03:05
I am of the standing Walnut clan on our mother's side. We follow our. 00:03:06
We follow our mother's side where matriarchal society. 00:03:10
And my father is actually from the San Carlos Apache tribe, my late father. 00:03:13
He's from the Seven Mile District and then my mother is deep rooted in the Verde Valley, which is my clan, the standing Walnut 00:03:18
clan. 00:03:21
That we. 00:03:25
We come from the Verde Valley, so I just wanted to share that with you and thank you for this opportunity to present. 00:03:26
Our water settlement with you. 00:03:32
So to start it out, I have a map here to show everyone the ancestral Yavapai and Apache homeland and neighboring tribes in 00:03:36
Arizona. 00:03:40
So we have been here since time immemorial in the Verde Valley. As you can see, we started out our ancestral. 00:03:45
Territory of 16,000 square miles. 00:03:51
Send a green off to the left is our Yavapai. 00:03:54
Where we broke and then on that. 00:03:57
The right is the. 00:03:58
Apache area that we roam. As you can see that includes this area as well. 00:04:00
So we do have we are related to the San Carlos and the White Mountain. 00:04:05
Apache people as well as the Mescalero. 00:04:08
The. 00:04:11
And the tonsil Apache. 00:04:13
In 1871 to 1875, we were established the Camp Verde Indian Reservation in the Verde Valley. 00:04:16
Which was 900 square miles. That took us down from 16,000 square miles down to 900 square miles. 00:04:22
Of our area and this was done by Executive Order of President Ulysses Grant. 00:04:29
And then in 1875, we were forced removed by military. 00:04:34
To the San Carlos Reservation, where we were held as prisoners of war. 00:04:38
Over 20 years. 00:04:43
So we. 00:04:44
Gracefully started heading home in the early 1900s. 00:04:46
Meaning the Birdie Valley area. 00:04:49
And along the way. 00:04:51
Of course we stopped. This is where our relatives come in. 00:04:52
Some of us stayed here in San Carlos and some of us made the trip home. 00:04:55
And way. 00:04:59
And now today, as we stand now. 00:05:01
Our current reservation lands is 2.86 square miles. 00:05:04
So as you can see, we've gone down and down and down. 00:05:07
I want to share also to the importance that. 00:05:11
The first lands that we received from the Bureau of Indian Affairs. 00:05:14
Was in the lower. 00:05:18
Areas umm. 00:05:20
And we had to. 00:05:21
Beg to have. 00:05:23
The federal government purchased the land in which it started. 00:05:25
Our homeland. 00:05:29
Development. 00:05:30
So we started there and now we are at the 2.86 square miles where we're at today. 00:05:31
Just as a history, we have bought back every single property that we have to date. 00:05:37
So we've worked. 00:05:43
Continuously we've worked hard previous leadership and. 00:05:44
Future leaderships will continue to do that. 00:05:47
Build our homelands is. 00:05:50
We know that. 00:05:52
We do not have enough land for our people. 00:05:53
And we are checkerboarding. 00:05:56
So we are not all in one contiguous area. 00:05:57
We are in. 00:06:00
We are in Clarkdale. 00:06:01
You're in Camp Verde. You're into me. 00:06:02
We are in Rimrock and lower camp. 00:06:04
And there's a Middlebury district as well, so we have 5 areas. 00:06:07
That we. 00:06:10
Have our homelands. 00:06:11
Currently, right now we have we did a historic land. 00:06:14
Exchange with the Forest Service, which was 3200 acres of land. 00:06:18
That was swapped with the Forest Service. 00:06:23
This has been over 30 years in the making. 00:06:25
So it's been wonderful to be able all the leadership before me, whether they're here with us or not. 00:06:28
To see that they had a vision for us to grow. 00:06:33
And it was wonderful. In November of 2024, we signed those documents with the Forest Service, which the land was exchanged with 00:06:36
us. 00:06:40
So out of the thirty 203,088. 00:06:44
Like Acres will go into trust so that has actually been made public notice on August 12th. We have a 30 day waiting period. 00:06:47
With the government. 00:06:55
To see if there's anything. 00:06:57
Any. 00:06:58
Or to that. 00:07:00
To move it into trust. 00:07:03
When we did the land exchange, we did have two public meetings that she had in Chino Valley and we also had in Cap Verde. 00:07:05
So it was able to bring all the. 00:07:11
The community together and if they had questions to clarify an understanding. So right now. 00:07:13
When the lands go into trust, that will take our homelands. 00:07:19
Back to 7.6. 00:07:22
Square miles. 00:07:23
So as you can see with on. 00:07:25
From 16,000 and we're going to set. 00:07:27
So this is just a few maps that you can see the 16,000. 00:07:31
Square miles down to 900 square miles. 00:07:35
And the little red dots is what we are at today. 00:07:39
So we've gone down significantly and this is basically. 00:07:43
On the right. 00:07:48
The information that I had shared and I remember the. 00:07:49
The documents that I have read back then, they called us chiefs and it was Chief Beecher. 00:07:52
That went to DC and asked the Bureau of Indian first. 00:07:57
To buy back the 1st. 00:08:00
First acres that the nation started with when we came back home in 1900s. When we came back home, we had nothing. 00:08:02
They absolutely nothing. 00:08:08
So as I shared, we have 18. 00:08:11
1809 acres in. 00:08:14
Existing reservation, which is the Clarkdale district as you can see on the very top. 00:08:16
As we go, as we travel. 00:08:20
East on the 260 we have the Middle Birdie District. 00:08:22
We have the Camp Verde district, we have the Montezuma district, That's where our casino is. 00:08:26
And then the. 00:08:31
Rimrock District. 00:08:32
Which is off. 00:08:34
Which as you go 17 more. 00:08:35
So these are the lands that are going into trust the green areas. So as you can see, they're contiguous to the Middle Verde 00:08:39
District and the Monas in the district. 00:08:43
So that is. 00:08:48
The large green area. 00:08:49
At the 17. 00:08:51
The corner that goes up, that is our economic development area that we signed an IGA with the town of Camp Verde. 00:08:52
Which is a collaborative work. 00:08:58
That we do with them, so it's been great building our relationships with the local communities, the town of Clarkdale, the town of 00:09:00
Cambridgeshire. 00:09:04
So what is being settled? 00:09:10
This is the Gila River adjudication case. So what it is doing is we have. 00:09:11
Settlement cases in our water rights in the Gila River adjudication. What this does is this gets us out of the healing River 00:09:17
adjudication claims. 00:09:21
That this is what we are asking for. This is our forever for my people. 00:09:25
And uh. 00:09:30
And of course it's. 00:09:31
It's extensive. It's a lot of money. 00:09:32
And this way it provides water certainty. 00:09:35
For the nation and our neighboring communities and. 00:09:38
The overall goal is to protect. 00:09:41
The Verde River, which is the. 00:09:43
Last free flowing river in the state of Arizona. 00:09:44
And our local ground and resources. 00:09:47
So the history, and this is very brief, we actually started. 00:09:52
Engaging in our water settlement in 1972. 00:09:55
So this has been going on for. 00:09:59
Over 50 years. 00:10:02
In 20. 00:10:04
2008. 00:10:05
Initiated a settlement discussion with Salt River Project, the State of Arizona and other parties. 00:10:07
In 2011, Department of Interior appointed as a federal negotiating team. 00:10:12
And we agreed to compromise the water settlement budget. 00:10:17
The challenge was how to find a water resource to meet the long term needs of the nation. 00:10:20
And protecting the local aquifers. 00:10:25
The Verdict River. 00:10:27
And the water resources in our neighboring communities. 00:10:28
In 2023, the. 00:10:31
The Bureau of Reclamation, with the input of the nation and settling parties, all of us together. 00:10:33
In one room, as you can imagine. 00:10:38
How exciting that was. 00:10:40
We conducted of how you planning study. 00:10:41
Which we looked at potential water resources. 00:10:43
To support our settlement. 00:10:47
So we sat in A room. 00:10:49
We agreed on. 00:10:50
Different. There was probably like 6. 00:10:52
Options that were put on the table. 00:10:54
And we went through them. 00:10:56
Vigorously. 00:10:58
And it was very painful. 00:10:59
We had all our hydrologists, we had all our. 00:11:01
Contractors. We had all the experts in the room, not just the nations. 00:11:05
At Salt River Projects, Bureau of Reclamation, this was actually a group team. 00:11:09
And then after doing everything, we all agreed upon the CC Kragen. 00:11:15
Dam reservoir that's that's owned by Reclamation and it's operated by Salt River. 00:11:19
Project So we actually have to import water into the Verde Valley. 00:11:24
Is what we all. 00:11:29
Agreed upon. 00:11:30
To be able to bring water in. 00:11:31
And that is? 00:11:33
The overall goal to keep The Dirty river running. 00:11:35
To protect the aquifer. 00:11:38
And the ground, the groundwater resources. 00:11:40
In the Vertebrae valley. 00:11:43
So as you can see up here, we have the settling parties, which is the nation. 00:11:45
The United States State of Arizona Salt River Project. The town of Camp Verde. The town of Clarkdale, City of Cottonwood. 00:11:49
And the Central Arizona Water Conservation District, which is the CEP. 00:11:56
So that's all of us that have all worked together. 00:12:00
Diligently. Umm. 00:12:03
And working. 00:12:05
All of us together, our hydrologists, our scientists. 00:12:06
Figuring out topography, everything. 00:12:11
That we worked on together. 00:12:13
So this is a 60 mile pipeline. As you can see on the map, there's a red line from the little turquoise area all the way down into 00:12:16
Camp Verde into the Middle Birdie district. 00:12:20
So it is. 00:12:26
All of this it will cross 4 service lands on existing roads and right of ways. 00:12:27
And when the pipeline comes down, the nation will build a new. 00:12:32
New water treatment plant. 00:12:37
Which is over where our it's on the I-17. 00:12:39
There's a Chevron right across the street from the casino. 00:12:42
There's a land that's right above it. It's black. 00:12:46
And that's where we would cook. 00:12:48
In the pipeline. 00:12:50
For the wastewater treatment plant. 00:12:52
And then they will also provide importer water service for our current and future growth of our reservation because this 00:12:54
settlement is. 00:12:57
This is it. This is what we need for our people. 00:13:01
For Homeland. 00:13:04
The congressional legislation includes an option to upsize the pipeline to deliver up to 1600 acre feet of Kragen water to benefit 00:13:06
the local communities. So in the agreements that we have, it states that they have five years from the date of the settlement. 00:13:13
Signage that if they would like. 00:13:20
To hook into this opportunity for water. 00:13:22
As we share, we are good neighbors. 00:13:25
And we're a good stewards to the land and water and by being a good neighbor. 00:13:28
It's being able to to work with our local communities as well. 00:13:32
And then what are the major benefits of the settlement? 00:13:39
As you can see, it protects the surface water in the Verde River. It's culturally important to the nation. 00:13:41
Serves an economic driver for the entire Verde Valley through tourism. 00:13:46
Provides a key water resource to neighboring and downstream communities. 00:13:50
Keeping in mind that there is a. 00:13:54
There's the biomass scenic downstream from us where his sister tried to stop. 00:13:57
River Hula. Indian community. 00:14:02
Community. Their water settlement is based off the Verde River. 00:14:04
Our relatives down South further. 00:14:07
The Fort McGowan Nation is also tied to the Verde River in their water settlements. 00:14:09
So that's why we're always very conscious of what the decisions we make. 00:14:14
Who is gonna affect and how it's gonna? 00:14:17
Effects and also protecting the animals in. 00:14:19
That are downstream from us as well. 00:14:22
We project the limited ground. 00:14:25
Groundwater supply in the Verde Valley by limiting future groundwater pumping by the nation. Camp Birdie, Clarkdale and Cottonwood 00:14:26
supporting smart growth. 00:14:31
So right now. 00:14:35
We have. 00:14:37
When we build our homes. 00:14:38
In our communities, you can tell which homes have been there for a while because they have longs and things like that. 00:14:40
Going forward in our community and to me, we actually do 0 escaping. 00:14:45
So if we're asking our neighbors to be responsible. 00:14:50
We need to be responsible. 00:14:53
As well. So we work together on that. 00:14:54
And we provide an option for neighboring communities to also use their Craig and imported water as I shared they have. 00:14:57
Five year option whether? 00:15:03
They like to opt in or opt out. 00:15:05
So with the in stream flow. 00:15:10
It was very. 00:15:12
Important to the nation. 00:15:13
And my late uncle, Vincent Randall. 00:15:16
He has passed. 00:15:19
It was in. 00:15:22
He passed in December of 2023. 00:15:24
And it's been very difficult. He was a man of integrity. 00:15:26
He was my mentor, he was my school. 00:15:30
Orders and he always told me. 00:15:32
That him and other elders that had passed on. 00:15:35
It is important to preserve the in stream flow. 00:15:39
For our cultural purposes. 00:15:42
It is important to never forget who we are aware without. 00:15:45
It is always important to protect them. 00:15:48
So everyone. 00:15:51
Who has come before me in leadership? 00:15:53
We have been told that that. 00:15:55
And it's been understood by us and even those coming forward. 00:15:56
We this is very important to the nation to recognize. 00:16:00
Our culture and significance ties to the river. 00:16:04
So the. 00:16:08
The settlement calls for a minimum in stream flow to be maintained at the Verde River at the Middlebury district on the 00:16:09
reservation. 00:16:13
It had a healthy ecosystem of flowing. 00:16:16
Verde River supports plants and animals apart. 00:16:19
Cultural, traditional and religious importance to the nation. 00:16:21
A flowing river that brings wildlife, recreation and. 00:16:25
And economic opportunity for the entire Verde Valley. 00:16:28
Just finished in the entire. 00:16:31
So these are. 00:16:35
Photos This is my niece. 00:16:36
Dance her ceremony Naias. 00:16:38
This is our coming of age ceremony for women. These are done. 00:16:41
Down by the river and our ceremonial grounds. 00:16:44
The river plays a significant importance to this as the. 00:16:47
As river provides the life. 00:16:50
To all of us. 00:16:52
All the all the Goa is her home, which is the middle photo that they're building. 00:16:54
Akawa is what we learn. 00:16:59
To do to build. 00:17:02
When we build shelter, the goat is not only just a. 00:17:03
That's our hub, that's our sanctuary, that's where we feel safe. 00:17:06
That's. 00:17:10
That's where we gather. 00:17:11
This is where we raise our children. 00:17:12
This is where we. 00:17:14
We discipline our children. This is where we build our family. 00:17:15
So it's very important. And the girl. 00:17:18
Builds this on her own and these are taken by the Cottonwood trees along the river. 00:17:20
So when we. 00:17:26
We take the Cottonwood trees along the river. We pray with Han Din, which is the cattail, the yellow powder, the yellow pawn. 00:17:27
How many time would you take something from the earth? 00:17:34
We pray. 00:17:37
And bless the ground. 00:17:38
That it's there for the next person who needs it. 00:17:40
That is with our medicines. 00:17:42
That is with the. 00:17:44
The trees, that is, for the animals. 00:17:44
That is everything that we do. 00:17:47
That is what it means to be a good stewards of the land. 00:17:49
With these, not only do we use the Cottonwood trees along the river, we also use the Willow trees and the cat. 00:17:52
That we use in our ceremonies. What are the the burden basketwood? 00:17:58
Terrace Christensen has at his desk right now. 00:18:04
As made out of catclaw and Willow and the buckskin. 00:18:06
From the male deer. 00:18:09
That we use that. 00:18:10
And we? 00:18:12
We use that together. 00:18:14
And we use that for ceremony and then we use that to teach our young, our young lady, our young woman. 00:18:15
The importance of life. 00:18:20
Because this is a four day of strenuous. 00:18:21
Fair faith integrity. 00:18:23
Strength in any way possible because we all know as adults and as we get older. 00:18:27
Life is hard. 00:18:32
Life is difficult, but this teaches her. 00:18:33
How to deal with these? 00:18:35
In a positive manner, In a faithful manner. 00:18:37
In which she. 00:18:40
She learns this. 00:18:41
And with the gone, when we say our prayers and as we dance. 00:18:44
That they be heard. 00:18:47
And that they go up. 00:18:49
They go up to the Creator. 00:18:50
And he answers our prayers. 00:18:52
And that's what the ceremony is so important. 00:18:55
And that's why we it it. 00:18:58
This is what ties us to the industry and flow of the Verde River. 00:19:00
This is what brings to our attention that we need to take care of it, because if it takes care of. 00:19:03
If we take care of it, it takes care of us. 00:19:08
We have. 00:19:10
Wild spinach that grows we have the onions we have. 00:19:11
Of course, the natural habitat as well that lives along the river. 00:19:14
We need to protect them as well. 00:19:17
And then the. 00:19:19
Just to make sure that. 00:19:20
It's taken care of. 00:19:22
For generations to come, today our. 00:19:23
Our children, our grandchildren, those yet to be here with us. 00:19:25
This is a quote from our late. 00:19:31
Elder Mary Sign as long as the river flows. 00:19:33
Life will be good. 00:19:36
Because we take care of it, it takes care of us. 00:19:39
And I strongly believe that. 00:19:41
I believe in everything that we do. I believe in our cultural, our culture and our traditions. 00:19:44
I want to share with you that I did not grow up with my culture or my language. My mother spoke Alva Clive fluently and she was 00:19:49
raised in the church. 00:19:52
And we are. We are raised in the Baptist Church. 00:19:56
My father was a traditional man, an Apache man who spoke the language, but my mother chose us to raise us. I call it modern. 00:19:59
So we were raised in the church. 00:20:06
Were raised in the Baptist Church. 00:20:08
Were still in that church today. 00:20:10
But we also uphold our culture and traditions as well. 00:20:12
And my family. 00:20:15
And because I was not raised in that. 00:20:16
I had to send my children up to White Mountain to our family where my son. 00:20:19
Took on the tradition. 00:20:23
When there's not much more I can do. When our little boys act out. 00:20:25
I sent him up there and he came back to the man he is today. He's 32 years old and a successful entrepreneur. 00:20:29
My daughter the same way I went through ceremony. These are things I didn't get to have, but I had to send them to relatives to 00:20:34
learn. 00:20:37
My daughter went through Nyans. 00:20:41
It was beautiful, it was wonderful. It goes to show how strong she was. Her godmother is always there for her, to protect her and 00:20:43
guide her in her godfather. 00:20:47
It's been wonderful to see all our young women go through us, go through this. 00:20:52
My daughter is now at. 00:20:56
And a huge is 21 and she's starting her. 00:20:57
Dental hygiene career. 00:21:00
So it's very exciting to see how. 00:21:02
How we all know how the blessings come to us. 00:21:05
To our families, to our people. 00:21:08
To our community. 00:21:09
And to protect it, and to always. 00:21:11
Only speak for it and believe in it. 00:21:14
So this water settlement is a win win across the board we have. 00:21:16
Full support from all our settlement parties. 00:21:21
We the only one that needs to sign their water settlement is the city. 00:21:24
Hotmail. They've had some. 00:21:27
They have they have new council, they have a new mayor, they have new leadership. 00:21:29
And prior to that, they had, they had a little. 00:21:33
They had a moment in put in their government, but I'm glad to see that they're doing. 00:21:36
They're doing well. 00:21:40
I do work with all the local communities. It's been great. It's been wonderful to be able to sit with your Christianson. 00:21:42
And spend time with him. 00:21:48
And to come up to paste in and do that, and it's an honor. 00:21:49
And very humbling to be to stand here before the Hewlett County Board of Supervisors. 00:21:54
To share this with you and seek your support of the nations Water Song. 00:21:59
Thank you. We're here. 00:22:04
I think the chairwoman and we're going to have some questions, I'm sure so. 00:22:05
I did. 00:22:09
Want to let you refer to this. This was given to me by. 00:22:11
Tono Apaches and which are your. 00:22:16
Relatives, your ancestors, etc. 00:22:20
And the past chairman? 00:22:23
Jerry Nicholas. 00:22:25
Gave that to me and so. 00:22:27
I didn't bring it to be a display, but since you mentioned it, I. 00:22:30
And it's and. 00:22:33
The way it's made and everything has significance. 00:22:34
But I went out, you know, because the Apache seemed to come from all around and they liked to pick the acorns from the. 00:22:37
Oaks and. 00:22:43
That's kind of a thing if you don't understand. 00:22:44
The Emory oaks and the struggles that they're going through with those trees now to make sure that they survive. 00:22:47
So we've got a few on the property in. 00:22:54
Basin and at my home and so I decided, why don't I just fill them up with acorns right there? 00:22:56
And uh. 00:23:03
So several hours later. 00:23:04
I gotta say. 00:23:07
I finally got it. 00:23:08
And so I gave that to you. 00:23:10
To make your traditional. 00:23:12
Meals and stuff out of it, but. 00:23:14
That's a lot of hard work and we have people come from. 00:23:16
The White Mountains and everything. 00:23:18
Intubation to do that. 00:23:20
So thanks for the presentation. 00:23:22
And let's open it up. 00:23:25
And I've learned so much from you so. 00:23:27
The chairwoman and I have have. 00:23:30
Lengthy discussions regarding Fossil Creek, which is another matter. 00:23:32
Completely. We're not talking about that today. 00:23:36
And so I've learned a lot about. 00:23:39
Your culture and the past and everything so. 00:23:41
Umm. The presentation today. Just kind of. 00:23:44
Touches the edges. 00:23:47
Some of that so. 00:23:48
Supervisor. 00:23:50
Humphrey. 00:23:51
Thank you very much for being here today. 00:23:53
I appreciate your presentation. 00:23:57
And with your presentation, I have no question. 00:23:59
You answered a lot of questions and a lot of history and. 00:24:03
What you're trying to do so? 00:24:07
Have no question. 00:24:09
Thank you. Thank you, supervisor. Supervisor. 00:24:11
Chairwoman Lewis, thank you for being here. 00:24:14
It's really good to see you and to meet you. 00:24:17
I do have questions. 00:24:22
So start with the. 00:24:24
The idea of. 00:24:28
Of tapping into CC. 00:24:31
With another pipeline. 00:24:33
And as you both know, CC Kragen is real vital. 00:24:35
County. 00:24:39
It supplies paste in. It supplies a tunnel, Apaches and face in and. 00:24:41
And that is most of our water. 00:24:46
Is right there coming out CC Kragen. 00:24:49
Cissy Craig's not very big. 00:24:52
And so. 00:24:56
I'm hesitant to put another straw into CC again. 00:25:01
And I respect all your traditions, as you know I have. 00:25:06
Three reservations on me. 00:25:10
San Carlos. 00:25:13
White Mountain Apaches and the Tunnel Apache so I'm very familiar with. 00:25:14
Both familiar as I can be. 00:25:18
With the. 00:25:20
Traditional culture and. 00:25:22
Traditions and things so. 00:25:25
But I do respect all that. 00:25:27
But I have some grave concerns over the water. 00:25:28
In the supply of the water. 00:25:32
Obviously. 00:25:34
If you go through this settlement, and you very well may. 00:25:35
And there's going to be a trade off. 00:25:39
SRP is gonna. 00:25:41
Give you water basically out of CC. 00:25:44
My question is, is what's SRP going to do with the water that you are now taking out of the Verde Valley? Where is it going to go? 00:25:48
They're just going to keep going down. 00:25:56
Stream or. 00:25:58
Or how is that designed and what's? 00:26:00
So this is Sue Montgomery, our water attorney, in. 00:26:05
Thank you for asking that questions. 00:26:09
Oh yeah. 00:26:10
And a longtime resident of Payson and actually watched the pipeline being built over Washington Park Supervisor. 00:26:11
First, let me address that. 00:26:18
The concern about straws because. 00:26:19
It's a natural concern. 00:26:21
Understand when CC Kragen, which we all call Blue Bridge when we went back up, right? 00:26:24
Hanging out and. 00:26:29
Kayaking and doing all the fun stuff up there. 00:26:30
That reservoir was. 00:26:33
Operated by felt such. 00:26:35
When the reservoir was turned over. 00:26:37
To Reclamation to operate and be operated by Salt River Project. 00:26:39
That was in the Arizona Water Settlements Act of 2000. 00:26:44
For in that. 00:26:47
There was an allocation. I wish I had a slide but. 00:26:48
If you imagine it like a. 00:26:51
Like a glass of wire. 00:26:53
Or a bucket of water. 00:26:54
Whatever, there was an allocation by Congress. 00:26:56
To northern Gila County communities. 00:26:59
That allocation. 00:27:01
Includes the pace and allocation. 00:27:03
That cannot be touched. 00:27:05
As a result. 00:27:06
Of the Avipai settlement. 00:27:07
Because the Yavapai settlement. 00:27:08
Is out of. 00:27:10
The separate. 00:27:11
Part of the reservoir, in other words. 00:27:12
There is a set allocation for Payson. 00:27:14
And that's part of the reservoir. 00:27:16
There is an additional side of the reservoir. 00:27:18
Mount of the reservoir. 00:27:20
That is operated by Salt River Project in the United States is going to acquire a piece of that Salt River Project water. 00:27:22
Is not out of the northern Hill County bucket. 00:27:28
And it is that piece that will be. 00:27:31
Basically brought through the pipeline. 00:27:33
And then I'll answer your second question. 00:27:35
Brought through the pipeline. 00:27:37
It will be delivered to a surface water drinking plant. 00:27:38
And that means it'll be treated. 00:27:41
And used for portable. 00:27:43
Uses that also allows. 00:27:44
The allocation for Kragen. 00:27:47
That the Yavapai has under the settlement has to be used on their reservation. 00:27:50
And they will use it for. 00:27:54
Potable water purposes. They'll drink it. 00:27:55
What that does is it. 00:27:58
It eliminates, of course, all the conflict. 00:28:00
About the tribe's claims. 00:28:03
And it protects sources in the Verde because they're not going to be pumping. 00:28:05
That future amount of water that they need right by this. 00:28:08
So it's going to be. 00:28:11
Consume via drinking, but it'll also then go. 00:28:12
To a wastewater treatment plant which we are going to reclaim the water and use it on our farming fields. 00:28:15
So what kind of guarantees? 00:28:20
I would assume that. 00:28:23
That northern Gila County with that settlement originally in 04. 00:28:24
Yeah, his first in time and 1st in right. 00:28:28
Well, it's a little different because you're and I'm not trying to be sneaky. 00:28:31
But it's it's not. 00:28:37
1st in time and 1st in right is sort of that idea of water rights for beneficial use. This is about how much water goes into the 00:28:38
reservoir. 00:28:41
Right when it goes into the reservoir. 00:28:45
That allocation to northern Hill County, including Payson. 00:28:47
Is not in any way impacted by the other allocation. 00:28:50
For the apple pie Apache. 00:28:53
And on Salt River Project. 00:28:55
Has worked closely with the town of Payson. 00:28:57
And we understand we're getting actually under letter of support from the town of Payson. I have not seen it yet. 00:28:59
So that's on Salt River Project purposes I'm. 00:29:04
I'm not working on that piece of it. 00:29:07
But we do not see an impact. SRP does not see an impact. 00:29:10
And I'd be happy to connect you directly with Salt River Project and they could actually. 00:29:13
Give you that graphic I'm. 00:29:17
Visualizing my head, which isn't helping you at all. 00:29:18
And walk you through it if that would be helpful. 00:29:21
I don't don't worry about that. I have contact with SRP. 00:29:24
I see it to trade off. 00:29:28
And, and like I said, I totally respect your your traditions and what you're thinking on the river. 00:29:29
I really like that. 00:29:34
But but you gotta understand my concern. 00:29:36
My concern is for Gila County. 00:29:38
Absolutely. 00:29:40
And that's first and foremost. 00:29:41
And and also when I think about a reservoir. 00:29:43
Green Lake Reservoir, if I say Blue Ridge Reservoir anymore, nobody knows. I know exactly what you're saying, so I can't call it 00:29:47
CC. So it's CC Craig and usually, but. 00:29:51
But I think of a reservoir like we have. 00:29:56
This much? 00:29:59
When I think of the Verde River, Salt River, any of these rivers. 00:30:01
You have. 00:30:06
This much? 00:30:07
Watershed. 00:30:08
And an ability to. 00:30:09
To collect water. 00:30:11
So my worry, and I think I'm legit in this, especially today because we all see our weather patterns have changed. 00:30:14
Water is a huge, huge issue. 00:30:21
Right now. 00:30:23
And what does that mean for us going forward? 00:30:24
You know, town of Pacin, the ton of Apaches. 00:30:29
I know they have all got ideas of some growth and bringing more people in. 00:30:33
Patients kind of landlocked. 00:30:38
But the tribe there's looking at? 00:30:40
Acquiring some land, additional land. So there's some growth being thought about around. 00:30:42
As well. 00:30:47
With basically any community that's just saying Arizona. 00:30:49
So when I think about that and I think about, OK, we have this. 00:30:52
Water reservoir. 00:30:56
How much? 00:30:58
In it supply. 00:30:59
Where? Where's the limits to what it can do? 00:31:02
Without running somebody really short. 00:31:06
Yeah, and Supervisor I the reservoir itself is subject to. 00:31:09
Precipitation and implementation. 00:31:13
Particular and we've done a lot of modeling, technical modeling and particular snowmelt. 00:31:15
And and some other things. So the reservoir is going to produce. What it produces is a very productive reservoir, as you know. 00:31:19
But it will produce what it produces in the At the end of the day, though, the allocation for the town of Payson is secured. 00:31:27
And the volume the patient is entitled to. 00:31:34
Which will be coming through that pipeline? 00:31:36
Will be achieved to the extent. 00:31:38
The water is in the reservoir. 00:31:41
You know, if the water isn't in the reservoir, the water is not in the reservoir. 00:31:42
Like, you know, that's a tough situation. We had that this year, we had this couple other years. 00:31:45
Back with a lack of snow belt. 00:31:50
And that's just a big. 00:31:52
Productive so. 00:31:53
So my hats off to you for having those meetings over water because I understand what you're saying. That's like watching paint 00:31:55
dry. 00:31:57
Hey, but you know. 00:32:00
So, uh. 00:32:03
But, but let me ask you, because you're the lawyer, one of the lawyers. 00:32:04
Yes, I am. 00:32:08
Water gets low. 00:32:09
Who gets turned off 1st? 00:32:10
That's a really good question, but I don't think it works that way. 00:32:14
If the water gets well, let me just say. 00:32:17
If the water gets low on May 1st, patient is going to get. 00:32:19
The allocation they're entitled to from their side. 00:32:22
There's not. 00:32:25
Turning off relative one or the other. 00:32:27
So are you telling me there's a way in CC Kragen that that's divided, I mean? 00:32:30
Physically, umm. 00:32:34
It's ultimately going to be. 00:32:36
The allocation that comes out of the side of the road with. 00:32:38
Part of the reservoir. 00:32:40
That is allocated to the northern Gila County communities. I am not the engineer. So now now I'm getting outside my water world 00:32:42
and into engineering land, which I can't I. 00:32:46
Rather not try to do. 00:32:51
Again, happy to connect you and give you. I could have SRP give you this in granular detail. 00:32:53
With their engineers and they would do a much better job than me. 00:32:58
Yeah, well. 00:33:01
I do have some issues with it. 00:33:04
I really do. 00:33:06
And it's a tough position to be in because it's not that I don't want to support the Yavapai Apache, that's not the case. 00:33:07
But first and foremost, I have to support Gila County. 00:33:14
And so. 00:33:17
That's my concern. 00:33:18
And especially in today's time, we haven't seen the smoke packs. 00:33:20
For a long time. 00:33:24
And that's in the issue for everything. 00:33:25
I get it. I understand that. 00:33:28
But. 00:33:30
So thank you very much and thank you so much for coming today. 00:33:32
And it's nice to meet you. 00:33:36
Thank you, supervisor. And so Susan, don't get too comfortable. 00:33:40
Oh, OK. 00:33:43
Miss Montgomery. 00:33:46
So. 00:33:47
I'm still not clear. 00:33:50
Think I understand. 00:33:51
What Superfund the client is trying to ask? 00:33:52
I'm going to try and ask it in a different way. 00:33:55
OK. So this is CC Craig. And sometimes it's full, sometimes it's half full. 00:33:57
And Payson gets 3000 acre feet. 00:34:03
1600 acre feet to the yawn. 00:34:07
And so. 00:34:09
I don't know who else. 00:34:11
Brings water out of that reservoir. 00:34:12
So as the reservoir gets more and more depleted. 00:34:15
And the allocations become. 00:34:18
Percentage. 00:34:20
Of the acre feet. 00:34:21
Listen, is that correct? 00:34:23
That is correct relative to the allocation for patients and that is true also free alpha patch. So if the water doesn't exist for 00:34:25
Payson, they're not going to pull out 3000 acre feet. 00:34:29
SRP is going to say your allocation right now is 1500 and they wouldn't do it anyways. 00:34:34
Like as we sit right now. 00:34:40
If the allocation. 00:34:42
If the water is not there, a patient is only gonna get. 00:34:43
The percentage they're gonna get. 00:34:46
And I can't speak to Payson's agreement. 00:34:47
It is a separate agreement, but that allocation comes out of the Northern Territory. 00:34:49
OK, so then the second. 00:34:53
Part of that question is the 1600 acre feet. 00:34:55
Was that previously allocated to another? 00:34:58
Entity. 00:35:03
And was it being used? 00:35:04
No. So you have to understand the percentage that goes to northern HeLa County is a, is a. 00:35:07
Fractionary part. 00:35:12
Of the overall reservoir. 00:35:13
The remaining water in that reservoir is SRP's allocation. 00:35:14
For it to do with what it wishes OK and. 00:35:18
To the point of. 00:35:21
Supervisor Klein. 00:35:22
Right now. 00:35:23
You know what they do with it if they don't ever you they drain it, they run it down East Verde and they put it in their own 00:35:25
reservoir. 00:35:27
Areas and that doesn't help. 00:35:30
Field County either. 00:35:32
Right. Umm. 00:35:33
That's that's the way the 2004. 00:35:35
Allocation in the transferred SRP. 00:35:38
Works, so there is a significant amount. 00:35:41
In the reservoir right now, that is. 00:35:43
Sits with SRP and has not been allocated to others. 00:35:45
OK. And that is a substantial part of the? 00:35:48
Very good and just and I'll get it. 00:35:51
Hang on the. 00:35:54
So yes, and occasionally they do run the water down the east birdie. 00:35:55
It ends up in the hurry. 00:36:00
And it never settles in. 00:36:02
Eva, Tony. 00:36:05
I'm just. 00:36:08
Trying to clarify. 00:36:10
The possible? 00:36:11
Impact umm. 00:36:13
Of the 1600 additional acre. 00:36:14
To the allocation to Payson. 00:36:18
Do you know how many acre feet are available? 00:36:20
At any given time. 00:36:22
To be pulled out of CC credit I would have to pull that number up. I don't want to say it cuz I don't want to be wrong but I will 00:36:24
tell you what. 00:36:27
When you're saying the 1600, are you referring to the additional allocation of the allocation for yellow? 00:36:31
The the Yavapai. 00:36:36
Even the allocation for the Yavapai Apache and if there were. 00:36:38
The decision by local communities in the Verde Valley. 00:36:42
To acquire that water. 00:36:45
Again, uh. 00:36:46
That is not coming out. 00:36:47
Of the portion and the per share share. 00:36:49
That goes to pacing that is from the larger overall application and I can follow up and give. 00:36:51
Miss Wilds the correct number for. 00:36:56
Patient I did not bring my laptop in so but I have my car so I will send it over OK. 00:36:59
All right. Yeah, we'll just try to understand. So supervisor client. 00:37:04
When you brought up the fact that turning some of that water down these birdies and going down SRP so. 00:37:07
When you guys make this deal with SRP? 00:37:12
The settlement is done. 00:37:16
Is SRP gonna give up on taking so much water out of CC Kragen to send it to Phoenix or how's that gonna work? 00:37:18
Well understand what will happen is the United States will a. 00:37:25
Wire on behalf of the apple pie. 00:37:29
A portion. 00:37:31
A small portion. 00:37:33
Of SRPS. 00:37:35
Allocation. 00:37:36
On that side of the Ledger of the reservoir. 00:37:37
Perhaps in the distance if their water is short, it might limit some of that water going through E 30, but it's. 00:37:40
It's just dependent on each year and I can't really say. 00:37:46
I really wishing you'd tell me that was the case and they're not going to send so much down there. 00:37:49
I'll just tell you the heartache I have with it. 00:37:53
That valley continues to grow and it's going to be on the expense of all of us, including Yavapai Apache. 00:37:56
That's, that's the, that's one of the big heartaches I have. 00:38:02
You know, like. 00:38:06
And I don't see. 00:38:08
The lower end of Arizona. 00:38:11
Given in to anything. 00:38:13
They just reach out broader and broader and. 00:38:15
More supplies. 00:38:17
You're you are right. And I will tell you I've been a longtime member of the Arizona Water Finance Authority. 00:38:19
Right Infrastructure Authority of Arizona. 00:38:24
And in that role, I'm no longer on the role, but in that role. 00:38:27
I I represented Halo County. 00:38:30
And fought like. 00:38:32
Heck, to ensure. 00:38:33
That Gila County got a conservation dollars. 00:38:35
That are small irrigation folks. 00:38:38
And our small communities. 00:38:40
Receive the benefit. 00:38:42
Equal to. 00:38:44
What they get down in Phoenix. 00:38:45
And it was a fight like heck because they are growing and their tentacles are everywhere. 00:38:47
That's why this settlement is so important for the Verde Valley, though. 00:38:51
And we would say. 00:38:54
Important for the state as a whole. 00:38:56
Because what it's doing is. It is. 00:38:57
Benefiting rural communities, it is benefiting. 00:38:59
Not only Yavapai Apache. 00:39:02
But uh. 00:39:04
Camp Birdie, Clarkdale, Cottonwood and it's providing them all. 00:39:05
Potential alternative source? 00:39:08
That can help. 00:39:10
Protect their resources in the long term. 00:39:11
That that's a, that's a win. 00:39:14
And fighting SRP, as you may imagine, is a. 00:39:15
I have been fighting them. 00:39:18
Frankly, don't quote me on this even though the public. 00:39:19
I've been fighting them for over 25 years and achieving a settlement with them. 00:39:21
With the state of Arizona. 00:39:27
With CAP and with our local communities. 00:39:28
Is a benefit to the state because it resolves a huge piece of litigation. 00:39:31
And uncertainty. 00:39:35
For part of rural Arizona. 00:39:36
And I stand by that, Sir. 00:39:38
Really an amazing part of this settlement. 00:39:40
And I understand what you're saying and and I understand the benefits and the support this would bring to that. 00:39:42
Birdie Valley down there. 00:39:49
And in the pluses it'll bring. 00:39:50
But what pluses does it give to Gila County? 00:39:54
I don't think it hurts. 00:39:56
I don't know if it gives her plus except for that as a statewide matter it helps to resolve issues. 00:39:58
And I think that's a matter. 00:40:03
The benefits of communities. 00:40:05
At all counties. 00:40:06
Well, you, you have a way of putting this in the hot seat, you know that? 00:40:11
You know so. 00:40:15
I, I I I'm back to what I said a while ago. 00:40:18
I totally admire what you're doing. 00:40:21
And you're pushing for your people. 00:40:23
And everything over there. I really, really do. 00:40:26
I was. 00:40:30
Yeah, and I understand a lot of what you're saying. SRP is a pretty big machine. 00:40:31
And it's really big and if there was a better trade off that I could see. 00:40:38
Like, you know. 00:40:43
Water goes to Yavapai Apaches. Water goes Tunnel Apaches and Payson. 00:40:44
And we don't turn the sticket on very much on the East Verde. 00:40:49
That that would be a plus. 00:40:54
But I don't. 00:40:56
Trust that to be the case. 00:40:58
I really don't. 00:41:00
But we want you to be assured. 00:41:01
Supervisor. 00:41:03
And so if I need to do anything to facilitate a granular conversation, so you have that level of assurance, certainly that's 00:41:04
something we can facilitate and make happen. 00:41:08
Because I stand here today, I don't think it's harms. 00:41:13
I, I agree with that because thank you supervisor client for bringing that up because. 00:41:17
Those are questions. 00:41:21
We had to. 00:41:22
Because we, we don't we this, we do not want this water set on there. 00:41:23
To do any harm. 00:41:27
To anyone, no one. 00:41:28
We did. That's the whole thing. 00:41:30
When we look at. 00:41:32
Going to do this, this and this. 00:41:33
You don't want anybody to be harmed. 00:41:35
In any way? 00:41:37
And so that's. 00:41:38
I think that graph that Sue is referring to. 00:41:40
I think that'll help. 00:41:43
Because. 00:41:44
I know for me, I was trying to wrap my head around it for a minute and I was like, well, this doesn't make sense. Like. 00:41:45
You need to show me again and. 00:41:50
I would look at it and read it and then they will go over it with me. I thought I had to go through it. 00:41:52
It wasn't just like a one time thing. 00:41:57
But then it made sense and I'm like OK, as long as there's no. 00:41:59
Harm than to anyone. 00:42:02
That's the main thing. 00:42:04
And of course with the reservoir it's all based off. 00:42:05
The the rainfall, the precipitation, we've done studies on those that we've done years out and we just. 00:42:09
We looked at every possible angle. 00:42:16
For everybody across the board. 00:42:18
And that's that's why I said there were six options on the table. 00:42:20
And we're going into different subtitles. We're like, I don't know how, we're just. 00:42:23
We're losing our minds, so we just said we're. 00:42:28
These are the options and this is the best box. 00:42:30
And that's all of us sitting in the room. 00:42:33
All of us at the table with all the attorneys, all the. 00:42:35
The hydrologist on. 00:42:39
People doing topography, everybody that did everything. 00:42:40
And attorneys. 00:42:43
The lobby, like everybody in the room and that's. 00:42:45
All of us from. 00:42:48
Interior from. 00:42:49
State of Arizona. 00:42:51
CAP and. 00:42:52
SRP the towns. 00:42:54
Like everybody in the room. 00:42:57
That's why I said it was. 00:42:59
Quite the quite the action with all of us. 00:43:02
Sometimes you do, you just have to walk out of the room for a minute. 00:43:05
Like before you. 00:43:07
Pull somebody across the table, but I mean. 00:43:09
That's what negotiations are. 00:43:11
That's what we do. It's a give and take. 00:43:12
And our Tribal Council is fully aware of the steps taken all the way through. 00:43:15
That are give and takes to the nation to have to do as well. 00:43:18
They were difficult ones. 00:43:22
But we believe, we believe in the settlement. 00:43:25
Thank you for that question. 00:43:27
And I do respect your concern. 00:43:29
I do and I know that. 00:43:31
It's important with the role that you have. 00:43:33
We have similar roles. 00:43:36
Our responsibilities to make sure that people are OK. 00:43:37
So one thing and I'm a firm believer of is especially when it comes to rural areas and you are a rural area as well. 00:43:43
You know we can't do anything alone. 00:43:50
Right. And so? 00:43:53
Please keep that in mind. 00:43:57
I believe that I'm a firm believer in that. I sat with them at the table as many at times and I say I always admire the expertise 00:44:01
in the room, the knowledge. 00:44:04
They would be like, oh, this happened in this case or this happened in that case, and you need to be mindful of this. 00:44:09
ABC. 00:44:15
And I said we can't do this. 00:44:17
We need everybody. 00:44:19
We do this together. 00:44:20
That's how it's been all the way through, it said. We have to do this together. 00:44:22
You are right, you're correct. 00:44:25
My executive assistant right there, Kathy Melvin, and she'll get your. 00:44:29
Your number and stuff anymore? 00:44:33
Because I will be calling you to have that meeting with SRP. 00:44:35